This essay The Lack of Comprehensive Speech in Catch 22 has a total of 804 words and 4 pages.
The Lack of Comprehensive Speech in Catch 22
Most of what we really say has no meaning. This concept is perfectly
supported in Catch 22, by Joseph Heller. Almost every character and scene in
the novel contain dialogues where the people speak aimlessly and have no
explanation for why they are talking. Colonel Cargill addresses his men by
saying, ÒYou\'re American officers. The officers of no other army in the world
can make that statement. Think about it."(29) Even though the remark is true,
it has no meaning. These type of random statements and dialogues occur
throughout the whole book.
Another situation when two people speak without making any sense is when
Clevinger is being questioned.
"I didn\'t say you couldn\'t punish me," said Clevinger.
"When?" asked the colonel.
"When what, sir?"
"Now you\'re asking me questions again."
"I am sorry, sir. I\'m afraid I don\'t understand your
Later in the interrogation, the colonel is so twisted in his conversation that
he no longer wants to know when Clevinger said that he could not be punished.
He now wants to know when Clevinger did not say that he could not be punished.
Clevinger quickly rebuts and states, "I always didn\'t say you couldn\'t punish me,
sir." Finally, the colonel is satisfied with that answer even though
Clevinger\'s statement did not answer the question and has no meaning.
Major Major often spoke with a lack of meaning. He simply did not make
sense. For instance, he told Sergeant Towser, his assistant, "From now on, I
don\'t want anyone to come in to see me while I\'m here."(102) According to this
statement, when would anyone be able to see him if they could only go to his
office when Major Major was out? When Appleby once went to see Major Major, he
started to talk to Sergeant Towser.
"About how long will I have to wait before I can go in to
see the major?"
"Just until he goes to lunch," Sergeant Towser replied.
"Then you can go right in."
"But he wont be there then. Will he?"
"No, sir. Major Major won\'t be back in his office until
The famous catch 22, stated that one can only be grounded from flying if
he/she is crazy. However, if one asks to be grounded, he/she is no longer
considered to be crazy and the soldier would have to fly more missions.
Yossarian always fell into this trap. He wants to be grounded but he couldn\'t
be considered insane because he keeps on asking to be grounded. Dr. Stubbs
comments about Yossarian\'s catch 22. He says, "That crazy bastard may be the
only sane one left." This obviously represents a complete contradiction.
When Orr explains why he walks around as a kid with crab apples in his
cheeks, he too speaks with no meaning. His explanation was, "because they\'ve
got a better shape than horse chestnuts."(23) But, why put anything in your
cheeks? This conversation is so ambiguous and had such little meaning that the
answer to "why?" is never explained to Yossarian.
For no reason, Yossarian and Orr convince Appleby that he has flies in
his eyes. Appleby becomes extremely worried and asks Havermeyer if he truly has
flies in his eyes. Havermeyer confirms that he does not. A few minutes later,
Appleby says to Havermeyer, "You\'ve got peanut brittle crumbs on your face."(48)
Havermeyer quickly responds by saying, "I\'d rather have peanut brittle crumbs on
my face than flies in my eyes."(48) Havermeyer contradicts himself because he
first says that Applyby has nothing in his eyes and then moments later abruptly
says that he has flies in his eyes.
Another example of when the characters in the novel talk and act without
making any sense is when Captain Black started the Glorious Loyalty Oath Crusade.
Captain Black encouraged the soldiers to sign this optional oath to show that
they were not communists. However, he says to Milo, "The men don\'t have to
sign.......if they don\'t want to. But we need you to starve them to death if
they don\'t."(118) Obviously, this statement is a contradiction. If Captain
Black is going to starve them to death, then the oath is, in fact, forcing every
member of the squadron to sign.
Colonel Cargill, Clevinger, Major Major, Dr. Stubbs, Sergeant Towser,
Captain Black, Appleby, Havermeyer, Orr, and of course, Yossarian are all
notorious for speaking profusely and rarely saying anything of substance.
Frequently, the jumbled dialogues are a result of two characters communicating
on different wave lengths. This
Topics Related to The Lack of Comprehensive Speech in Catch 22
Essays Related to The Lack of Comprehensive Speech in Catch 22
Mother to the tribeMother to the tribe English 1302 November 27, 1996 Mother To The Tribe Throughout time people have been questioning their society. Many wonder if the beliefs and customs of their culture are actually what is in the interest of themselves or even the masses. Times of hardship can create strong and powerful people to bring about change; however the means to achieve such is relevant to ones morals or ethics. For many would agree utilitarianism is the best route to take when trying to appease most i
The Atrocity Of WarThe Atrocity Of War The Atrocity of War More than an end to war, we want an end to the beginning of all wars - yes, an end to this brutal, inhuman and thoroughly impractical method of settling the differences between governments (Franklin D. Roosevelt). In some people’s minds, war is glorified. The romanticized perspective that society bases war on is reversed in the book Catch-22. The Vietnam War established the book as an anti-war classic because of the war’s paradoxical nature. Heller perceiv
Harriet Beecher StoweHarriet Beecher Stowe Harriet Beecher Stowe was a high class women, reformer, and writer in the 1800’s. She wrote many anti-slavery documents that helped reform society. You may know her as the writer of Uncle Tom’s Cabin, the best-selling book in the 1800’s about how bad slavery was. Because of the encouragement if her husband, Calvin E. Stowe, she became one of the most famous writers, reformers, and abolitionist women of the 1800’s. Harriet Elizabeth Beecher Stowe was born on June 14, 1811, i
The Lack of Comprehensive Speech in Catch 22The Lack of Comprehensive Speech in Catch 22 Most of what we really say has no meaning. This concept is perfectly supported in Catch 22, by Joseph Heller. Almost every character and scene in the novel contain dialogues where the people speak aimlessly and have no explanation for why they are talking. Colonel Cargill addresses his men by saying, ÒYou\'re American officers. The officers of no other army in the world can make that statement. Think about it.(29) Even though the remark is true, it h
Catch 22Catch 22 The Lack of Comprehensive Speech in Catch 22 Most of what we really say has no meaning. This concept is perfectly supported in Catch 22, by Joseph Heller. Almost every character and scene in the novel contain dialogues where the people speak aimlessly and have no explanation for why they are talking. Colonel Cargill addresses his men by saying, ÒYouÕre American officers. The officers of no other army in the world can make that statement. Think about it.Ó(29) Even though the remark is tr
E E Cummings-life And WorkE E Cummings-life And Work e e cummings e e cummings (no, this is not a typographical error, take note to the way he writes his name) was an unusual, yet highly acclaimed writer of the 20th century. His style of writing was much different than that of any other contemporary or even 18th and 19th century writers. Although difficult to understand at times, e e cummings is a very profound and inventive writer. e e cummings was born Edward Estlin Cummings on October 14, 1894 in Cambridge Massachuset
IB World Lit Paper 2 Virginity In Chronicle Of A DIB World Lit Paper 2 Virginity In Chronicle Of A Death Foretold Be Gabriel Garcia Marquez And Like Watr For Chocalate Eric Orr Latin American society has placed a very high value on women being virgins when they marry. This value is one of the primary themes in Chronicle of a Death foretold by Gabriel Garcia Marquez. In contrast, virginity does not appear to hold significance in Like Water for Chocolate by Laura Esquivel. However this is only on the surface but as one delves into the deeper mean
Literary Critical Essay Literary Critical Essay Catch-22 302 3/22/04 A.P. Composition Joseph Heller is a laudatory writer of a book Catch-22, whose intentions are to show his readers that it isn’t satisfactory to be crazy in the society and it is crazy not to be insane by using literary elements such as satire. This book is set in during WWII. The main character is Yossarian, just your average soldier who, at first, seems insane. Everyone around him considers him insane as well. However, because he is insane, he’s not
Flathead: Road to Self-sufficiencyFlathead: Road to Self-sufficiency Before the Anglo American invaded the home of the Native Americans, Native Americans were successfully governing themselves. They managed to keep peace and administer justice though using their own customs, laws, and traditions. After the white invasion, the United States government recognized the need to let a “sovern nation” (such as the Indian nations) make and govern themselves by their own rules, “make their own laws and to be ruled by them”(Williams v Lee
The History of Kenworth Motor Truck CompanyThe History of Kenworth Motor Truck Company During the time that brought dramatic change to the Northwest as Model Ts began challenging the horse and carriage in the transportation race, a Seattle businessman Edgar Worthington was managing his mother’s building, which was a car and truck dealership at the time. Edgar had a very special interest in the Gerlinger Motor Car Company, watching as they worked, sold, and fixed cars and trucks. He never had any clue that someday it would be his. The fir
The Year 2000 ProblemThe Year 2000 Problem Where did this problem come from? What is going to happen on January 1st, 2000? What will we be doing on New Year\'s Eve 1999? Will we be partying and celebrating like it\'s the beginning of the new millenium or will we be storing up on food, gas, and batteries for our survival? According to Professor Bill Erdly, Director of Computing and Software Systems at UWB, the Y2K problem certainly does exist and can result in some major problems if not corrected. (Nelson-White, 1/
Reality Based ProgrammingReality Based Programming “By crossing into a space whose curvature is no longer that of the real, nor that of truth, the era of simulation of inaugurated by a liquidation of all referentials-worse: with their artificial resurrection in the systems of signs, a material more malleable than meaning, in that it lends itself to all systems of equivalences . . . It is no longer a question of imitation, nor duplication, nor even parody. It is a question of substituting the signs of the real for the re
The Origin of Ice HockeyThe Origin of Ice Hockey Ice hockey is a sport played on an 85’ by 200” sheet of ice. The ice is divided into three zones, a neutral zone and two attacking zones which hold the goals. The game starts with six players on the ice: two defenceman , left and right, two wings, left and right, a center, and a goalie. There are three referees on the ice at all times. A normal game of ice hockey consists of three periods each twenty minutes long. The job of the referees is to call all infractions. There
Lyndon Baines JohnsonLyndon Baines Johnson Lyndon Baines Johnson served as the thirty-sixth president of the United States of America. Events which marked the Johnson presidency were the funeral of President John Fitzgerald Kennedy, the push for the Great Society, and most memorably, the Vietnam conflict. Johnson was a man who possessed incredible power. In the early stages of his presidency many domestic programs were initiated. The latter portion of his presidency suffered due to his bad handling of the situation
The Bubonic PlagueThe Bubonic Plague It was a golden age! Queen Elizabeth, a strong, powerful leader ruled England from 1558-1603, a time of remarkable accomplishments. England’s economy prospered, the Navy defeated the Spanish Armada, explorers claimed new land for the queen, and music and literature flourished(Runnion, Snow, and Watson 246d). Some of the world’s greatest writers emerged, including William Shakespeare. While he enjoyed sixteenth century success and accomplishments, he also survived one of the wo
The SpaThe Spa The water in the soaking pool is 100°, the odor of sulfur fills the nostrils, Mary and I are sitting here again, soaking away another months worth of problems at Parriso Hot Springs. Though it is expensive, we find our way as often as the budget will allow. To the west stand the pale brown desert-like hills that tell what the land was like before man arrived. It is these pale brown hills, broken in color by the short scrub brush native to the land, that keep the breezes of the Pacific Oc
The Quintessential CanadianThe Quintessential Canadian For this project I chose as the quintessential Canadian, Paul Henderson. He is representative of the entire 1972 Team Canada. Before this famous series, it was assumed that Team Canada was unbeatable, but it soon became clear that Canada would be the underdogs and have to fight back. In the end, it was the little known player, Paul Henderson, who became the star and restored pride in the hearts of all Canadians. He is truly a quintessential Canadian. The 1972 Summit