This essay The Crime at Compiegne has a total of 762 words and 4 pages.
The Crime at Compiegne
The Crime at Compiegne
Proving herself to be a good deal more than ordinary, Jeanne d’Arc, the Maid of Orleans and patron saint of France, united her nation at a critical hour in history and decisively turned the Hundred Years’ War in France’s favor, forever ending England’s dreams of hegemony over France. The crimes and eventual triumph of this most amazing young woman are better understood when applied to Dostoevsky’s "extraordinary man" theory.
Dostoevsky’s theory, as written in Crime and Punishment, claims that all of mankind is divided into two basic categories, the "ordinary" and the "extraordinary." Where the "ordinary" masses are "by nature conservative, staid, live in obedience and like being obedient," the "extraordinary" few "all transgress the law… for the sake of an idea." It is this idea or "new word" that calls the "extraordinary" man to "allow his conscious to…step over certain obstacles" in order to fulfill this idea.
Jeanne’s "new word" was that of the call of Heaven. At only 13, Jeanne began hearing voices that were sometimes accompanied by visions. She was convinced that these voices were those of St. Michael and the early martyrs St. Catherine of Alexandria and St. Margaret. These voices exhorted her to help the Dauphin, later Charles VII, king of France, recapture the city of Orleans and thereby win the Hundred Years’ War against England. Jeanne succeeded in convincing Charles and his board of theologians that she had a divine mission to save France. Approving her claims, she was granted a small detachment of troops to command. Dressed in armor and carrying a white banner that represented God blessing the French royal emblem, the fleur-de-lis, she led the French to a decisive victory over the English at Orleans.
Having accomplished this miraculous feat she convinced Charles to risk the journey to Rheims in order to hold coronation ceremonies in the cathedral there, according to the custom of the kings of France before him. Jeanne again triumphed. In the eyes of the people the cowardly and lethargic Dauphin became the king of France and regained legitimacy and the loyalty of Frenchmen everywhere as a consequence of the ceremonies. Charles, still irresolute and hesitant, delayed and missed the moment for riding the psychological crest and driving the English from his land. Instead of acting, he vehemently opposed any further campaigns against the English. Therefore, it was without royal support that Jeanne conducted a military campaign against the English at Compiegne, near Paris where she was finally captured and convicted of the crime of answering to God before the king and the Roman Catholic Church. Jeanne directly disobeyed the king and was responsible for the murder of hundreds of Englishmen.
Dostoevsky claims that as an "extraordinary" woman, that this transgression was her duty, as was the shedding of the blood of "ordinary" people. Dostoevsky goes on to say that "most of the benefactors and founders of mankind were especially terrible blood-shedders," and Jeanne’s crime in no way diminishes her extraordinary nature. In fact, it only serves to further illustrate it. According to the theory, if Jeanne had not gone on to Compiegne and disobeyed the king, she would cease to be extraordinary because she would not be fulfilling her calling, her "new word." Where Dostoevsky’s theory falls through is with his assertion that "the act of carrying out a crime is always accompanied by illness." Jeanne was never ill that history has recorded except to be dubbed insane and a heretic by the English. Perhaps illness would have befallen her if she had been allowed to live; she was burned at the stake only days after her capture.
Dostoevsky’s statement that "those who are a tiny bit off the beaten track…by their very nature cannot fail to be criminals" seemed to be written especially for Jeanne. As a female in the early 1400s, Saint Jeanne managed to break two stereotypes rigorously supported by the Roman Catholic Church of the day, that God could speak directly to the people, even a peasant like Jeanne, and that God not only showed himself to women, but that he also could command the "inferior sex" to serve Him gloriously. Until this time, it was commonly held that God spoke only to the
Topics Related to The Crime at Compiegne
Joan of Arc, Jeanne, Crime and Punishment, Crime, Fyodor Dostoyevsky, Compigne
Essays Related to The Crime at Compiegne
Mark Twain's Masterpiece 'The Adventures of HuckleMark Twain\'s Masterpiece \'The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn Mark Twain and his masterpiece The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn ________ A Research Paper Presented to Mr. Neil of Chula Vista High School ________ In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for English 10 Honors/Gate ________ By: Id #: 937228 May 16, 1996 Outline I. Samuel Clemens A. Who he is B. Where he was born C. Family II. How Samuel came to be Mark Twain A. His working life B. First writings III. The Adventures of Huck Finn
Joan of ArcJoan of Arc A French saint and a heroine in the Hundred Years\' war was Joan of Arc. This farm girl helped save the French from English command and was often called the Maid Orleans and the Maid of France. Her inspiration led the French to many victories. Joan Of Arc (In French Jeanne d\'Arc) was born around 1412, in the village of Domremy, France. She was a peasant girl who, like many girls of that time, could not read or write. Her father, Jacques, was a wealthy tenant farmer and her mother, I
Joan of ArcJoan of ArcJOAN OF ARC A French saint and a heroine in the Hundred Years\' war was Joan of Arc. This farm girl helped save the French from English command and was often called the Maid Orleans and the Maid of France. Her inspiration led the French to many victories. Joan Of Arc (In French Jeanne d\'Arc) was born around 1412, in the village of Domremy, France. She was a peasant girl who, like many girls of that time, could not read or write. Her father, Jacques, was a wealthy tenant farmer and h
THE TRIAL AND DEATH OF JOAN OF ARCTHE TRIAL AND DEATH OF JOAN OF ARC On May 16, 1920, Pope Benedict XV conducted a ceremony at St. Peter’s Basilica in Rome to canonize Joan of Arc, often referred to as the Maid of Orleans. This ceremony was the final step in a process that was begun in 1849 by the Bishop of Orleans, Felix Dupanloup, over 400 years after St. Joan’s was tried, convicted and executed in the name of the Church. A study of her heroic deeds and an intensive review of her life, virtues and the trial transcripts that co
Joan Of Arc By Jules Basten LepageJoan Of Arc By Jules Basten Lepage “Joan of Arc,” was painted by the French realist artist Jules Bastien-Lepage in 1879. “After the province of Lorraine was lost to Germany following the Franco-Prussian War in 1821, The Frenchmen saw in Joan of Arc a new and powerful symbol. In 1875, Bastien-Lepage, a native of Lorraine began to make studies for a picture of her. In the present painting, exhibited in the Salon of 1880, Joan is shown receiving her revelation in her parents garden. Behind her are
Hundreds Years WarHundreds Years War Hundred Years War The definition of the Golden Rule is that those with the gold make the rules. In other words, those with the gold have the power as well as those with the power have the gold. History books will discuss the general reasons for war such as freedom from adversity or freedom from religion. But the real issue for any war is the thirst for power and control; and the means to finance them are the economic issues. Nations will endure years of fighting for power and
Jeanne La Pucelle (Joan The Maid)Jeanne La Pucelle (Joan The Maid) 1412, it is in the last half-century of the Hundred Years\' War in which the French attempted to attain freedom from English rule by fighting to eradicate English strongholds. An unusually strong, healthy, and possibly clairvoyant girl is born to Isabelle Romée and Jacques d\'Arc in the small village of Domremy, France. Her mother is from the town of Vouthon, which is west of Domremy. Her surname concurs that either she or a family member has visited Rome. Her f
Mark Twain and His Masterpiece: The Adventures ofMark Twain and His Masterpiece: The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn ________ A Research Paper Presented to Mr. Neil of Chula Vista High School ________ In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for English 10 Honors/Gate ________ By: Id #: 937228 May 16, 1996 Outline I. Samuel Clemens A. Who he is B. Where he was born C. Family II. How Samuel came to be Mark Twain A. His working life B. First writings III. The Adventures of Huck Finn A. Story Plot 1. The outside of the book 2. The inside of the
Fantasy's Integral Role In The Creation Of A KilleFantasy\'s Integral Role In The Creation Of A Killer Through out history seldom has an individual been able to hold a city in fear. Most times people will just either ignore the individual, let the police handle the situation, or call them wacko or crazy. But then there are the extreme cases. On this end of the scale people may have extreme mental problems or very strong motives, so extreme or so strong that they captivate an entire city or even nation. Jack the Ripper did it by killing and murd
Serial KillersSerial Killers God, I\'ve never done anything. Help me, help me! God, why is this happening? Help me! Robert Violante screamed as the Son of Sam\'s .44 caliber bullet tore through his temple (Eyes of a Killer, http.//www.serialkiller.com). Serial killers are the most famous of all murderers because of their mass numbers of victims and their odd rituals of killing. What is a serial killer? A serial killer falls into two categories: psychotics and psychopaths. Psychotics are clearly insane, they
Goodness and EvilGoodness and Evil A.P. European History 7 May 1997 Throughout the world’s history, man has displayed his capacity for good and evil. Unfortunately more of the latter than the former. It is well known that people should be judged in the context of their times, so it is difficult to objectively say who was good and who was evil without using today’s moral beliefs. It is also difficult to say how these two characteristics can be controlled to make a better society because whatever viewpoint appears
A History of the English Church and PeopleA History of the English Church and People Conversion of Edward of N. Umbria. Instructed in Christianity. Debate whether or not worship of Christianity is better than pagan. Burned temple down. Sparrow=how we spend life on earth, banquet hall before after is unknown=pagan religion Las Siete Partidas: Castilian Law Code Jewish life in Spanish kingdom of Castile in reign of Alfonso the Wise. A learned ruler interested in history, science, and the law. Conduct around Christians. Segregation with pr
EnglandEngland England (Latin Anglia), political division of the island of Great Britain, constituting, with Wales, the principal division of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland. England occupies all of the island east of Wales and south of Scotland, another division of the United Kingdom. Established as an independent monarchy many centuries ago, England in time achieved political control over the rest of the island, all the British Isles, and vast sections of the world, becoming
Joan of ArcJoan of ArcJoan of Arc was born on January 6, 1412, in the village of Domremy in north-eastern France. Her father Jacques was a peasant farmer and a minor village official. Her mother Isabelle, raised her daughter in the teachings of the Christian faith. Joan was more religious than most of the girls in her village. At the age of thirteen or fourteen Joan began to hear voices and to have visions. She claimed the voices and visions were of Saint Michael, Saint Margaret, and Saint Catherine. Thes
Christine de PisanChristine de Pisan Christine de Pisan was a 20th century woman living in the 15th century. Like many women of today, she incorporated government and political ethics, women’s rights and accomplishments, and religious devotion in her writings. Yet, defying the expectations of her time, Christine was one of the few true feminists before the modern era. Christine de Pisan was born in Venice, Italy in about 1364. Her father was Tomasso di Benvenuto da Pizzano (Thomas de Pisan), a famous physician an
The Middle AgesThe Middle Ages Scott Flanagan Period1, 12/17/96 Table of Contents Map of Middle Ages Europe.......................................................................................3 Map of Modern Europe...............................................................................................4 Charlemange’s Eulogy...............................................................................................5 Charlemange’s Empire.................................................................
Mark TwainMark Twain Samuel Langhorne Clemens, also know as Mark Twain, was born in 1835 and died in 1910. He is best known as an American humorist and for his realistic view of America in the nineteenth century through his novels and other stories. He had the whole world captivated through his expert writing and lectures. “I never let my schooling interfere with my education (home.eathlink.net/…/twain.html),” Mark Twain once said. Mark Twain was a great inspiration to America in the nineteenth century an
The Golden RuleThe Golden Rule The definition of the Golden Rule is that those with the gold make the rules. In other words, those with the gold have the power as well as those with the power have the gold. History books will discuss the general reasons for war such as freedom from adversity or freedom from religion. But the real issue for any war is the thirst for power and control; and the means to finance them are the economic issues. Nations will endure years of fighting for power and control. France and E
The Hundred Years WarThe Hundred Years War The Hundred Years War was a series of wars throughout Europe from 1337 to about 1453. This war was fought between France and England because of claims by the English monarchs on the French throne. The period of war concentrated on in the following was from 1337 to about 1360. It includes rivalries between King Edward III and King Philip of England. King Edward III played a large role in many of these battles which really helped the English. However, his accomplishments were
Joan of ArcJoan of Arc I read the passage on Joan of Arc from A History of Their Own; Women in Europe Volume 1 by Bonnie Anderson and Judith Zinsser. I was immediately engrossed in the story of her determination and drive to succeed, and later survive, in the single sex world of that time. I found it amazing that she lived only 19 years, yet was able to make such a lasting impact on history that she is still revered over 500 years after her death. Her persecution and death were products of men who feared w
Mark TwainMark Twain Mark Twain, one of the most prolific writers in American history, used his previous experiences as an inspiration for his most widely acclaimed literary works. By reading and studying his books, one learns many things about the type of life he led. In some novels, an individual reader can experience his childhood adventures first hand. In his later works there are portions about the importance of love in the family, but, of course, there is always the indomitable wisecrack. John Marsh
Joan of ArcJoan of Arc Many people have heard the name Joan of Arc, but have never known what she did and what happened to her. Joan of Arc was bold, fearless and powerful. During her short lifetime Joan helped many people and got a death sentence in return. I\'m going to tell her story in my report. Joan of Arc was born in Doremy, in the Duchy of Loraine, which we now know as France. She was born a peasant and was taught things like sewing, hoeing, and shepherding. In 1428 she went to live in a Castle in
The CrucibleThe Crucible INTRODUCTION The Crucible by Arthur Miller was written during the early 1950s at the time of Senator Joseph McCarthy\'s House Un-American Activities Committee hearings on the infiltration of Communism in the United States and the loyalty to democracy of many prominent U.S. citizens. The McCarthy hearings pitted artists and performers against each other as they were called to testify about their own loyalty and what they knew about the loyalty of others. Although some critics have su
The Hundred Years WarThe Hundred Years War The Hundred Years War was considered to be the last medieval war that played a significant role in English history.(Schwarz) The Hundred Years War was a series of wars fought between Great Britain and France with Burgundy playing a small role for the French. Although the conflict lasted over a century the war was broken intermittently by treaties and truces. (Goubert) There were more stalemates than actual battles. (Froissart) Actual fighting didn’t brake out until the mid
El Guerra de los Cien AñosEl Guerra de los Cien Años 1. El guerra de los cien años empezó con un argumento dinastico que origino cuando el conquesto de Inglaterra por William de Normandia creó un estado que quedo en dos lados del canal Inglaterra. 2. Muchos lideres y reyes participaron en este larga guerra. Unos importantes personas fueron Eduardo III rey de Inglaterra, Eduardo el Negro Principe de Frances, Juan II de Frances, Joan de Arca, Henry V de Frances. Todos estos reyes y guerreros jugaron un importante trabajo e