This essay Stare Decisis and the Law of Precedent has a total of 1365 words and 6 pages.
Stare Decisis and the Law of Precedent
Law of Precedent
One of the major considerations on how someone is tried in a court of law depends upon the previous convictions of similar cases. This law of precedent (stare decisis) was founded hundreds of years ago as part of our common law. The literal translation of stare decisis is "that like cases be decided alike." Precedents in law play a fundamental role in the judicial processes of Canada. From stealing a loaf of bread ranging to murder in the first degree, there are precedents for any type of case that has ever occurred in Canada, and even many cases from Britain (prior to 1949 and the abolishment of the JCPC). Unfortunately, the law of precedent does have its downfalls.
Despite the fall backs of stare decisis, the law of precedent still holds true and important in our modern society. Some of the shortcomings of stare decisis are the following: As time changes, precedents need to change in order to accommodate society’s new values and laws. Furthermore, the introduction of "social facts" in court cases has clouded over many existing precedents with many new facts and ideas that render the basics of stare decisis much more complicated.
One of the more common drawbacks to the law of precedent is that over time, a law may be found as no longer applicable, or on the other hand, a new decision may be found in a trial which can also be undesirable. Keep in mind that the courts are not supposed to create new policies to deal with new problems, that is the role of the legislature. This drawback is prevalent in two forms: The first is the ruling of a court case, and the second is the sentencing or judicial decision of a case.
In order to examine the first form an example is given. A long time ago, sexual harassment at the work place was virtually unheard of or it was ignored altogether. The case probably would not even make it to court. Nowadays if a boss (traditionally a man) simply inquires about an employee’s sexual status (traditionally the woman) is considered sexual harassment, and the boss would be found guilty of the charge. This is a classic example of the changing views of society. Sixty plus years ago, women seemingly meant nothing to the world. They were considered tools, possessions, and frequently were not referred to at all by the law. However, with the long battle for the realization of woman’s rights, females have become respected by our society and our laws. Unfortunately, sexual harassment at the workplace is going too far. It used to be a threat of one’s job in return for sexual favors to qualify as quid pro quo harassment. Yet in today’s context, simply inquiring about an employee’s sexual status is deemed as sexual harassment.
There are problems with old laws and precedents that may need to be rectified. Previous decisions by judges do not necessarily embody the law. Here is where a judge’s duty is to apply the law, not another justice’s determination of it. "The law and the opinion of the judge may not always be one and the same." For judges, it is important to correct any precedent that is now viewed as a mistake. Making sure that precedents are kept "in check" is a vital role of the courts.
The second case of changing precedent is that of court sentencing and decision making. This part of stare decisis troubles many people along with myself for a good reason, court cases are getting out of hand! Here offered is another example. Fifty years ago, a convicted serial killer would have been hung by the laws of capital punishment. Yet nowadays, the taking of a convicted killer’s life is deemed as cruel and unusual punishment, even if he murdered the Prime Minister on national television. If that example is too drastic, here is another, more reasonable example. In the United States, court rulings dealing with personal injury or damages are becoming out of this world. Here are a couple of examples: A lady gets 8 million dollars for spilling hot coffee from McDonalds’ on herself; O.J. Simpson is out a total of 33 million dollars for the
Topics Related to Stare Decisis and the Law of Precedent
Legal citation, Precedent, Common law, Judiciary, Kimble v. Marvel Entertainment, LLC, Judicial restraint
Essays Related to Stare Decisis and the Law of Precedent
MexicoMexico Mexico Country Profile Country Formal Name: United Mexican States (Estados Unidos Mexicans). Short Form: Mexico. Term for Citizen(s): Mexican(s). Capital: Mexico City (called Mééxico or Ciudad de Mééxico in country). Date of Independence: September 16, 1810 (from Spain). National Holidays: May 5, commemorating the victory over the French at the Battle of Puebla; September 16, Independence Day. Mexico Geography Size: 1,972,550 square kilometers--third largest nation in Latin America (after
Pay Equity Vs. Pay EqualityPay Equity Vs. Pay Equality Title: Pay Equity vs. Pay Equality Abstract: Pay Equality means equal pay for equal work, but pay equity programs throughout the world attempt to legislate and regulate the elimination of systemic gender-based wage discrimination and to ensure ongoing systems that will maintain equitable wage relationships over time. Six Pages APA Citations, Seven Sources Pay Equity vs. Pay Equality In 1963, President Kennedy signed the Equal Pay Act into law, making it unlawful to di
Gay ParentingGay Parenting Lesbian and Gay Parenting I. SUMMARY OF RESEARCH FINDINGS Charlotte J. Patterson University of Virginia Like families headed by heterosexual parents, lesbian and gay parents and their children are a diverse group (Martin, 1993). Unlike heterosexual parents and their children, however, lesbian and gay parents and their children are often subject to prejudice because of sexual orientation that turns judges, legislators, professionals, and the public against them, frequently resulting
MARITIME LIFE ASSURANCE COMPANY MARITIME LIFE ASSURANCE COMPANY About Maritime Life The company I’ve chosen to research is the Maritime Life Assurance Company. Maritime Life started over 80 years ago by a small group of families in Halifax and from those humble beginnings this company has grown into the 4th largest national insurance company in Canada. This company has their head office in Halifax and provides benefits to almost three million Canadians from offices in Halifax, Montreal, Ottawa, Toronto, London, Kitchener, Oak
The Pros of Phone TappingThe Pros of Phone Tapping J Hey, I’m putting the paper together and this is what I’m going to use from your draft. I need you fill in the blanks. The most IMPORTANT part you’ll need to address is in the second paragraph. You need to look up “how phone tapping/surveillance has been regulated?” You stated that it has been regulated but didn’t explain how. Please work on that part and try to get as much information about it as you can. Also, give me the citations, where I bolded (NEED CITATION) bel
EthicsEthics Table of Contents Page Introduction………………………………………………………… 1 The Ethical Issue…………………………………………………… 1 Analysis…………………………………………………………….. 3 Evaluation………………………………………………………….. 4 Recommendation…………………………………………………… 5 Endnotes……………………………………………………………. 6 Appendix A………………………………………………………… 7 Bibliography………………………………………………………... 8 When people walk into a department store and buy an article of clothing they almost never look at the tag to see where it\'s made. For the people that do look at the tags the
CONTENT ON THE INTERNET: FREE OR FETTERED?CONTENT ON THE INTERNET: FREE OR FETTERED? Focus: This paper examines the nature of the problem caused by potentially offensive material on the Internet and summarizes current efforts to regulate content, along with reactions to those efforts. 1. Introduction: what is the problem? Earlier last year, anyone could have been forgiven for believing that the world had just discovered the Internet, and that it had, in the process, concluded that the Internet was awash with pornographic images, drugs i
Japan Internment CampJapan Internment Camp On December 7, 1941, the Japanese attacked the United States Naval facility at Pearl Harbor in Hawaii. 19 ships were sunk, 2,335 servicemen lost their lives, and, afterwards, the United States declared war on Japan, and her allies Germany and Italy. However, another great loss occurred on United States soil--the imprisonment of 120,000 people, 2/3 of whom were United States citizens. The Japanese Internment, the name of this mistake, was illegal, unconstitutional, and an ac
Write a one page summary of your decision in Roe i Write a one page summary of your decision in Roe if you were a member of the Supreme Court in 1973. Would it change if you were deciding the case today? Â Â Â The Roe v. Wade decision established many controversial precedents and left many other questions unanswered and undecided. If I was on the Supreme Court during this case, I would have probably concurred with the majority decision based strictly on the Rule of Law and the merits and argument put forward during the case. The real precede
GangsGangs Introduction I. -A Los Angeles family takes a wrong turn into gang territory and is fired upon. A 3-year-old is killed and her 2-year-old brother wounded. -A Chinese immigrant in Brooklyn is kidnapped by a Chinatown gang which demands ransom payments from her family. She is murdered when the family fails to pay. -Two FBI agents and a police sergeant are murdered inside the Washington, D.C. police headquarters by a gang member. -A Pittsburgh police sergeant walking home with his daughter is
Internet Pornography: Freedom of Press or DangerouInternet Pornography: Freedom of Press or Dangerous Influence? The topic of pornography is controversial many times because of the various definitions which each have different contexts. Is it nudity, sexual intercourse, art, or all of these? Is it magazines, videos, or pictures? For the purposes of this paper, pornography will be defined as any material that depicts erotic behavior and is intended to cause sexual excitement. With all of the arguments presented in this paper, it seems only a vag
Legalization of Marijana: ForLegalization of Marijana: For It\'s time we put to rest the myth that smoking marijuana is a fringe or deviant activity, engaged in only by those on the margins of American society. In reality, marijuana smoking is extremely common, and marijuana is the recreational drug of choice for millions of mainstream, middle class Americans. According to the most recent NIDA data1, between 65 and 71 million Americans have smoked marijuana at some time in their lives, and 10 million are current smokers (ha
Ernest Hemingway - An American ContemporaryErnest Hemingway - An American Contemporary Jason Milford April 2000 Ernest Hemingway Ernest Miller Hemingway was an American novelist, journalist, writer of short stories, and winner of the 1954 Nobel Prize for literature. He created a distinguished body of prose fiction, much of it based on adventurous life. He was born on July 21, 1899, the second of six children, in Oak Park, Ill., in a house built by his widowed grandfather, Ernest Hall. Oak Park was a Protestant, upper middle class suburb
“Same sex adoption: Do I qualify?” “Same sex adoption: Do I qualify?” ENG 1000cResearch Paper 12/17/03 In recent years, the gay adoption issue has taken big dimensions. Ever since the public acknowledged that Rosie O’Donnel is a gay mother. This has caused many states to debate the legality of the issue, and has created a public debate on the ethics of it. In trying to understand the issues at hart, I researched it from a unique point of view. I interviewed 3 gay couples at different stages of adoption. These are their stories.
Wartime Propaganda: World War IWartime Propaganda: World War I The Drift Towards War Lead this people into war, and they\'ll forget there was ever such a thing as tolerance. To fight, you must be brutal and ruthless, and the spirit of ruthless brutality will enter into the very fiber of national life, infecting the Congress, the courts, the policeman on the beat, the man in the street. It is one of history\'s great ironies that Woodrow Wilson, who was re- elected as a peace candidate in 1916, led America into the first worl
Who is Controlling YouWho is Controlling You Christopher L. Lewis March 27, 1999 Professor Haslor English 102 One of the biggest issues in the United States that I would change would be gun control. The government is constantly proposing legislation for more and more gun control. Slowly they are chipping away at our constitutional right to keep and bear arms. You must ask yourself: For what reason does the government want to restrict law-abiding citizens from owning guns? Certainly government is not so naive to think
Recruiting Recruiting HR Management Cody Ellis 11/7/2016 Recruiting is attracting, evaluating, and hiring employees for an organization or company. When a recruiter is looking for an applicant, he/she needs to be as cost efficient for the company as they can. The recruitment process includes analyzing the requirements of a job, attracting employees to that job, screening and selecting applicants, hiring, and integrating the new employee to the organization. (BusinessDictionary.com) These five steps will
A man without ethics is a wild beast loosed upon A man without ethics is a wild beast loosed upon this world. (Camus) This powerful statement by Camus is a statement that if one wishes to succeed in the profession of journalism should consider. â€¦wild beast loosed upon this world can be linked to ethics in the way that ethics provides some form of accountability. The work journalists do require ethics in a large way. The absence of ethics will allow the work of journalists to become questionable as the public is very trusting of the broa