This essay Problems of History in The Theory of Knowledge has a total of 1107 words and 6 pages.
Problems of History in The Theory of Knowledge
Critical examination of the Problems of History in the Theory of Knowledge by exploring and discussing the statement, “Every work of history is at least as revealing of the person who wrote it, and of the period in which it was written, as it is
of the events it portrays.”
“Every work of history is at least as revealing of the person who wrote it, and of the period in which it was written, as it is of the events it portrays.” The problem with the past is that there may be more than one version of it. Depending on the cultural background, place it was written, point of view and many other variables may produce different accounts of the same event.
That is when the concept of ‘truth’ is hard to determine. History does not write itself, people must record it and none can do it completely impartially. The emotions one may feel towards an event may well determine the kind of language used in a work of history. Likewise a historian’s reasoning to whether a certain event would benefit or not a county’s image is likely to be criticised, praised or conveniently forgotten.
No historian can be completely unbiased, “The historian must pick and choose and organize in accordance with his insight as to what is significant.” Simply sorting the ‘relevant’ from the ‘irrelevant’ is already defining the importance of certain events. Personal judgement comes into play here along with cultural ideals and beliefs. Furthermore what one historian may consider relevant another may disagree, different countries or parts of the world may completely cast aside a selection of happenings that others would select as an important part of history. For example a great earthquake destroyed most of the capital city of Portugal – Lisbon – in 1755, this would be a very important fact recorded in Portuguese history. However probably be unmentioned elsewhere since it would have had no impact on their environment or society.
Another factor that is a big problem in recording or attempting to record history – as mentioned earlier – are biases and censorships. Certain countries, governments, religions and societies have strict censorship rules that do not allow certain publications that may in some way become prejudicial to teachings, laws, theories, policies, administration, forms of government or its leaders. This may cause certain objectionable sections of history to be either forced into oblivion or at least subdued to modifications as to make it more convenient for future readings and interpretations. Censorship has been used throughout history. Tzar Alexander III – emperor of Russia during 1881 through 1894 – along with his counsellor Pobedonostev introduced very harsh censorship regulations and closed over fourteen newspapers in the first year of his reign. Nothing could be said or even implied against the monarchy under penalty of death. This was at a time of great turmoil during which the Emperor feared to be overthrown or assassinated, as had been his father. Alexander III also censored the teaching curriculum concentrating on religious teachings that asserted the Tzar as sole and rightful leader appointed by God.
More than one report regarding a historical episode are usually formed. They may express their version of what they think may have occurred. For instance, if a country is at war with another historians from both sides will write different accounts, as will those on neither side but who in some way have become involved or affected. Two or more different views of a portion of history may all be equally accurate and yet say completely different things. It all depends on what has been going on around each historian as well as his personal opinions both in selection and beliefs as well as what their notion of the event was. During the Berlin Wall crisis (1960s) communist Berlin was separated from capitalist Berlin by a concrete wall. Whilst the west claimed that Joseph Stalin had set up the wall to impede people from leaving Russia to move to a more promising capitalist, Stalin maintained that it was erected in order to stop unwanted prostitutes, beggars and criminals from entering the USSR.
An additional difficulty that historians may come across are when they are recording history is
Topics Related to Problems of History in The Theory of Knowledge
Essays Related to Problems of History in The Theory of Knowledge
Women, Work And Public PolicyWomen, Work And Public Policy Gender and the market are both concepts that carry tremendous power to shape society. Indeed, these institutions are so powerful within society that they can seem invisible and immutable. Each of these influential constructs has become the lens through which a theoretical approach defines and analyzes the world: feminist theory centering on gender, and economic theory centering on the market. Such a primary focus enables each theory to function as an invaluable tool
PRODUCTIVITY GROWTH HYPTHESISPRODUCTIVITY GROWTH HYPTHESIS In this assignment, we will attempt to study the effects that difference in Income Ratio (henceforth known as I.R.) between the years 1980 and 1990 have on the Productivity Growth (P.G.) during the same period of time. The Income Ratio of one specific year can be found if we take the average income of the richest faction of a country (the richest 20% of the population) and divide it by that of the poorest faction (the poorest 20%). In this assignment, the Income Rat
The Sight of ScienceThe Sight of Science It is a truth universally acknowledged that he whose mind is ahead of his time and above that of his peers may not be understood by his fellow people and be subject to critisizm and persecution. Galilei Galileo, Francis Bacon, and Rene Descartes were among the first to break away from the conventional views of their times to find a place for science in a society and propose the way it should be practiced. All three authors agree on some points but differe markedly on others.
Theory and ResearchTheory and Research Introduction This paper will focus on the quantitative correlation study method used in survey based researches such as the attached article entitled Horatio Alger lives. Social research is a collection of methods people use to systematically combine theories and ideas to produce knowledge. Because of it\'s complexity, researchers must be able to carefully select a method or methods that will best suit their study objectives. Quantitative research method consists of: experi
Theories Underlying the Constructivist ApproachTheories Underlying the Constructivist Approach Introduction According to Elliot Eisner: “teaching is an art and the creations of the teacher in producing an engaging stimulating and insightful lesson are the result of using many different skills but these are influenced by qualities and contingencies that are unpredictable’ but all teachers do operate with theory where theory is ‘a general set of ideas through which we make sense of the world” And according to Peel (1967): “psychology may be de
The French RevolutionThe French Revolution I. Absolutism A. Absolutism defined 1. In the absolutist state, sovereignty resided in kings--not the nobility or the parliament--who considered themselves responsible to God alone. 2. Absolute kings created new state bureaucracies and standing armies, regulated all the institutions of government, and secured the cooperation of the nobility. a. Some historians deny that absolutism was a stage of development that followed feudalism, but, instead, was administrative monarchy.
Asian Philosophies of Critical Thinking EXTENDED EAsian Philosophies of Critical Thinking EXTENDED ESSAYAsian Philosophies of Critical Thinking: divergent or convergent to western establishments? MAY 2003 AbstractThe research question of this extended essay came across at a very early stage in my life. Having been born and developed from a family with all its members being University instructors and professors, I was often involved in arguments related to the lack of critical thinking in Asian cultures. As I got older, having had the chance to
Piaget’s Theory of Cognitive Development Piaget’s Theory of Cognitive Development During the past half-century, the Swiss psychologist Jean Piaget devised a model describing how humans go about making sense of their world by gathering and organizing information (Piaget, 1954, 1963, 1970a, b). Piaget’s ideas provided an explanation of the development of thinking from infancy to adulthood. According to Piaget (1954), certain ways of thinking that are quite simple for an adult are not so simple for a child. Sometimes all you need to do t
TeachingTeaching Background and Setting My teaching practice is being carried out in Blackrock College. This is a large, fee paying all boys secondary school with roughly 1000 pupils from second to sixth year, with first years attending the feeder school Willow Park. My assignment relates to my experiences with second year classes. There are eight streamed classes, roughly 24 pupils per class, ranging highest to lowest from 2.8 to 2.2. The junior syllabus has been divided up, with a different teacher re
Difference Between Greek and Muslim PhilosophersDifference Between Greek and Muslim Philosophers Any attempts to answer the question posed must be complimented with an appropriate understanding of the schools of thought that are under discussion. It is for this purpose that I will begin by underlining the fundamental thought processes involved in Muslim and Greek philosophers and then assimilating the various approaches. The Greek philosophers, namely Socrates depended on the method of scientific induction, reasoning and this extended to the
Robert BoyleRobert Boyle The English scene of the seventeenth century is a particularly rich one with regard to its contributions to the scientific revolution. The discovery and development of America moved Britain from the edge of the civilized world into the center of the new world, in which the sciences were to play a major role. During this period, in the field of chemistry, theories which offered direct opposition to Aristotelian natural philosophy and Paracelsian principles were rapidly disseminating.
Cognition and LanguageCognition and Language EMANUEL KAKAOUNAKIS CHAPTER 7 COGNITION & LANGUAGE HUBBLE TELESCOPE -PROBLEM SOLVING -COGNITION PSYCHOLOGY -COGNITION -THINKING & REASONING -LANGUAGE THINKING -ONLY HUMANS CAN CONTEMPLATE, ANALYZE, RECOLLECT OR PLAN -THINKING= THE MANIPULATION OF MENTAL REPRESENTATION OF INFO -REPRESENTATION= WORD, VISUAL IMAGE, SOUND OR OTHER DATA -REPRESENTATIONS TRANSFORM INTO A DIFFERENT FORM TO ALLOW PROBLEM SOLVING -WE DO NOT REALLY KNOW HOW THIS HAPPENS -WE DO UNDERSTAND FUNDEMENTAL
ChallengerChallenger It was a cold, crisp, and damp morning on the Florida Space Coast as the space shuttle Challenger raced through the sky at speeds approaching mach 2 at an altitude of 104,000 feet when something went perilously wrong. All of America watched, including the family members of the seven doomed crew members, as Challenger exploded into an expansive ball of fire, smoke and steam. An Oh. . . no! came as the crew’s final utterance from the shuttle as the orbiter broke-up. As the reality of
David HumeDavid Hume I was from the beginning scandalised, I must own, with this resemblance between the Deity and human creatures. --Philo David Hume wrote much about the subject of religion, much of it negative. In this paper we shall attempt to follow Hume\'s arguments against Deism as Someone knowable from the wake He allegedly makes as He passes. This kind of Deism he lays to rest. Then, digging deeper, we shall try our hand at a critique of his critique of religion, of resurrecting a natural belie
Historical TruthHistorical Truth All of human history is a collaboration of truth. In it, emotion and rationality fight each other in a bitter struggle for supremacy. The outcome remains in doubt still to this day, however, as evidence of both individual and institutional involve- ment contribute towards this subtle yet potent friction. Institutions are the founda- tion of the house of social order while individuals roam free throughout the house itself. History teaches us that humanity grows and becomes streng