Macbeth: Macbeth A Murderer?

At the end of the play, Malcolm refers to Macbeth and Lady Macbeth as:
\'...this dead butcher and his fiend-like queen...\', consider the accuracy of
Malcolm\'s judgment by reference to their speeches and actions throughout the
play. (2,5 pages)

In Malcolm\'s eyes, the Macbeths are just tyrannical murderers who snatched the
throne away from him and his father and reigned a rule of terror in all of
Scotland. But looking carefully from a different point-of-view, we see that
Macbeth is driven by the powerful contradictions in his character. Unlike other
villains, Macbeth does not enjoy doing evil; he has not totally renounced the
idea of morality, although it is apparent that his ambition is stronger than his
conscience.

At first, Macbeth had the itch to be king, but he did not have the will to
scaratch it. We can see that Macbeth is not a cold-blooded monster in that the
very idea of killing Duncan horrifies him, and in Act II he tries to tell Lady
Macbeth that he will not go through with the murder. The character of Lady
Macbeth is therefore required to provide Macbeth with the extra will-power to
fulfil his royal ambitions. Macbeth is almost \'forced\' by Lady Macbeth to murder
Duncan. After committing the murder, Macbeth seems almost delirious and he says
that "...all great Neptune\'s ocean....hand". We can already see that he is sorry
for what he has done.

When Macbeth orders Banquo\'s murder, he is still in torment, but the cause of
his anguish seems to have been changed. He is afraid of Banquo, because Banquo
knows about the witches and their predictions of his(Banquo\'s) descendants being
kings. Banquo\'s death, he says, will put his mind at rest. Banquo\'s murder, he
figures, will serve as an aspirin to his aches and pains.

We are never told how Macbeth feels about the murder of Macduff\'s wife and
children. Their killing gains him nothing. He has good reason to fear Macduff
though, but slaughtering his enemy\'s family is pointless. Macbeth seems to order
their murder for spite, out of a feeling of desperation. Despite the witches\'
new prophecies, which appear to be reassuring, he is afraid of losing the crown.
Since he cannot get at Macduff directly, he lets loose this senseless violence
to those closest to Macduff.

Macbeth\'s other unspecified act of violence serve no purpose, as far as we can
see, beyond terrifying his subjects so much they won\'t resist his rule. Macbeth
is striking out at random, and his moral sense seems to have disappeared. The
brave hero we met in Act I has metamorphosised in to someone or something that
is completely twisted. He will do anything and will stop at nothing to preserve
the crown in his head.

Once Macbeth has killed to get the crown, the other crimes seem invitable. In
order to keep what he has taken, Macbeth has learned to lie and kill as a matter
of course, and seemed to have mastered the art of keeping up appearences. His
values and morals become totally pervesed, since his ambitions and the
preservation of it is on top of his priorities.

We can see how much these crimes have cost Macbeth. His reaction to Lady
Macbeth\'s death is a sign of complete despair-all feeling is dead in him. His
famous speech upon hearing of her suicide-"Tomorrow,........"(Act V Scene V
lines 17-28)-is less an expression of grief than it is about the utter
meaninglessness in life.

Another aspect of Macbeth is his active and vivid imagination. Considering
Duncan\'s murder, he can vivdly picture all the consequences. His imagination
pursues him throughout the play, continually reliving his crimes and fantasizing
about present and future possible dangers. Nothing Lady Macbeth says will
comfort his mind and bring peace to him even for a minute. At time he seems
crazy or haunted.

In retrospect, we see that Macbeth is primarily the victim of his own ambition,
supported by his active imaginations. The witches provide him with the idea of
being king, Lady Macbeth helps him overcome his natural hesitation to commit
murder, but Macbeth himself chooses between honor and the crown, between
salvation in the next world and material gain in this one. Figuratively speaking,
he chose to rule in Hell rather than serve in Heaven. Lady Macbeth, the iron
lady ended up to have some rust in her. Her consience caught up to her tormented
mind and had tortured it further, resulting in her suicide.

We cannot therefore say that Macbeth is just a butcher who murders in cold-blood.
He is tormented by his deeds, and he is never to enjoy the crown