This essay Lamb To The Slaughter & The Speckled Band has a total of 2044 words and 10 pages.
Lamb To The Slaughter & The Speckled Band
St. Patrick\'s Comprehensive
I am going to compare the following two short stories; "Lamb To the
Slaughter" by Roald Dahl and "The Speckled Band" by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle.
I will investigate these stories separately before comparing them.
The Speckled Band, written by the infamous Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, and
involves his two most famous creations: Sherlock Holmes and Dr Watson (Watson is a Doctor of the medical sense) it is story of murder, although this is not instantly apparent. The story is written in a first person view and is set as a sort of memoir by Watson (As is the other books) and it is set in the April of 1883, and begins in 21B
Baker Street in Greater London. Watson tells us he is only bringing the case to light because the person who had sworn him to secrecy recently passed away. It revolves around the untimely death of Helen Stoker at her family home, her sister reports the events to Holmes in hope of finding some sort of explanation
I get the impression Holmes and Watson are close because of the opening
quote by Watson;
"In glancing over my notes of the seventy odd cases in which I have during
the last eight years studied the methods of my friend Sherlock Holmes."
The use of the "My Friend" tells me that they are not only close in their
work, but also enjoy each others company socially, and this is further
backed up by the way they address each other, keeping a "professional
friendship" e.g.: when Holmes is telling Watson he is apprehensive about him
being there, as his life may be at risk, and Watson replies
"Can I be of assistance?"
"Your presence may be invaluable"
Watson then says that he will definitely accompany him. To me this is a not
only a gesture by Holmes to spare Watson from harm, but is also a show of
their friendship. Watson knows he could be harmed, but chooses to go as he
wishes to assist Holmes. They have not known each other for that long a period of time, as Holmes later refers to
“…a case that was before your time”
This indicates that they started of as two professionals, but soon developed the friendship they have today. The whole setting for the story is the mysterious death of Julia Stoker, the mystery around her death is what drives her sister Helen to go and seek Holmes’ help. Miss Stoker visits Holmes and Watson and pours out every detail of her life and of her sisters last movements to an eager Holmes, who deduces (Although we are not aware of it at this time) that there is only one suspect – Dr Grimsby Roylott, the “mild mannered” step father of the two sisters. A brief encounter with the man in question is all that is needed to confirm Holmes’ suspicions;
“What has she been saying to you?” Screamed the old man furiously.
“I know you, you scoundrel! I have heard of you before. You are Holmes the meddler, Holmes the busybody, Holmes the Scotland Yard jack-in-office”
At this point I did not think Dr Roylott was the prime suspect, when reading books or watching films I tend to avoid Litman’s Theory of “The most obvious answer is usually correct” I thought it was far too obvious that the murderer would be revealed at such and early stage. I later find out that it is not finding the killer that is the motive of the story, it is proving he is the killer. Although I realised that Roylott did have several not so ludicrous reasons to kill his stepdaughter:
§ Julia’s mother, who was considerably well off, had bequeathed her daughters not an entirely mediocre sum of money per year after they were married. This would decrease the amount he received. This then made Dr Roylott jealous.
§ One of the people whom he relied on to keep the house clean etc. was about to be taken away, and now he also has a motive for murdering Helen Stoker, as she is too engaged.
Although the motive is not completely backed up in the story, I believe this to be the true reason, it could have been that he did not
Topics Related to Lamb To The Slaughter & The Speckled Band
Sherlock Holmes, Fictional detectives, The Adventure of the Speckled Band, Dr. Watson, The Speckled Band, Canon of Sherlock Holmes, Professor Moriarty
Essays Related to Lamb To The Slaughter & The Speckled Band
Maigret And Then Toy VillageMaigret And Then Toy Village I read the book Maigret And Then Toy Village. I really liked this book. The Hound of the Baskervilles and Maigret And The Toy Village were very different. I liked Maigret And The Toy Village better than The Hound of the Baskervilles because it had more of a mysrery to it and it was more interesting. In the story The Hound of the Baskervilles the story hooked me because I learned the mystery in the beginning of the book. It made me want to learn more clues and more ab
Edgar Allen Poe's: The Murders in the Rue MorgueEdgar Allen Poe\'s: The Murders in the Rue Morgue In Edgar Allen Poe\'s short story, The Murders in the Rue Morgue, a classic detective story is played out in a seedy Paris suburb. The story begins as the narrator meets Monsieur C. Auguste Dupin, a poor but well-read young man. As they become close friends, they live together in seclusion, departing only briefly each evening to take introspective strolls along the dark Paris streets. Soon both the reader and the narrator begin to see Dupin\'
Edgar Allen Poe's Murders In the Rue MorgueEdgar Allen Poe\'s Murders In the Rue Morgue The Murders in the Rue Morgue In Edgar Allen Poe\'s short story, The Murders in the Rue Morgue, a classic detective story is played out in a seedy Paris suburb. The story begins as the narrator meets Monsieur C. Auguste Dupin, a poor but well-read young man. As they become close friends, they live together in seclusion, departing only briefly each evening to take introspective strolls along the dark Paris streets. Soon both the reader and the narr
Life Of Arthur Conan DoyleLife Of Arthur Conan Doyle Life of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, a British physician who later devoted his life to writing, has become one of the most popular and widespread authors and creators of all time. Doyle\'s early childhood years to his later years in life have allowed him to observe many sophisticated yet adventurous paths, in which have inspired him greatly to become an influence on spiritualistic views as an author and crusader. His interests and achievements in medi
Lamb To The Slaughter & The Speckled BandLamb To The Slaughter The Speckled Band St. Patrick\'s Comprehensive I am going to compare the following two short stories; Lamb To the Slaughter by Roald Dahl and The Speckled Band by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. I will investigate these stories separately before comparing them. The Speckled Band, written by the infamous Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, and involves his two most famous creations: SherlockHolmes and Dr Watson (Watson is a Doctor of the medical sense) it is story of murder, although this is n
Discuss the issues of publishing pictures that havDiscuss the issues of publishing pictures that have been altered using a computer. Picture and subject manipulations have been a part of photography since it was first invented. But because of computer technology, digital manipulations are relatively easy to accomplish, hard to detect and perhaps more alarming, alter the original image so that checking the authenticity of the picture is impossible. Some critics have predicted that in a few years, images -- whether still or moving -- will not be
What is Stevenson’s message about the dual natureWhat is Stevenson’s message about the dual nature of the human personality in The Strange Case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde? Throughout the novella, Robert Louis Stevenson gives the readers various different messages about the dual nature of the human personality, from the evil hidden beneath the goodness of man to the true inner id we all possess. To me, the basic message is that we are all evolved from primitive ‘ape-like’ creatures and the book metaphorically explores what would happen if we went
Holmes and PoirotHolmes and Poirot Mystery Literature Minor Paper 10/05/03 Both Sir Arthur Conan Doyle and Agatha Christie were pioneers in the mystery genre. Each used an above average if not extremely intelligent character co-stared by a run of the mill Joe. Doyles’ SherlockHolmes and Watson characters are a perfect combination of wit and ingenuity, likewise with Christies’ Mr. Hastings and Hucules Poirot from The Mysterious Affair At Styles. Doyles’ Final Problem is where Holmes is disenchanted because somew
A Scandal in BohemiaA Scandal in Bohemia The Adventures of SherlockHolmes was written by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. The novel was first published in 1892. A Scandal in Bohemia was a short story about a woman who has pictures of herself and a high English nobleman. She used them to blackmail him. Sir Arthur Conan Doyle was a novelist, a detective-story writer, and a physician. He was born on May 22, 1859 and died on July 7, 1930. He began writing The Adventures of SherlockHolmes in 1890 and finished writing it in 189
A Study in ScarletA Study in Scarlet A Study in Scarlet was written in 1887 by Sir Arthur Doyle. It was a mysterious case of love, murder, and revenge. Mr. SherlockHolmes and Dr. John Watson used the science of deduction to solve this mysterious case and catch the killer. The first section of the book took place in 1878 in London, England. SherlockHolmes and Dr. Watson shared an apartment together on 221b Baker street. The first murder was held in Lauriston Gardens. The second murder took place in Hallidays Pri
ForensicsForensics In this paper I will debating and discussing the distinct topics/ideas that go along with genetic engineering in forensics. First I will agitate the basics of forensics and forensic science is and what some of its uses are. Then I will discuss benefits , risks, ethical concerns with genetic engineering in forensics. Forensic science in its broadest definition is the application of science to law. Forensic science offers the knowledge and technology of science for the definition and enf
Sherlock HolmesSherlockHolmesSherlockHolmes stories have influenced all mystery stories one way or another. The structure in which they are written are the building block for all great mystery stories. I will show this though details found in three different SherlockHolmes stories and compare them to other stories and adventures. SherlockHolmes has a certain structure, which is present in every one of his stories. The first is that the main characters are always shown as doing nothing important. Then some
Sherlock HolmesSherlockHolmes Memoirs of SherlockHolmes, written by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, is a collection of SherlockHolmes short stories. “Silver Blaze”, “The Yellow Face”, “The Stock-Broker’s Clerk”, “The ‘Gloria Scott’”, “The Musgrave Ritual”, “The Reigate Puzzle”, “The Crooked Man”, “The Resident Patient”, “The Greek Interpreter”, “The Naval Treaty”, and “The Final Problem” are included. A lot of information about Holmes and Watson is included in this collection. There is some information which is sho
Edgar Allen PoeEdgar Allen Poe Born in Boston in 1809, Edgar Poe was destined to lead a rather somber and brief life, most of it a struggle against poverty. His mother died when Edgar was only two, his father already long disappeared. He was raised as a foster child in Virginia by Frances Allen and her husband John, a Richmond tobacco merchant. Poe later lived in Baltimore with his aunt, Maria Clemm and her daughter Virginia, whom he eventually married. The trio formed a household which moved to New York and t
The RainmakerThe Rainmaker The world is full of great novels. From SherlockHolmes to the three musketeers. As the years progress more novels are written and more money is made. John Grisham is a rising star in literature. His books have enticed readers and has given the people something good to read. What makes his books great is that they are so realistic. He applies his personal law and trial knowledge into the books he writes. What it is about ? It was his last semester of law school. Rudy Baylor was ass