This essay "Judge orders couple not to have children" has a total of 639 words and 3 pages.
"Judge orders couple not to have children"
Judge Marilyn O'Connor declared on March 31 that both parents "should not have yet another child which must be cared for at public expense". Quite a dillemma in the courts this past week since the judge is basically denying the couples constituional rights to bear children. The judge's logic behind the ruling is basically saying that once a couple or family can not care for their children it should be be a burden on the government to care for those children. However, this ruling is quite controversial because there is no precedent of any kind for this type of case, so it is quite possible that it could be taken all the way up to the supreme court. The judge feels that due to the incapability of both parents to properly care for their children they should not have anymore children. If they do conceive another child the couple may choose to be sterilized at no cost to them. The judge is also not forcing the couple to use condoms or any other contraception.
The problem here is simple, it is unconstitutional. "I don't know of any precedent that would permit a judge to do this, and even if there were a precendent, it woudl be blatantly unconstitutional because it violates the United States Constituion and the New York Constitution." said Anna Schissel, staff attorney for the Reproducted Rights Project of the New York Civil Liberties Union. If this ruling is unconstituional it will be overturned, however the dilemma of this case is the moral guardian issues. The parents are obviously unable to care for these children properly and all of the children have been tested positive for cocaine.
Moreover, since this case is quite controversial it is quite likely that it will be appealed to the supreme court. If it does go to the supreme court it will most likely be ruled unconstituional, however the bigger question is if it is ruled unconstituional will the supreme court push for some kind of amendment? As far as legal dilemmas go this case is clear; it is simply unconstituional. Even if it was constitutional there is really no way to enforce the ruling made by the judge. "..not sure how the ruling could be enforced." said Attorney Chris Affronti, who cairs the family law section of the Monroe County Bar Association.
Reflection. I think this case is rather quite interesting it is true that it is unconstituional, however since the parents are so neglectful and the children have been tested positive for cocaine I think the couple shouldn't be allowed to have children until they can care for themselves. Having children is a privledge, at least I think so if the parents are unable to care for the children properly it shouldn't be the responsibility of the government to keep caring for additional children. "Both parents had a history of drug abuse." It is quite obvious that the parents are neglectful.
"The mother was found to have neglected her four children, ages 1, 2, 4, and 5. All three children who were tested for cocain tested positive, according to court papers." If as a parent you can't properly care for children I don't think you should be allowed to have them. Nor should it be the burden of the government to continue to care for the children you are continuing to neglect. "This court believes the constitutional right to have children is overcome when society must bear the financial and everyday burden of care." The judge said at the ruling of the case. And since the mother is having another child that will most likely go up for foster care I see no point in starting the process all over again.
Topics Related to "Judge orders couple not to have children"
Law, Legal citation, Precedent, Philosophy of law, Political engineering, LGBT adoption in the United States
Essays Related to "Judge orders couple not to have children"
Lord of the Flies Book ReportLord of the Flies Book Report Gregory Lovell 5669 Wider Reading Project Title : The Lord of the Flies Author : William Golding Summary One fact about this book should be established from the start - this is not a children\'s book. The littluns and bigguns represent members of the human race. The conflict between law and barbarism would have, I believe to be the same had the island been inhabited with adult survivors instead of children. The novel is about a transition from an immensely excit
Lord Of The Flies by William GoldingLord Of The Flies by William Golding About the author Sir William Golding (1911-1993), was an English novelist who wrote exciting adventure stories who deal with the conflict between mind and instinct. William Gerald Golding was born in St. Columb Minor, in Cornwall. He was knighted in 1988. His novels are moral fables that reveal how dangerous and destructive human brings may be unless they are restrained by conscience. Golding won the 1983 Nobel Prize for literature. His most famous book, Lor
Lord Of The FliesLord Of The Flies In Lord of the Flies, a novel by William Golding, an airplane load of school-age boys are stranded on a deserted tropical island after their plane is accidentally shot down during World War II. Since there are no adults, the boys try to organize themselves with a chief, hunters, and a few people to watch a signal fire for any ships that might pass. Factions develop with the original group and the hunters. The child who is chosen to be the chief is Ralph. As the leader of the hu
LordofthefliesLordoftheflies Charlemagne Charlemagne, also known as Charles the Great, became the undisputed ruler of Western Europe. As Western Europe was deteriorating Charlemagne was crowned the privilege of being joint king of the Franks in 768 A.D. People of Western Europe, excluding the church followers, had all but forgotten the great gifts of education and arts that they had possessed at one time. Charlemagne solidly defeated barbarians and kings in identical fashion during his reign. Using the re-est
Lucifer In StarlightLucifer In Starlight Lucifer in the Spotlight Examining a poem in detail can bring out new meanings and ideas. By careful analysis, the full beauty of the poem can be appreciated. The poem Lucifer in Starlight (p. 959), by George Meredith, can be analyzed to refine the authors purpose, by examining every subtle hint, every possibility, for a deeper theme. Also, deciphering formal literary techniques such as metaphor, connotation, and symbolism is the key to unlock other expressions. The main
M ButterflyM Butterfly RIUve played out the events of my life night after night, always searching for a new ending to my story, one where I will leave this cell and return forever to my ButterflyUs arms.S (Hwang 3.3.1-4) With these words of David Henry HwangUs play M Butterfly, we realize that we have just been staring directly into the memories of Rene Gallimard. The fact that Rene Gallimard serves as the narrator of his memories in the play M Butterfly delivers an impression of the character behind Galli
MacbethMacbeth MACBETH Macbeth is presented as a mature man of definitely established character, successful in certain fields of activity and enjoying an enviable reputation. We must not conclude, there, that all his volitions and actions are predictable; Macbeth\'s character, like any other man\'s at a given moment, is what is being made out of potentialities plus environment, and no one, not even Macbeth himself, can know all his inordinate self- love whose actions are discovered to be-and no doubt h
EqualityEquality In 1890, less then one half of one percent of women were employed gainfully outside of the home. Over the next hundred years, women have not only gained access to jobs outside of the home, but also fought for equality in the work place. These struggles have not been easy by any means. Women have overcome many obstacles in there journey into the work force, none grater then the views of their male piers. Many males thought and continue to think that there is no place for women in the wor
Mafor Themes in Faulkner's Light in AugustMafor Themes in Faulkner\'s Light in August Major themes in Faulkner’s Light in August Light In August: A Study of 20th Century Man\'s Search for Self A Study of the Origins of Evil...a man\'s future is inherent in that man... -Faulkner in the University. p.139 Faulkner\'s Light in August is a metaphor. In fact it is many metaphors, almost infinitely many. It is a jumble of allusions, themes, portraits, all of them uniquely important, many of them totally unrelated. In fact no 20th century wri
Major Themes In Faulkner’s Light In AugustMajor Themes In Faulkner’s Light In August Light In August: A Study of 20th Century Man\'s Search for Self A Study of the Origins of Evil ...a man\'s future is inherent in that man... -Faulkner in the University. p.139 Faulkner\'s Light in August is a metaphor. In fact it is many metaphors, almost infinitely many. It is a jumble of allusions, themes, portraits, all of them uniquely important, many of them totally unrelated. In fact no 20th century writer has even approached the sheer quantity of
Marching OnMarching On The novel The Long March by William Styron is a prime example of anti-war, anti-goverment, and anti-military writing. William Styron uses marine reserves, that are forced to make a 36 mile march that they are not prepared for, to show the brutality and hypocrisy in the leaders of this country. The reserves are people that have been out of the service for many years, but have just been called back into service. A terrible accident has just occured at the base they are stationed at. A
Gender InequalityGender Inequality The issue of gender inequality is one which has been publicly reverberating through society for decades. The problem of inequality in employment being one of the most pressing issues today. In order to examine this situation one must try to get to the root of the problem and must understand the sociological factors that cause women to have a much more difficult time getting the same benefits, wages, and job opportunities as their male counterparts. The society in which we live
Merchant of VeniceMerchant of Venice -The Merchant of Venice- Shakespeare’s The Merchant of Venice is still relevant today because it deals with issues which still affect us. Show how two of those issues are discussed in the play. Throughout the play a distinction is made between how things appear on the outside and how they are in reality, or on the inside. The issue of appearance versus reality is demonstrated in varied ways, mainly by the use of real-life situations. The first representation of this is Shylo
Methods of control ( curfew )Methods of control ( curfew ) Methods of Control BY Makeveli There are various ways of controlling things. Things such as: money, kids, pets criminals etc . . . Some things cannot be controlled; things such as: time and mother nature. We can although control time in a certain way. In our civilization we have set a method of the way we use time. Time is a method of control to keep things from going chaotic. Take for instance: Curfew. Curfew is a conflict of underage adolescence, the law, and some
Mexico And BordersMexico And Borders International borders have always been centers of conflict, and the U.S.-Mexican border is no exception. With the European colonizing the New World, it was a matter of time before the powers collided. The Spanish settled what is today Mexico, while the English settled what is to day the United States. When the two colonial powers did meet what is today the United States’ Southwest, it was not England and Spain. Rather the two powers were the United States and Mexico. Both Coun
Mid Life CrisisMid Life Crisis Mid-Life Crisis In Horst Stern’s The Last Hunt, a man named Joop is portrayed as a professional worker in a very well known bank. Outside of being a banker, Joop enjoys to hunt wild animals. This has been a hobby of his since he was a young boy. Throughout the story many questions are raised about Joop’s true feelings about his job, hunting, and his life. In the beginning of the story, a women walks in on Joop while he is staring at a picture on a wall in his office. The women is
Moral Destruction In The Great GatsbyMoral Destruction In The Great Gatsby The Great Gatsby: The Destruction of Morals In The Great Gatsby, the author F. Scott Fitzgerald shows the destruction of morals in society. The characters in this novel, all lose their morals in attempt to find their desired place in the social world. They trade their beliefs for the hope of being acceptance. Myrtle believes she can scorn her true social class in an attempt to be accepted into Ton\'s, Jay Gatsby who bases his whole life on buying love with w
Morals And Psychological Aspects in Jane EyreMorals And Psychological Aspects in Jane Eyre Morals And Psychological Aspects in Jane Eyre Jane Eyre takes the idea of a fairy tale a step further by adding psychological aspects to the story. Jane did the right thing in regards to marrying Mr. Rochester because what is [considered] morally wrong cannot be psychologically right. In other words, Jane\'s moral values told her what Mr. Rochester had done wrong. Because of this she cannot psychologically go along with it as if nothing was wrong
My Great-Grandmother was not a PersonMy Great-Grandmother was not a Person My Great-Grandmother was not a person. Neither was yours. Up until about 67 years ago no females were. We were supposed to be pregnant and barefoot in the kitchen. At least that\'s the perception that the laws enforced. (For ex: The Election Act of the Dominion of Canada and The Common Law of England) As part of the British Commonwealth many of our laws were the same as England\'s and enforced by British parliament. One such law from the Common Law of Englan
Music CensorshipMusic Censorship Marilyn Manson, The Beatles, NWA, Garth Brooks, and the king, Elvis, What do all these people have in common? Well, yes, they are all musical groups, but there is something more. Marilyn Manson is a heavy metal group who worships Satan, the Beatles were one of the greatest Rock N’ Roll bands of all time, and NWA was a hard-core rap group from the 80’s. Garth Brooks is a country singer and greatest selling performer of all time, and well, Elvis is the king of Rock N’ Roll. So wha
My Experience with English EducationMy Experience with English Education My Experience with English Education English has never been my favorite subject. In fact, it has always been my least favorite subject. Going through school, I often wondered why I needed to do so many English related tasks, and in wondering, I learned to detest the subject without realizing its future benefits. Why do I dislike English so much? Is it such a dreadful thing to learn? Isn’t learning how to correctly write and interpret the English language impo
My First MurderMy First Murder I committed my first murder at the age of twelve. I had killed before, but before there were always motives such as self defense and protection of property. On December 25, 1991, however, I killed for the carnal sake of killing. Taking this life did not feel wrong until the fraction of a second after it was too late. I remember vividly the pride I felt in my steady aim, the rifle-sights barely moving from the tiny target I had chosen, and then the crushing suffocation which repla
The Prevalent Issues of Surrogate ParentingThe Prevalent Issues of Surrogate Parenting Surrogate parenting refers to an arrangement between a married couple who is unable to have a child because of the wife\'s infertility and a fertile woman who agrees to conceive the husband\'s child through artificial insemination, carry it to term, then surrender all parental rights in the child. Often, the surrogate mother receives compensation for her services. The final step in the process is typically the father\'s acknowledgment of paternity and
Nathaniel Hawthorne Weaves Dreams Into Much of HisNathaniel Hawthorne Weaves Dreams Into Much of His 19th Century Prose ENG 1015, Sec. 331 March 19, 1997 Nathaniel Hawthorne Weaves Dreams into Reality in Much of His 19th Century Prose Nathaniel Hawthorne, a master of American fiction, often utilizes dreams within the annals of his writings to penetrate, explore and express his perceptions of the complex moral and spiritual conflicts that plague mankind. His clever, yet crucial purpose for using dreams is to represent, through symbolism, the hum
Native Canadians in LiteratureNative Canadians in Literature Introduction: Literature offers a strong and passionate voice for the past. The literature of the Native Canadian is a voice we, the people of Canada, can no longer ignore. There is little to be gained by dwelling on the past. Nevertheless, there is much to be realized by accepting what has passed, with all of its mistakes and dust we might otherwise wish to hide under the carpets. English literature, since at least the sixteenth century, has a firm grounding in Ca
Sexual HarassmentSexual Harassment Sexual harassment is not about sex, it is about power. -Gretchen Morgenson An unwanted sexual advance, an offensive touch, and suggestive comments illustrate examples of sexual harassment. Sexual harassment is defined by Stephanie Riger as, unwanted sexually oriented behavior in a work context. However, sexual harassment does not only appear in an occupational environment, and this form of harassment is not limited to a specific race, a specific gender, or any certain lifes
Rights of Egyptian WomenRights of Egyptian Women Throughout written history, women have experienced status subservient to the men they lived with. Generally, most cultures known to modern historians followed a standard pattern of males assigned the role of protector and provider while women were assigned roles of domestic servitude. Scholars speculate endlessly at the cause: biology, religion, social custom. Nevertheless, the women were always subordinated to the men in their culture. Through their artwork, tomb inscri
Nonviolent ResistanceNonviolent Resistance NONVIOLENT RESISTANCE In Martin Luther King, Jr.¹s selection, Nonviolent Resistance which first appeared in 1958 as a part of his book Stride Towards Freedom, he describes the processes people follow as they confront their situation. There are three ways he explained how oppressed people can deal with their situation. The different processes that are opened to the oppressed people are acquiescence, violence, and nonviolent resistance. Martin Luther King, Jr. does not approv
Oedipus's CrimeOedipus\'s Crime What Was Oedipus’s Crime? Oedipus, ruler of Thebes, murdered his father and married his mother. Such acts are almost always deemed unnatural and criminal; they are not tolerated within traditional society. A person who has committed these illegal acts of murder and incest would be considered a criminal, yet Sophocles’s character, Oedipus, is not guilty of either crime. Prior to the birth of Oedipus, a prophecy was spoken over Laius and his wife Jocasta. They were told that their
Sex DiscriminationSex Discrimination Despite Legislation for Equal Opportunities, sexism is still in evidence in the workplace. Sexism is a particular concern for society when considering it\'s effect in the workplace. Sexism has always been a particular problem in the labour market especially with the formation of capitalism. In the last half of the 20th century this has been especially highlighted due to the increase of woman entering the labour market. This aroused the need for a legislation for equal opportun
On the left sideOn the left side On the left side: B: The story takes place in Conn -- a town in western Ireland - during the 1980s. Conn is a rather conservative town with many farmers and shop owners. All of the conservatives are sitting on the right side during Sunday Mass while the principal character and nine other sinners are sitting on the left side. It is easy to see which part of the congregation Farther O\'Rourke likes most, since electric heaters have been installed in the right side of the church. F
Orwell's thoughts on TotalitarianismOrwell\'s thoughts on Totalitarianism V Orwell\'s thoughts on Totalitarianism A. From life experiences B. From a writers point of view VI Conclusion Introduction Orwell observed that every line of serious work that I have written since 1936 has been written directly or indirectly, against totalitarianism and for democratic socialism, as I understand it (George Orwell). George Orwell has been a major contributor to anticommunist literature around the World War II period. Orwell lived in Engla
Patriarchy in Kefka's Metamorphsis and Asian CultuPatriarchy in Kefka\'s Metamorphsis and Asian Cultures (Although most cultures cannot be generalized with certain behaviours, however, certain Japanese traditions and values are common to all their people and is taught to them from a very early age. The practice of having the son of a family to look after his parents, as mentioned later, is common to both Japanese and Chinese cultures.) In our studies of European literature, we can see that patriarchy, that is, the supremacy of the father in a f
Politcal Allegory Term Paper Of 1984- By OrwellPolitcal Allegory Term Paper Of 1984- By Orwell The Political allegory of George Orwell\'s 1984 In 1984, by George Orwell, the reader sees a primary theme of political allegory and satire. Orwell is presenting the world of 1984 as a satiric statement of what might come to pass, though of course its exact form could never be predicted, if the world did not become aware of the terrible problems facing it, not in 1984, but here and now. Orwell wrote the novel not as a prediction, but as a warning.
Professional ysis of Published WorksProfessional ysis of Published Works Professional ysis of Published Works Professional columnists have often enjoyed the luxury of an additional writer to verify their work. This person is usually an editor or proofreader. Each day, millions of pages of text are scrutinized for accuracy by the public. Many times, people have read through an article and found an error in syntax or spelling. It almost appears to be a rewarding experience for the reader to discover an error in professional works. I
ProhibitionProhibition Prohibition Prohibition is considered as a period of time in the 1920’s when alcohol was controlled by the government. Alcohol, at this time in history, was illegal unless for medical or industrial purposes. This government control came about because of the fact that people were drinking too much and “destroying the moral fiber of America” (Martin 76) Alcohol has been part of American society since the colonist came over on the Mayflower. At that time, alcohol was safer to drink that
Public exposure ( a letter to a newspaper's editorPublic exposure ( a letter to a newspaper\'s editor) Dear Sir I\'m writing to you because I want to publicly express my thoughts about a very serious problem, a problem which tortures our society.I\'m talking about young offenders, those of about 16-18 years old who seem to be the cause of a big part of the crime which keeps going on.These juveniles do just about anything to cause trouble: vandalism, burglaries, kerb-crawling.... the list is endless. And what do WE do?We arrest them, put them in
Puritan BeliefsPuritan Beliefs Puritan Beliefs When people hear the word Puritan, one will notice faces of displeasure, because nobody wants to hear about these uptight people. Our misconceptions of these people have spread all over America, when in fact these peoples\' morals and beliefs are what shaped our nation today. If one looks deeper into puritan meditations they will find that these people were not just uptight people. Stereotypes that we have can be easily altered by actually reading Puritan literatu
Presidents and Affirmative ActionPresidents and Affirmative Action In 1965, President Lyndon B. Johnson issued Executive Order #11246 at Howard University that required federal contractors to undertake affirmative action to increase the number of minorities that they employ. He wanted to ensure that minorities were recruited to have real opportunities to be hired and then eventually get a promotion. In 1969, the Department of Labor exposed widespread racial discrimination of the Construction Department so President Richard M. N
The music rap only a decade and a haft old , finalRap The music rap only a decade and a haft old , finally notice by the world in 1990 as real music had has its real downfall with violence and corruption that surounds this new kind of music. Its gotten so bad 1/20 people that listen to rap has run into the law that been influence by listening to music.That in order to stop all this violence that involves rap we must learn to understand were their coming from why the offending lyrics. 2 years ago a rapper named Ice Cube(O\'shea Jackson) sang at
America and Affirmative ActionAmerica and Affirmative Action Affirmative action has been the subject of increasing debate and tension in American society. However, the debate over affirmative action has become ensnared in rhetoric that pits equality of opportunity against the equality of results. The debate has been more emotional than intellectual, and has generated more tension than shed light on the issue. Participants in the debate have over examined the ethical and moral issues that affirmative action raises while forge
Reality, Illusion, and Foolish PrideReality, Illusion, and Foolish Pride Reality, Illusion, and Foolish Pride Chandler Friedman English 231 Dr. Clark Lemons In the plays The Cherry Orchard by Anton Chekhov, A Doll\'s House by Henrik Ibsen, and Galileo by Bertolt Brecht, the protagonists\' mental beliefs combine reality and illusion that both shape the plot of each respective story. The ability of the characters to reject or accept an illusion, along with the foolish pride that motivated their decision, leads to their personal down
Reclaiming the lost virtues in AmericaReclaiming the lost virtues in America Respect Many people have ideas on how to reclaim the virtue and morality that made America a great nation. However, the only sure way that everyone can achieve this goal is if parents start teaching and demonstrating respect to their kids. The dictionary defines respect as- “to have regard for the quality of a person” or “to refrain from obtruding upon or interfering with”. The problem with society today is that there is a complete lack of respect. The lack
Repressive Governments in Zamiatin's We and OrwellRepressive Governments in Zamiatin\'s We and Orwell\'s 1984 The Repressive Governments of Zamiatin\'s We and Orwell\'s 1984 Benjamin Bulloch Outline: Thesis: Both Zamiatin\'s We and Orwell\'s 1984 have governments that repress actions and thoughts through the use of physical and psychological force. I. Intro. II. We\'s Government\'s Use of Psychological Force A. Number system B. Sexual Registration III. 1984\'s Governments Use of Psychological Force A. Newspeak B. Doublethink IV. Both Government
Responsible DrivingResponsible Driving Responsible Driving Imagine a crowd of 44,000 people in the stands at a World Series or Super Bowl game. A television camera scans the individual faces --- some exuberant, some anxious --- all sports fans out for a good time. As many people as are in that crowd will die in highway accidents this year. More than half of those accidents will involve alcohol, alone or in combination with other drugs. A disproportionate number of the dead will be young, between the ages of 15 an
Revenge In HamletRevenge In Hamlet The Presence of Revenge in Hamlet Revenge is a major theme in the Tragedy of Hamlet. In the play Hamlet, by William Shakespeare, the theme of revenge is repeated numerous times throughout the play and involves a great deal of characters. Of these characters, eight are dead by the end of the play by result of murder which was initiated through revenge. Shakespeare uses the revenge theme to create conflict among many characters. Revenge causes one to act blindly through anger, ra
Biography and History: Harriet Jacob's The Life ofBiography and History: Harriet Jacob\'s The Life of a Slave Girl To be a good writer, you must posess a careful balance between detachment and association, a delicate waltz where you are not so wrapped up in the events of a story that it alienates the reader, and yet not so far separated from the subject matter that the readers cannot get into it. This is espectially the case in an autobiographical narrative. In this case, it is very difficult to detach yourself from the main subject matter, tha
Review- Thomas Cahill's How the Irish Saved CiviliReview- Thomas Cahill\'s How the Irish Saved Civilization Thomas Cahill opens his story describing Rome’s fall, “For as the Roman Empire fell, as all through Europe matted, unwashed barbarians descended on the Roman cities, looting artifacts and burning books, the Irish who were just learning to read and write, took up the just labor of copying all of western literature - everything they could get their hands on. These scribes then served as conduits through which Greco-Roman and Judeo-Christian
Richard IIIRichard III 1. The tragedy of Richard III lies in the progressive isolation of its protagonist . Discuss. From the very opening of the play when Richard III enters solus , the protagonist\'s isolation is made clear. Richard\'s isolation progresses as he separates himself from the other characters and breaks the natural bonds between Man and nature through his efforts to gain power. The first scene of the play begins with a soliloquy, which emphasizes Richard\'s physical isolation as he appears a
Robert F KennedyRobert F Kennedy Robert Francis (“Bobby”) Kennedy Robert F. Kennedy was born in 1925 in Brookline Massachusetts , and was raised with traditional family values. He was a true patriot, with a strong sense of nationalism. While Attending Harvard University, he saw that his country needed his help, so he put his undergraduate studies on hold to serve his country’s Navy in World War II. When he returned home, he finished his Bachelor’s degree at Harvard, and received an LL.B. from the university of