This essay Hopkins Case has a total of 1840 words and 13 pages.
Ann Hopkins was an accomplished college professor, mathematical physicist, and systems management consultant working at Hollins College, IBM, NASA and the accounting firm of Touch Ross. In August of 1978 Hopkins began working for Price Waterhouse (PW), another national accounting firm as a manager in the Management Advisory Services.
PW specialized in auditing, tax and management consulting with offices worldwide. The partnership ranks included 662 partners in the United States and approximately 2600 partners worldwide.
The partners were elected by the senior partner and a policy board through a formal, annual nomination and review process, which was followed by a partnership-wide vote. Once partnership was attained, it was in essence a lifetime appointment with very few exceptions.
Nominated for partner in August of 1982, Hopkins was rejected and eventually told she would never make partner at PW. Her fellow partnership class consisted of 87 other candidates of which Hopkins was the only woman. Of the nominated class, 47 were offered partnership, 21 were rejected and 20, including Hopkins, were placed on “Hold.” Hopkins was later told that it was unlikely she would ever be selected as a partner. She subsequently quit PW and filed suite against the partnership alleging gender based discrimination.
During her employment with Price Waterhouse Hopkins proved herself a capable, dedicated employee. She generated more billable hours than any other candidate in her partnership class. She also had a record of securing major contracts that far exceeded those of her contemporaries.
When Hopkins investigated the reasoning for her “hold” status she was told that much of the decision was based on her interpersonal skills, or lack there of, when working with co-workers and clients. One partner criticized Hopkins for acting too "macho" while another claimed that she "overcompensated for being a woman." Yet another partner suggested that Hopkins "take a course at charm school," and the firm\'s Policy Board, after informing Hopkins of her rejection, recommended that she "walk, talk, dress and appear more feminine.”
There were other comments made from many of the people Hopkins had worked with during her time at PW. Many of these were concerned with her lack of staff management skills. Over all, Hopkins reviews were mixed. She demonstrated excellent drive and task accomplishment, but had the tendency to push her staff too hard and didn’t show the tact expected of a partner.
Did PW violate employment law by passing Hopkins over for promotion?
Were any of Hopkins’ civil rights violated?
United States labor laws are designed to protect workers from unfair acts of management. These laws deal primarily with the circumstances under which an employee can be terminated, what rights workers have to organize, and how management and labor should deal with one another as well as other protections against reprisals against employees for certain acts. The circumstances in the Hopkins case are not concerned with any of these practices and do not raise an issue under these statues.
The Civil Rights Act of 1964 (CRA) is an important piece of legislation that attempts to end discrimination against members of a protected class, which includes discrimination based on color, religion, race, sex and national origin. In this case it is necessary to determine if sex/gender was a factor in the denial of promotion.
The case indicates Hopkins had a mixed record of success while with PW. Hopkins’ record shows she was able to complete tasks and in many cases exceeded her peers in measurable results in both billable hours and engagement procurement. The record also shows that there were doubts about her ability to function effectively as a partner. She was noted to lack interpersonal skills required of partners and showed a tendency toward abuse of subordinates. Had this been the only criterion evidenced during the selection process, Hopkins would have been denied partnership and would have most likely not sought or gained legal recourse. Unfortunately for PW, it was not.
Hopkins was noted for being “rough on people” by one partner in his general comments and offered the opinion that this might be because she “may have overcompensated for being a woman.”
Another of the partners Hopkins worked with advised her to, “soften her image in the in which
Topics Related to Hopkins Case
Ann Hopkins, PricewaterhouseCoopers, Disparate treatment
Essays Related to Hopkins Case
Sex Education And The ClassroomSex Education And The Classroom In today\'s society there is an on going debate over sex education and its influence on our children. The question is no longer should sex education be taught, but rather how it should be taught (DeCarlo). With teenage pregnancy rates higher than ever and the imminent threat of the contraction of STD\'s, such as HIV, the role of sex education in the school is of greater importance now then ever before. By denying children sex education you are in a sense shelterin
Lincoln - Douglas DebateLincoln - Douglas Debate Affirmative Case Introduction- We must use every tool of diplomacy and law we have available, while maintaining both the capacity and the resolve to defend freedom. We must have the vision to explore new avenues when familiar ones seem closed. And we must go forward with a will as great as our goal – to build a practical peace that will endure through the remaining years of this century and far into the next.” Because I believe so strongly in the words of U.S. Secretary
The Different Conceptions of the Veil in The SoulsThe Different Conceptions of the Veil in The Souls of Black Folk For now we see through a glass, darkly -Isiah 25:7 W.E.B. Du Bois\'s Souls of Black Folk, a collection of autobiographical and historical essays contains many themes. There is the theme of souls and their attainment of consciousness, the theme of double consciousness and the duality and bifurcation of black life and culture; but one of the most striking themes is that of the veil. The veil provides a link between the 14 seeming
The Different Conceptions of the Veil in The SoulsThe Different Conceptions of the Veil in The Souls of Black F For now we see through a glass, darkly -Isiah 25:7 W.E.B. Du Bois\'s Souls of Black Folk, a collection of autobiographical and historical essays contains many themes. There is the theme of souls and their attainment of consciousness, the theme of double consciousness and the duality and bifurcation of black life and culture; but one of the most striking themes is that of the veil. The veil provides a link between the 14 s
Hopkins CaseHopkins Case Facts: AnnHopkins was an accomplished college professor, mathematical physicist, and systems management consultant working at Hollins College, IBM, NASA and the accounting firm of Touch Ross. In August of 1978 Hopkins began working for Price Waterhouse (PW), another national accounting firm as a manager in the Management Advisory Services. PW specialized in auditing, tax and management consulting with offices worldwide. The partnership ranks included 662 partners in the United Stat
E. E. CummingsE. E. Cummings In the early twentieth century, an unfamiliar face arose with an unusual style of writing. His name was Edward Estlin Cummings. As a young man, Cummings wrote many poems and a few plays that would later be published. He enjoyed painting, which was also a reflection of his writing, and developed a style that was unique in any time period because it defied all rules of grammar and syntax. He used ambiguity as a means to open peoples\' minds and challenge their intellect and to expre
Unequal Representation: Membership Input and InterUnequal Representation: Membership Input and Interest Group Decision-Making Introduction Interest groups play a key mediating and representational role in politics. In the theory of pluralist politics, organized groups represent the interests of varied segments of society in the national policy process. These groups organize to represent the views of their members in the halls of Congress, administrative agencies, and federal courthouses, giving voice to their members\' interests in all policy m
The CrucibleThe Crucible INTRODUCTION The Crucible by Arthur Miller was written during the early 1950s at the time of Senator Joseph McCarthy\'s House Un-American Activities Committee hearings on the infiltration of Communism in the United States and the loyalty to democracy of many prominent U.S. citizens. The McCarthy hearings pitted artists and performers against each other as they were called to testify about their own loyalty and what they knew about the loyalty of others. Although some critics have su