This essay Franklin Delano Roosevelt has a total of 724 words and 4 pages.
Franklin Delano Roosevelt
Franklin Delano Roosevelt is one of our countries best known and most
beloved presidents. He is commonly remembered for taking a tired, beaten,
nation and instilling hope in it. This positive view of Roosevelt is held
by Burns, who paints the picture of a man whose goal was to alleviate our
nation\'s economic pains. But, is this view too myopic? Is Roosevelt
deserving of such a godly reputation? These questions are posed by Conkin
as he points out the discrimination that underlies many New Deal programs,
and even suggests that many of Roosevelt\'s actions were for purely political
During the weeks preceding Roosevelt\'s inauguration the country was engaged
in an economic crisis that was quickly spiraling downward. Banks failed,
people panicked, and the nation looked to someone, anyone, for help.
Hoover, sensing the country\'s desperation, but realizing his lack of power,
and the feelings of resentment harbored towards him looked to Roosevelt. He
asked the president-elect to join in economic planning, support policies,
and most importantly to reassure the nation. While both authors note
Roosevelt\'s unwillingness to cooperate with Hoover they site different
reasons for it. Burns talks of Roosevelt\'s belief that the nation was not
yet his domain, and that Hoover had the authority to handle the situation.
In addition, Burns excuses Roosevelt by maintaining "Roosevelt did not
foresee that the banking situation would reach a dramatic climax on
Inauguration day. No man could have." (P. 148) This position is an
exceedingly benevolent one when contrasted with Conkin\'s who writes
Roosevelt "did nothing, and helplessly watched the economy collapse, letting
it appear as one last result of Republican incompetence." This measure
allowed Roosevelt to emerge as the "nation\'s savior," and ally the
Democratic party with this image.
Furthermore, the two authors differ in their assessment of the effect
of public opinion on Roosevelt\'s actions. Burns gives the impression of a
president who looked to engage all in his coalition. He states,
politically, his cabinet "catered to almost every major group." Burns also
adds, "Roosevelt did not slavishly follow the wishes of group leaders." (P.
150). Roosevelt is portrayed as the paragon of a humanitarian, "he wanted
to help the underdog, though not necessarily at the expense of the top dog.
He believed that private, special interests must be subordinated to the
general interest." (P. 155)
Conkin attempts to poke holes in this idealistic portrayal of Roosevelt.
Conversely, Conkin implies that many of Roosevelt\'s programs helped the top
dog, at the expense of the underdog. He argues, many New Deal programs
such as the AAA and NRA, ignoreed the plight of the common American, while
helping the politically more influencial sectors of the population.
Similarly, many programs such as the Wagner Act, Social Security, and the
AAA did not apply to migrant labors: those with the least political clout,
and a comparatively low rate of voter turnout.
I have come to be a believer in many of the arguments made by Conkin.
While Burns spends much time praising Roosevelt and focusing on his
successes, he ignores to talk about the non-existent benefits that the New
Deal brought to a significant percentage of the population. He does not
focus on Roosevelt\'s policy towards blacks. Why? Because Roosevelt\'s
programs typically did not aid this sector of the population. As noted by
Conkin Roosevelt\'s AAA led to an increase in unemployment among blacks, and
Roosevelt refused to support an anti-lynching bill, fearing that his support
would alienate the white Southern Democratic vote. My support for Burns\'
opinion is strengthened by my additional outside knowledge. Roosevelt\'s
programs such as the CCC and PWA were not designed, to and mainly did not
include women. Moreover, under the Roosevelt administration a law enacted
which legally allowed only one family member to hold any type of job, this
measure essentially kicked married women out of the workforce.
I think Conkin\'s argument is much more concrete than Burns\'. While Burns
focuses on high figurative language to praise Roosevelt, Conkin gives the
reader concrete examples that serve to cast doubt on this demi-god image of
the former president. What must be understood is that Conkin does not go as
far as to denounce Roosevelt as a leader, he merely makes us look at some of
the short comings of "the New Deal President." To quote Conkin, the man who
in my opinion said it best, "To call Roosevelt a dictator is as
meaningless as calling him a demigod."
Topics Related to Franklin Delano Roosevelt
Delano family, Freemen of the City of London, Sons of the American Revolution, United States Assistant Secretaries of the Navy, Livingston family, Franklin D. Roosevelt, New Deal, Theodore Roosevelt
Essays Related to Franklin Delano Roosevelt
The DepressionThe Depression Imagine for a moment, waking up one day to find yourself on a dirty floor, a pile of rags, or maybe even the street. You look down at yourself to find you\'re wearing the same clothes you wore yesterday, except they are completely filthy and have lots of holes in places like the knees and elbows. You have no access to a mirror to show you what you look like so you go to touch you hair with your hand and find it to be a pile of grease and dirt that obviously hasn\'t been washed in
Biography Of Franklin Delano RooseveltBiography Of Franklin Delano Roosevelt Biography of Franklin Delano Roosevelt Roosevelt was born at his family’s estate at Hyde Park, in Dutchess County, New York on January 30,1882. He was the only child of James Roosevelt and Sara Delano Roosevelt. James Roosevelt was a moderately successful businessman, with a variety of investments and a special interest in coal. He was also a conservative Democrat who was interested in politics. His home overlooking the Hudson River was comfortable without
Eleanor RooseveltEleanor Roosevelt Eleanor Roosevelt was a honest person who had responsibility and compassion towards her husband , family and her fellow man, whatever their social status. She used great citizenship and initiative actions in dealing with anyone who was fortunate enough to make her acquaintance. Eleanor Roosevelt is an outspoken advocate of social justice. During the years she has taken over a lot of responsibility. For someone who spent thefirst third of her life as shy and timid, she showed gr
RooseveltRoosevelt Franklin Delano Roosevelt, (1882-1945), 32nd of the United States. Roosevelt became president in March 1933 at the depth of the Great Depression, was reelected for an unprecedented three more terms, and died in office in April 1945, less than a month before the surrender of Germany in World War II. Despite an attack of poliomyelitis, which paralyzed his legs in 1921, he was a charismatic optimist whose confidence helped sustain the American people during the strains of economic crisis
FDR's Influence as president Some have called himFDR FDR\'s Influence as president Some have called him the best president yet. Others have even claimed that he was the world\'s most influential and successful leader of the twentieth century. Those claims can be backed up by the overwhelming support that he received from his citizens throughout his four terms in office. President Franklin Delano Roosevelt began a new era in American history by ending the Great Depression that the country had fallen into in 1929. His social reforms gave people
Franklin Delano RooseveltFranklin Delano Roosevelt Franklin Delano Roosevelt is one of our countries best known and most beloved presidents. He is commonly remembered for taking a tired, beaten, nation and instilling hope in it. This positive view of Roosevelt is held by Burns, who paints the picture of a man whose goal was to alleviate our nation\'s economic pains. But, is this view too myopic? Is Roosevelt deserving of such a godly reputation? These questions are posed by Conkin as he points out the discrimination tha
People and Events of World War IIPeople and Events of World War II by Kevan Salisbury The Axis Powers World War II was started by the Axis Forces, which were comprised of Germany, Italy, and Japan. They fought against the combined might of almost the entire world, and, but for a supreme combined effort on the part of America, the USSR, and Britain, almost won. During the war, the Axis Powers were totalitarian states, controlled by their respective leader or leaders. These are their stories. During World War II, there were three
Eleanor RooseveltEleanor Roosevelt Eleanor Roosevelt was a social activist, United States representative to the United Nations, and wife of 32nd U.S. president Franklin Delano Roosevelt. Eleanor Roosevelt had an active public career before and during her marriage and continued to maintain this after her husband’s death. Unlike any prior first lady, she held regular news conferences, wrote a daily newspaper column, represented the president and nation on foreign and domestic trips, and spoke out on a broad range
Civics ProjectCivics Project Political!—U.S. Herbert H.thought the depression was caused by problems, not the U.S. economy these problems were beyond the US control.He also believed they key to recovery was confidence in the economy.Factories and businesses tried to do this,but even as they shut down Hoover continued to insist that recovery was on its way.He thought keeping worker’s wages would b another way 2 get out of the G.D. but many businesses lowered the wages.Many ppl thought Hoover’s passive attitude
American History TimelineAmerican History Timeline I. The Prohibition Experiment A. Eighteenth Amendment 1. Abolished alcohol 2. Popularity a) Popular- Midwest and South b) Unpopular- East B. Prohibitionists 1. Naive 2. Hostile C. Questionable Conditions 1. Many wanted to violate law just to violate it 2. Wanted a repeal 3. Speakeasies were constructed to drink in without being caught D. Home brew & Bathtub Gin 1. became increasingly popular 2. less liquor was consumed in the days before the amendment II. The Golden A
Sentiment Expression IndustrySentiment Expression Industry I love this business, exults Robert Kaynes Jr., vice president of sales (and grandson of the founder) at Bron Shoe, the Columbus, Ohio-based company responsible for putting millions of pairs of bronzed baby shoes on bookshelves in the homes of loving parents across America for the past 75 years. It may sound schmaltzy Kaynes concedes, but it\'s a schmaltzy business. We\'re selling sentiment. Still, how do you market a memory? For companies like Hallmark, FTD,
Theodore RooseveltTheodore Roosevelt The turn of the century has always been a big deal for modern civilizations. One hundred years of life is quite large compared with the average 70 or so given to most. Because of that, people tend to look in trends of decades, rather than centuries or millennia. When it does come time for a new century, when that second digit rotates, as it does so seldom, people tend to look for change. Events tend to fall before or after the century, not on top of it, and United States histo
Dwight David EisenhowerDwight David Eisenhower The taste of victory was fresh and sweet to John Fitzgerald Kennedy. Just about a year ago, he sat in the drawing room of his Georgetown home and spoke breezily about the office he would assume. Sure it\'s a big job, he said. But I don\'t know anybody who can do it any better than I can. I\'m going to be in it for four years. It isn\'t going to be so bad. you\'ve got time to think -- and besides, the pay is pretty good. One year later, on a cool, grey day, the 35th Pr
Japan Internment CampJapan Internment Camp On December 7, 1941, the Japanese attacked the United States Naval facility at Pearl Harbor in Hawaii. 19 ships were sunk, 2,335 servicemen lost their lives, and, afterwards, the United States declared war on Japan, and her allies Germany and Italy. However, another great loss occurred on United States soil--the imprisonment of 120,000 people, 2/3 of whom were United States citizens. The Japanese Internment, the name of this mistake, was illegal, unconstitutional, and an ac
Theodore RooseveltTheodore Roosevelt Outline Thesis: Theodore Roosevelt\'s political presence altered the course of the United States, transforming it into a superpower fully ready to handle the challenges of any opposition, and changed the role of the president and executive branch of US government, making it a force to be reckoned with. I. Introduction II. Before Roosevelt A. Post-Reconstructionist Views B. The Industrial Revolution C. The Gilded Age 1. Railroads 2. Robber Barons 3. Immigration 4. Standard Ques
EspionageEspionage I am not what I am! -Iago in Othello In wartime, truth is so precious that she should always be attended by a bodyguard of lies. -Winston Churchill, speaking to Franklin D. Roosevelt and Josef Stalin. The Second World War was a many-faceted struggle. Battle lines were drawn on many fronts, but combat was not resolved exclusively by the G.I. on the black sands of Iwo Jima or in the bitter cold of the Ardennes. A sordid array of characters was fighting the war in such little-known pla
Analytic Review of “Grapes of Wrath”Analytic Review of “Grapes of Wrath” History 258 Nov. 21/01 Grapes of Wrath, the epic novel written by John Steinbeck, captures the travesty and tragedies of the “Great Depression.” Chronicling the travels of a displaced Oklahoma family, the “Joads,” Steinbeck captures many of the historical moods and thinking of the era. Steinbeck weaves a tale purposely driven towards the bourgeois classes of the United States. Steinbeck’s novel is not then just a tale copied and dramatized after the emigrant
19381938 On November 2, 1938, a nationwide radio station broadcast a radio show that was based on the best seller, War of the Worlds, by H.G. Wells. The play was performed by many people, namely Orsen Wells and John Houseman. It was during a time when the radio was the primary source of entertainment. People throughout America tuned in to listen to their favorite radio show or for some music to dance to, but instead heard a special news bulletin reporting that Martians were landing on Earth. The Mar