This essay Ethnographic Film has a total of 1167 words and 6 pages.
In making ethnographic film ethnographers will inevitably be confronted with conflicting values and will be forced to choose to uphold some while neglecting others. The situation is complicated further when the films are intended for television screening and the audience is the general public; the ethnographic filmmaker then faces the task of producing something that is simultaneously ethnographically competent, entertaining, accessible to general audiences and ethical. Here I will examine two ethnographic made-for-TV programs: Masai Women and Kayapo Out of the Forest. In each of these programs the filmmakers were confronted with ethical decisions requiring them to uphold one value while excluding another. It is my intent to show that in ethnographic film making there can be no set formula for which filmmakers can prioritize ethnographic values and human ethics; each decision to uphold one value over another must be made in regard to the specific social and political context in which it is being made.
Masai Women’s filmmakers were confronted with two conflicting values when treating several aspects of Masai culture. On one hand the film was meant to be an ethnographic documentary and as such had its own set of ethnographic goals. These include portraying whole people and being as objective as possible. On the other hand, the filmmakers had to be cognizant of their audience, the general (British) public. Knowing that their audience was the general public had both advantages and disadvantages: while it gave them a unique opportunity to reach a wide range of people it also created a certain responsibility, since the film wasn’t being shown in the context of any anthropological discourse on the subject. This isn’t to say the filmmakers were limited because their audience were the ignorant masses but rather that they were dealing with a diverse audience. The film, to be successful, could assume neither that the viewers were educated nor uneducated; a successful television program appeals to many sensibilities.
While depicting Masai culture these values came into conflict in treating several subjects. First and most striking was the subject of female circumcision: the topic was completely glazed over. In narrating the topic Melissa Llewelyn-Davies describes female circumcision as a joyous occasion, a rite of passage for Masai women, “the equivalent to a white wedding in British society.” The filmmakers’ reasoning behind this decision to not dwell on the subject was essentially a decision to adhere to one of the values described above, to be responsible and respectful in portraying a culture to “open” audiences; ethnographic filmmakers certainly do not want to create disdain for a culture based on practices that may seem adverse to western society. In adhering to one value however they were forced to abandon another, ethnographic completeness. In a film about Masai women, a female-centered film about the lives of women, the issue of female circumcision seems to me to be very pertinent and an important topic to explore. For instance, the girl’s screams are edited out, clearly in violation of ethnographic principle. Lleweyn-Davies also says that “the practice is the female equivalent to male circumcision.” It most certainly is not. If practiced on men female circumcision would amount to one-half to three quarters removal of the penis. Here, the point is that the issue is glazed over and made benign for the purpose of not offending the “average” western viewer.
One topic more difficult to avoid in a discussion of Masai women’s experience is the practice of polygyny. Here, the same conflicting values were confronted as are discussed above: on one hand the filmmaker wants to produce a film that is ethnographically whole in its description of cultural institutions, yet on the other hand the filmmaker must keep in mind the composition of the audience. In this instance Melissa Llewelyn-Davies chose to explore the topic at length in favor of the former value. She does however explore the topic with great sensitivity, choosing to ask the subjects how they feel about the practice themselves, rather than narrating .
In making Kayapo: Out of the Forest, Terrence Turner faced a somewhat different dilemma, yet it was a dilemma of conflicting values nevertheless. The Kayapo project arose out of a relationship between the Kayapo and various anthropologists. Anthropologists introduced as early as the 1950’
Topics Related to Ethnographic Film
Visual anthropology, Ethnography, Anthropology, Evaluation methods, Indigenous peoples in Brazil, Ethnographic film, Kayapo people
Essays Related to Ethnographic Film
PsychologyPsychology INTRODUCTION The study of the way people think and behave is called psychology. The field of psychology has a number of sub-disciplines devoted to the study of the different levels and contexts of human thought and behavior. Social psychology, for example, deals with human thought and action in a social context, while physiological psychology is concerned with thought and behavior at the level of neurology. Another division of psychology, comparative psychology compares the thought an
Escapism and Virtual RealityEscapism and Virtual Reality ABSTRACT The use of computers in society provides obvious benefits and some drawbacks. \'Virtual Reality\', a new method of interacting with any computer, is presented and its advantages and disadvantages are considered. The human aspect of computing and computers as a form of escapism are developed, with especial reference to possible future technological developments. The consequences of a weakening of the sense of reality based upon the physical world are also con
The Woman Warrior. A story of a lost fight.The Woman Warrior. A story of a lost fight. English 455 Anger and confusion were following me as I was trying to fight my way through Maxine Hong Kingston’s masterpiece. I was helplessly looking for some answers. Who is the Woman Warrior? Where is the fine line between fiction and non-fiction, if there is one? What is the connection between all of the stories that seemed non-related to each other? And as soon as I thought that I figured it out, the author failed me again. I was surprised (and no
An Analysis of Heart of DarknessAn Analysis of Heart of Darkness Conrad\'s novel, Heart of Darkness, relies on the historical period of imperialism in order to describe its protagonist, Charlie Marlow, and his struggle. Marlow\'s catharsis in the novel, as he goes to the Congo, rests on how he visualises the effects of imperialism. Marlow\'s change, as caused by his exposure to the imperialistic nature of the historical period in which he lived is one of the main concerns of our study.Because, Joseph Conrad develops themes of
Anthropology’s Symbiotic Relationship with PhotogrAnthropology’s Symbiotic Relationship with Photography 9/25/1999 Anthropology 174 It is by no coincidence that the fields of photography and anthropology have evolved together. At the very least, photography and the visual representation of so-called “primitive” peoples have legitimized and mainstreamed the field of anthropology. Anthropologists have been called “merchants of the exotic,” a reputation well deserved based on the early period of ethnographic photography. In many cases anthropologi
AnthropologyAnthropology Anth 174 Candomble is a branch of Santeria, an Afro-Carribbean religion which evolved among African slaves from the Yoruba religion. Historically, when slaves were brought to the Caribbean they were forced to take on the religion of their masters; in the Caribbean and South America it was predominantly Roman Catholic. Yoruban decedents kept their religion alive in part by continuing to worship the African deities in the guise of Christian saints; from this tradition evolved Voodoo i
Ethnographic FilmEthnographic Film In making ethnographic film ethnographers will inevitably be confronted with conflicting values and will be forced to choose to uphold some while neglecting others. The situation is complicated further when the films are intended for television screening and the audience is the general public; the ethnographic filmmaker then faces the task of producing something that is simultaneously ethnographically competent, entertaining, accessible to general audiences and ethical. Here I
Reality Based ProgrammingReality Based Programming “By crossing into a space whose curvature is no longer that of the real, nor that of truth, the era of simulation of inaugurated by a liquidation of all referentials-worse: with their artificial resurrection in the systems of signs, a material more malleable than meaning, in that it lends itself to all systems of equivalences . . . It is no longer a question of imitation, nor duplication, nor even parody. It is a question of substituting the signs of the real for the re
The Andromeda StrainThe Andromeda Strain The novel The Andromeda Strain by Michael Crichton was more detailed than the film due to events leading to climax, scientific terminology and characterization. This record of the earth\'s first biological crisis is perhaps the most painstakingly Authentic science-fiction novel ever made. When a satellite falls to earth near a small New Mexico village, the recovery team finds everyone in the area except an infant and an old derelict dead. The survivors are brought to a five
The HomelessThe Homeless I met Sue and Chris last summer at a campground in the eastern panhandle of West Virginia. They appeared to be just two ordinary campers. It was after some casual conversation that I learned they had been living in the campground for the past two weeks. Park authorities had informed them their time was up and they would have to move somewhere else. Sue, a young lady in her late twenties, told me they had no place else to go. Chris, a young man in his early thirties, had lost his job
The Renaissance PeriodThe Renaissance Period The Renaissance period had a great impact in many areas. One of the most obvious areas to see is in the Renaissance art. Renaissance art was something new to everyone at the time and varied from previous art in many ways. Renaissance art and Medieval art for example had many differences. In order to see a difference between these two different styles of art, characteristics of each must first be given. The first to be discussed will be the Renaissance. The Italian Renaissa