Do the subjects in Hobbes’s commonwealth retain th
This essay Do the subjects in Hobbes’s commonwealth retain th has a total of 1827 words and 9 pages.
Do the subjects in Hobbes’s commonwealth retain their liberty?
I intend to argue that subjects in Hobbes’s commonwealth do not retain their liberty. However I do not intend to argue that the loss of liberty is total. I will argue that the loss of liberty is gradual, partial and voluntary. Hobbes’s argument is constructed very carefully. He guides you through a series of premises, supported by rhetoric, which lead you, inexorably to his conclusion. The problem for me is that the basic ideas he is trying to get you to agree with are sometimes flawed or moulded to suit his hypothesis.
First and foremost is Hobbes’s definition of freedom:
“By liberty, is understood to the proper signification of the word, the absence of external impediments: which impediments may oft take away part of a man’s power to do what he would; but cannot hinder him from using the power left him, according as his judgement, and reason shall dictate to him.”
Thomas Hobbes. Leviathan. Chapter 14 paragraph 2. Oxford University Press.1996.
Here, Hobbes sets out a purely materialistic approach to his definition. Liberty is simply the freedom from external impediments. However, I would argue that there can be no true freedom from external impediments, and therefore question to what degree are we free. We are always confined to some degree. We were confined by gravity, until we developed flight. I intend to argue that besides being already constrained in our liberty, we exasperate this by giving up, voluntarily more of our freedom. A fish is only capable of living in water; it is not equipped to live on land. Therefore it has an external impediment blocking its liberty. When faced with a difficult choice, we are free to choose, however the choices may be limited as they guide us to a, in the same way that Hobbes constructs his argument, to a conclusion that is hard to escape. Hobbes argues that all desires have a causal relationship, which eventually links back the prime mover, God. This he argues does not remove our liberty as determinists would have you believe but that it merely provides a causal chain of events which leads you to make your choice, he believes that we still have liberty even when faced with limited choices. Hobbes’s believes this is a free choice made from liberty. During the terrorist attacks of September 11th, a few people caught in the World Trade Centre attacks jumped from the windows to their deaths. They were faced with a choice of death by fire or death from jumping from the 30th floor. This does not seem to be much of a choice and liberty can only play a minor role here. Circumstance has put you in a situation where the outcome will be the same regardless of your decision; your only freedom is on deciding the route.
Hobbes argues that in nature everybody’s desire and search for liberty brings them into conflict with others as they try do the same. He argues that according to his State of Nature, everyone is essentially equal:
“Nature hath made men so equal, in the faculties of the body, and mind; as that though there be found one man sometimes manifestly stronger in body, or of quicker mind than another; yet when all is reckoned together, the difference between man, and man, is not so considerable, as that one man can thereupon claim to himself any benefit, to which another may not pretend, as well as he. For as to the strength of the body, the weakest has strength enough to kill the strongest, either by secret machination, or by confederacy with others.”
Thomas Hobbes. Leviathan. Chapter 13 paragraph 1. Oxford University Press.1996.
Hobbes therefore claims that because of this state humans will come into conflict and that a “condition of war of everyone against everyone”. It is through this postulation that Hobbes decides that we need a sovereign to rule over us ensuring peace for all. You would think that this would spell the end for liberty, but Hobbes still believes that we retain liberty. The way in which he does this is through the idea of authorisation. Hobbes argues that when we make the contract with the sovereign we empower or authorise the representative of the sovereign to act
Topics Related to Do the subjects in Hobbes’s commonwealth retain th
Libertarian theory, John Locke, Sovereignty, Calvin and Hobbes, Leviathan, Oligarchy, Thomas Hobbes, Hobbes, Social contract, State of nature, Liberty, Natural and legal rights
Essays Related to Do the subjects in Hobbes’s commonwealth retain th
William Gibson and The InternetWilliam Gibson and The Internet Introduction The words Internet and world wide web are becoming everyday use these days, it has exploded into the mass market of information and advertising. There are bad points about the net as well as good points, this relatively new medium is growing at such a rate that the media have to take it seriously. This new form of communication was mainly populated by small groups of communities, but now that it is getting much easier to access the web these gro
Computer PornographyComputer Pornography Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press, or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.(Wallace: 3) A statement from a document that a group of individuals put together to ensure their own ideas and beliefs would never change. The group of people was the forefathers of the United States of Amer
A Comparison and Contrast of A Comparison and Contrast of Juergen Habermas and Hans Georg Gadamer 20083747 History 104 Nov.19/01 The intellectual battle between the Gadamer-Hermeneutics school and the Habermas-critical theorists is well documented. Hermeneutics claiming a universal applicability stating, “being that can be understood is language,” and the critical theorist claiming a reflective reasoning process that goes beyond hermeneutics. The battle has been aptly stated in the rather public disagreements between Ha
Free Speech, Hate Speech, and Equality of Citizens Free Speech, Hate Speech, and Equality of Citizens Nov23/01 POLI SCI 101(A) On October 23, 1998, abortionist Dr. Barnett Slepian, was shot and killed by a sniper’s bullet. The sniper in question was part of the radical pro-life contingency in the United States. Bill Baird, another abortionist, had his own clinic fire bombed. When holding a news conference afterwards, he stated, “I fault publicly the Roman Catholic Church, the Right to Life people, and all anti-abortion forces who use the rhetor
The Ontology of Gay and Queer The Ontology of Gay and Queer Homosexuality: History, Politics, Ethics April /2001 Table of Contents Introduction………………………………………………….. p. 2-4 Definitions and Genealogy of Homosexuality……………… p. 5- Genealogy of Ontology………………………………………. p. Coming Out of the Closet: Conversion and Inaugeration or Integration……….. p. Genetic Ontology, Social Artifice and Orientations………... p. Conclusion: The Sexual Tower of Babel and Politics of Ontology………………………………. p. -Introduction- In recent years, the gay commu
Communist ManifestoCommunist Manifesto Chapter 1 Summary: Bourgeois and Proletarians The Communist Manifesto begins with Marx\'s famous generalization that the history of all hitherto existing society is the history of class struggles (79). Marx describes these classes in terms of binary oppositions, with one party as oppressor, the other as oppressed. While human societies have traditionally been organized according to complex, multi-membered class hierarchies, the demise of feudalism effected by the French Revol
The Nobel Prize for EconomicsThe Nobel Prize for Economics The Nobel Prize for Economics or more correctly, The Bank of Sweden Prize in Economic Sciences is the world\'s most prestigious award for the people who contributions to the field of Economics. It is awarded in memory of Alfred Nobel by the Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences every year. The prize consists of a gold medal, a diploma bearing a citation, and a sum of money (US$1,000,000 in recent years). It represents the ultimate recognition by one\'s peers. The Econom
ChisholmChisholm It seems that Chisholm, in his argument for free-will, drives himself into a corner trying to escape the problem of determinism or, conversely, that of indeterminism; the truth of either of these negates the libertarian position of an agent that initiates causal chains but itself is uncaused. First, is it coherent to state that something initiated a causal chain, but is itself uncaused? Second, Chisholm seems to attempt an escape from indeterminism into the self for the initial push i
Ayn Rand and Objectivism: An IntroductionAyn Rand and Objectivism: An Introduction opinions and beliefs, but he finally accepts that they will not leave his mind and his destiny is sealed. In his recognition of his core belief (individual freedom), he knows that he cannot resist this immutable freedom. Briefly, this sentence is the summary of man\'s existence. Man knows he is selfish and those who allow self-interest permeate their being are often called greedy or evil. However, without selfishness, man is reduced from an advanced mind
Philosophical Foundations Of Poverty And DistributPhilosophical Foundations Of Poverty And Distribution Any Lockeian scholar would be lying if they told you that any topic in the secondary literature on the Two Treatises of Government was more famous (or infamousÉdepending on who you talk to), widely debated, or caused more controversy than the old Oxford gradŐs theory of property. Some are shouting from the left that Locke argues a rights claim for subsistence for all individuals, that it may even support MarxŐs theory of exploitation. Yelling
UNIVERSAL CAUSATIONUNIVERSAL CAUSATION I would prefer the view of the soft determinist, that being free is largely a question of definition. Do we truly have free will? That depends on how we define “freedom”. The very nature of language requires us to use definitions. If I were to say the word “tree”, a person understanding the English language would automatically know I was referring to a plant. Even though I do not specify what kind of tree, an image would be made. Two people could have different mental images
On LibertarianismOn Libertarianism Ethics 04/28/04 One of the most attractive features of libertarianism is that it is basically a very simple ideology. Maybe even simpler than Marxism, since you don\'t have to learn foreign words like proletariat . Essentially, it is a theory about the permissible use of non-consensual force. It holds that agents fully own themselves and have moral powers to acquire property rights in external things under certain conditions. These property rights set the following limits of fo
PolygraphPolygraph Introduction Homo Sapiens have yearned for a reliable and consistently correct way of finding out if one is telling the truth since ancient times. “Early societies used torture. Statements made by a person on the rack were considered especially believable.” (Jussim, pg.65) There was also trial by ordeal, which was based on superstition. For instance, if there were two suspects for one crime, it was thought that the innocent would be stronger in combat and thus vanquish a guilty opponen
Mental Health LegislationMental Health Legislation In 1997 when the current Government was elected into power one of their aims was to tackle the inequalities that existed within health and social care. Since then we have seen the publication of many policy documents which planned the way forward for health care, particularly in the way that care is delivered. Modern and Dependable (DOH, 1997), set out ways for national improvement in healthcare. Modernising Mental health Services (DOH, 1998a), set out the way on which
The GovernmentThe Government In 1997 when the current Government was elected into power one of their aims was to tackle the inequalities that existed within health and social care. Since then we have seen the publication of many policy documents which planned the way forward for health care, particularly in the way that care is delivered. Modern and Dependable (DOH, 1997), set out ways for national improvement in healthcare. Modernising Mental health Services (DOH, 1998a), set out the way on which mental heal
A Case Study of Soft DeterminismA Case Study of Soft Determinism Most often, philosophers attempt to prove their many theories by making use of several examples or analogies. Yet, it is through these clever, everyday platforms that we, the average knowledge-seeking citizen, gain a true understanding of his or her intent. It allows us to incorporate our personal lives into the theory and as a result, further enhances its overall meaning. Therefore, when analyzing the theory of soft determinism, I have chosen to philosophically