This essay Deterrence has a total of 1788 words and 8 pages.
In order to grasp some understanding of a possible military conflict between United States, China and/or Democratic Republic of People of Korea (DRPK), it is important to distinguish the relative differences between United States’ deterrence on China and the DRPK as well as China’s and DRPK’s deterence on United States. In the articles titled China and Weapons of Mass Destruction: Implications for the United States, Chinas New “Old” Thinking: The Concept of Limited Deterrence, China: Getting the Questions Right, Korean Peninsula, and North Korea’s Military Strategy discussed in class, deterrent distinctions between the three countries were made. Before elaborating on the relative deterrents, one must define what deterrence is. Deterrence, in the words of American strategist Thomas Schelling, is merely “the skillful non-use of force.” The enemy, when faced with the prospect of catastrophic damage, has second thoughts, and desists for fear of suffering a disproportionately greater loss than one they might inflict.
According to the authors, United States’ deterrence of China operates on multiple levels—e.g., conventional military attack on Taiwan, use of theater nuclear weapons, recourse to strategic nuclear weapons and economical restrictions. Although little systematic research has explored the range of potential U.S. options to strenghten deterrence at the strategic level, to bolster crisis stability, or to operationalize deterrence in a possible warfighting context, analysts have rather extrapolated what they view as a successful deterence of the Soviet Union and transfered such an understanding to the Chinese context. This, according to the authors, downplayed the prospects for a military confrontation between the United States and China (over Taiwan or other possible issues), or inferred that deterrence will obviously work for the United States ‘tooth-for-tooth’ China due to the large asymmetries in deployed capabilities. But a simple count of approximately 20 long-range nuclear weapons for China (or even the approximately 400 currently available strategic and tactical nuclear warheads) misses a critical point: that the U.S. ability to achieve its regional security objectives, predicated in part on power projection requirements, may be adversely affected by increased Chinese nuclear and missile capabilities. Maintaining stable nuclear deterrence at the strategic level while at the same time developing the military capabilities required to defend and promote U.S. regional interests is a clear challenge to U.S. defense planners. Looking forward, a larger Chinese nuclear force, together with a likely smaller number of future U.S. nuclear weapons, may suggest the need for a far-reaching review of U.S. deterrence policy and plans. More generally, determining the pressure points to which Chinese leadership will respond may become critical to charting a course through a crisis situation while preserving core U.S. interests. Finally, encouraging Chinese officials to learn from the Pearl Harbor rather than the Somalia analogy of American willingness to respond to aggression might enhance deterrence, diminish prospects for miscalculation, and help achieve key regional objectives.
In contrast, China has adopted a rather different deterrence tactic on U.S. policy. According to most analysts, China has long had the capability to develop multiple-war-head missiles, yet, the apparent lack of any MRVed or MIRVed missiles in the Chinese inventory suggests to many that China has adopted “limited (or ‘minimum’) deterrence” as its strategic doctrine; seeking a capability to deter convenitonal, theater, and stategic nuclear war, and to control escalation in the event of nuclear confrontation. Under a "limited deterrence" doctrine, China would need to target nuclear forces in addition to cities, which would require increased accuracy and expanded deployments. The Chinese strategic force mixture appears to be changing as PRC security perspectives evolve. The significant buildup of shorter-range missiles opposite Taiwan arguably represents a perceptual shift among PRC military officials and policymakers toward greater warfighting or coercive utility for the missile force in ‘local wars.’ China\'s deterrent posture may, therefore, rest on the use of non-nuclear-tipped missiles against non-nuclear-weapon states, coupled with a warning of potential escalation to nuclear attack. China today has a largely discretionary capability to build a larger force; much of the appropriate technological infrastructure is already in place. Moreover, the resources required for significant increases appear, in principle, to be available, although the extent to which this would require expenditure tradeoffs with other priorities is predicated in part on continued economic growth. China is currently pursuing a substantial military modernization campaign, central to which are evident qualitative improvements
Topics Related to Deterrence
Nuclear strategies, Deterrence theory, Mutual assured destruction, Nuclear warfare, Second strike, Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons, Nuclear weapon, Nuclear proliferation, China and weapons of mass destruction, Minimal deterrence, Nuclear utilization target selection
Essays Related to Deterrence
HRM - Ever EvolovingHRM - Ever Evoloving Outline Thesis Statement: Advances in technology along with shifts in the nations’ social structure heavily impact the workplace environment, creating a need for new management models in Human Resources. I. The Changing Workplace A. An Historical Perspective of Jobs in America B. Jobs in the 21st Century II. Identifying Corporate Needs A. The Emergence of Human Resource Management as a Component of General Management. B. Corporate Expectations III. Developing Human Resource
Counter MeasuresCounter Measures National Missile Defense (NMD) is once again a growing concern in America. There have been many new developments since the post-Cold War elimination of nuclear warfare. This diminishing of arms however, is a very fine line. The United States cannot afford to have less capability then the rest of the world, but it does want to encourage unilateral non-proliferation of nuclear arms. In addition, there is a new awareness of “rogue” nations that are completely unpredictable. Since t
BombsBombs A bomb is a container filled with an explosive, incendiary matter, or gas that can be dropped, hurled, or set in place to be detonated by an attached exploding device. It may range in design from a homemade device used by terrorists, assassins, or clandestine raiders to a sophisticated weapon of war. The original bomb, an ancestor of the hand-thrown GRENADE, was a simple container filled with black powder (see GUNPOWDER), which was set off by a fuse lit by the thrower. In the 16th century,
The InternetThe Internet The Internet: its effects and its future written by Eva Kotsi Internet, its effects in our lives and the future of the Internet: The Internet is, quite literally, a network of networks. It is comprised of ten thousands of interconnected networks spanning the globe. The computers that form the Internet range from huge mainframes in research establishments to modest PCs in people\'s homes and offices. Despite the recent hype, the Internet is not a new phenomenon. Its roots lie in a co
The internetThe internet The Internet: its effects and its future Essay written by Eva Kotsi Internet, its effects in our lives and the future of the Internet: The Internet is, quite literally, a network of networks. It is comprised of ten thousands of interconnected networks spanning the globe. The computers that form the Internet range from huge mainframes in research establishments to modest PCs in people\'s homes and offices. Despite the recent hype, the Internet is not a new phenomenon. Its roots lie i
StressStress Stress by Ashley Strawder I. What Is Stress? Stress is the combination of psychological, physiological, and behavioral reactions that people have in response to events that threaten or challenge them. Stress can be good or bad. Sometimes, stress is helpful, providing people with the extra energy or alertness they need. Stress could give a runner the edge he or she needs to persevere in a marathon, for example. This good kind of stress is called eustress. Unfortunately, stress is often not
Web AdvertisingWeb Advertising web advertising web advertising Web Advertising Web advertising, not to mention the Internet itself, finds itself in a stage of relative infancy and therefore provides marketers with novel challenges and situations which need to be dealt with caution . The realm of Web advertising is unchartered terri tory! In terms of South Africa, the country finds itsef somewhat behind technologically. However, this may not prove to be a disadvantage as the uncertain nature of Web advertising
The Influence of Green Groups on the Policy of theThe Influence of Green Groups on the Policy of the United States Abstract: This research examines the relationship between environmental groups and the policies of the United States. The United States political system has been historically anthropocen-tric, or human centered. Environmental groups have been attempting to change this to a biocentric or ecocentric viewpoint, which includes the rights of animals and the environment. These views are nature centered instead of human centered. This stu
The United States and National Security, and DominThe United States and National Security, and Dominant Party in Balance of Power The emergence of the United States as a dominant party in balance of power equations is a relatively new phenomenon in world history. New military technology coupled with increased global integration has allowed the United States to reinvent the fundamental assumptions of international diplomacy while propelling itself to the top of the hegemonic stepladder. This positioning was achieved piecemeal during the course o
The United NationsThe United Nations The United Nations is an organization of sovereign nations not a world government. It provides the machinery to help find solutions to disputes or problems, and to deal with virtually any matter of concern to humanity. It does not legislate like a national parliament. But in the meeting rooms and corridors of the UN, representatives of almost all countries of the world large and small, rich and poor, with varying political views and social systems have a voice and vote in shap
The Choosing of a Landfill SiteThe Choosing of a Landfill Site There is currently much debate on the desirability of landfilling particular wastes, the practicability of alternatives such as waste minimisation or pre- treatment, the extent of waste pre-treatment required, and of the most appropriate landfilling strategies for the final residues. This debate is likely to stimulate significant developments in landfilling methods during the next decade. Current and proposed landfill techniques are described in this information s
COLD WARCOLD WAR Less than a year after the end of World War II, the great wartime leader of Britain, Winston Churchill gave a speech at Westminster College, in Fulton, Missouri. After receiving an honorary degree and being introduced by President Harry Truman, he delivered a historic speech. Churchill said, “ It is my duty to place before you certain facts about the present position in Europe. From Stettin in the Baltic to Trieste in the Adriatic an Iron Curtain has descended across the Continent. Behi
The War of the WorldThe War of the World Poli 205/2 A 5 December 2003 With a high presence of terrorism in the twenty-first century, the world is on guard for practically anything that may come its way. Terrorism has played an important role in our lives, since the September 11 attack on American soil. Since that day, security measures have been taken to secure our everyday lives and we have not seen one day of peace. Following this, the U.S. found itself at war with Iraq, which has brought an imbalance to the worl
E-commerce an IntroductionE-commerce an Introduction E-commerce an Introduction In the broadest sense, electronic commerce (e-commerce), is the buying and selling of products and services over the Internet. It has included the handling of purchase transactions and funds transfers over computer networks. According to the Forrester Research Study Sizing Intercompany Commerce, total U.S business-to-business Internet trade in 1998 is $7.7 billion, compared to a total global e-commerce of $21.8 billion, dramatically increasin
Bay of Pigs, Brigade 2506 Bay of Pigs, Brigade 2506 On the 17th of April, 1961, Brigade 2506, comprised of Cuban exiles, landed at the Bay of Pigs on the southern-central coast of Cuba. They were mostly young men who came from all sectors of society and regions of the island with one common goal: to overthrow the growing communism led by Fidel Castro who was imposing a rigid totalitarian system on this largest island of the Antilles. In three days of hard fighting highly superior forces defeated them. Almost 40 years af
What do feminists find to be objectionable in patr What do feminists find to be objectionable in patriarchy, and are they right to be critical of it? www.microcosmpublishing.com The above illustration is one of many that are used on a daily basis in order to make the understanding and also the highlighting of patriarchy an everyday issue in the daily conflict of gender issues. Western female thought through the centuries has identified the relationship between patriarchy and gender as crucial to the women’s subordinate position. For two hundred
Thirteen DaysThirteen Days Management Final Assignment December 25, 2003 ª Table of Contents Preface……………………………………………………………………....... Chronology of Events………………………………………………………… Overview……………………………………………………………………... Questions……………………………………………………………………... Q1. “Thirteen Days” is a classic example of group work dynamics and both intra and inter group politics. The situation was “real,” different perceptions however defined their own sense of reality. What factors can you identify that may have defined “reality”
Acid RainAcid Rain CONTENTS Summary 1. Introduction 1.1 Terms of reference 1.2 Source of information 2. What is Acid Rain? 2.1 The definition of Acid Rain 2.2 How to Measure Acid Rain? 3. What cause Acid Rain? 3.1 History of Acid rain 3.2 Causes of Acid rain 4. What Are Acid Rain\'s Effects? 4.1 Water 4.2 Soil 4.3 Plant 4.4 Atmosphere 5. What Society Can Do About Acid Deposition ? 5.1 Understand acid deposition\'s causes and effects 5.2 Clean up smokestacks and exhaust pipes 5.3 Use alternative energy so
Dr. StrangeloveDr. Strangelove Dr. Strangelove, or How I learned to stop worrying and love the Bomb is a black comedy about nuclear war. Kubrick\'s original intention was to make a straight thriller about a possible nuclear accident, and, as is his custmary method, he began researching the topic in earnest -- subscribing to Aviation Week and the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, conferring with NATO officials, etc. According to Kubrick: I started our being completely unfamiliar with any of the professional
Political Action CommitteePolitical Action Committee The American electoral process is a complicated process by means of which the electorate chooses those men and women who will represent their interests on the local, state and national levels. Of course, this is an oversimplification of the electoral process, which is influenced by a number of different factors having little to do with the voice of the people. Among those influences are the reaction of the mass media to any particular issue or candidate, the ability
Unequal Representation: Membership Input and InterUnequal Representation: Membership Input and Interest Group Decision-Making Introduction Interest groups play a key mediating and representational role in politics. In the theory of pluralist politics, organized groups represent the interests of varied segments of society in the national policy process. These groups organize to represent the views of their members in the halls of Congress, administrative agencies, and federal courthouses, giving voice to their members\' interests in all policy m
The Y2K BugThe Y2K Bug Introduction The year 2000 problem could have been completely prevented had some early people envisioned the degree to which the microprocessor would change our lives. Surely, no one would have thought that in the early days of ENIAC that everything from your alarm clock to your car would be computerized. Even the IT managers of the 80\'s could not be blamed: The disk space savings from dropping the two digits of the date over 100 Million Records would represent almost 200 Megabytes!
Timeline History of Russia 1533-1991Timeline History of Russia 1533-1991 1533-1584 The Russian Empire, covering over one-sixth of the world, is governed by the sovereignty of Czar Ivan the Terrible. The feudal system oppresses every man, woman and child as the Czar releases Tax Collectors to maintain support for the nobles in the land. Brigands and financial extortionists persecute any lower class citizen who refuses to help contribute to the Czar\'s regime. 1682-1725 Under Czar Peter I (Peter the Great), the Russian Empire begi
Nixon's Program of Detente was the Reason for theNixon\'s Program of Detente was the Reason for the Decline of World Conflict in the 1970\'s I. Introduction 1.China & Russia a.Communists powers, threat to world b.Arms race c.Threat to each other d. Could pressure N.Korea into peace 2.Nixon\'s program of detente was the reason for decline in world conflict in the 1970\'s II. Reasons supporting 1.Nixon improved Commie\'s general attitude towards U.S.& vice versa a.initiated trade b.improved relations between China and Russia c.Halt to China\'s i
American NaivetéAmerican Naiveté PREFACE American Naiveté The United States trade gap with China jumped 17 percent in 1996 to $39.5 billion, the worst showing for any country other than Japan. It marked the 11th strait annual increase in the deficit with China and analysts believe this trend will result in the deficit with China surpassing the imbalance with Japan probably this year. Fundamental macroeconomics informs us that China’s trade surplus, created by virtue of its cheap labor, will directly support its
AP Human Geography Outline AP Human Geography Outline Ch. 1 Thinking Geographically Key Issue 1: How do geographers describe where things are? Map- a two-dimensional model of Earth's surface, or a portion of it. Place- a specific point of Earth distinguished by a particular character. Region- an area of Earth distinguished by a distinctive combination of cultural and physical features. Scale- the relationship between a map's distances and the actual distances on Earth. Space- the physical gap between two objects. Connect