This essay December 14 has a total of 2208 words and 11 pages.
Historians have long searched for the order to annihilate the Jews or -
insofar as they excluded a Fuehrer-order - for other central documents. The
Wannsee Protocol was rejected. Here second-level men were to be found, here they
spoke not of an order, but rather an authorization of Hitler.
Characteristically, a pre-arranged agreement applied to this meeting, ordered
from above. At the least, documentary criteria had to be found that permitted
plausible inferences as to place, point in time and personal construction of
such a conversation. The research led nowhere.
Now however a 34-year old Berlin historian [translator\'s note:
Geschichtswissenschaft is science of history] has precisely answered the old
question. And to say it right up front: the proof is ingenious. He didn\'t
publish it in one of the eternally boring academic tomes and in so doing made
the right choice. The work appeared in Volume 18 (6th year, November 1997) of
the unorthodox, independent magazine "Werkstatt Geschichte." Written
with practically mathematical precision, the essay covers 37 pages, including
223 source notes. The title is: "The Wannsee Conference, the fate of German
Jews and Hitler\'s fundamental political decision to murder all European
Jews." The author\'s name is Christian Gerlach. He has found proof of an
internal speech of Hitler\'s from 1941 that no other researcher had even
The weak dictator
Already Hans Mommsen, the foremost Holocaust researcher, grumbles: the young
man is to be sure "exceptional," has however "gone astray,"
using "outdated methods," and above all, makes "too much
noise." In fact Gerlach - in no way naive - falls between those two schools
of thought that contemporary historians have occupied for decades, passed down
and in every case retreated from even a centimeter only reluctantly.
On one hand, the so-called intentionalists impute an absolute desire of Adolf
Hitler for genocide, evident already in the earliest program. Even the means of
the extermination - poison gas - was determined by him in the "Kampfzeit"
[the years of struggle preceding the assumption of power]. Others underscore the
anticipated obedience, better put: the extensive freedoms of the
"paladins." They operated freely in accordance with the highly
flexible motto: "It is the Fuehrer\'s wish." If one ignores the now
defunct variants ("if the Fuehrer had known!") or the similarly
outmoded simplification ("puppets of the monopoly capitalists"), one
is able to posit a thesis that is to be taken seriously of a vascillating, even
weak dictator: he avoided conflicts, put off making decisions, thus his
receptiveness of grand visions for the future, conquest and new orders.
In spite of many differences in details and in weighting, one thing is
considered constant in the view of all the so-called functionalists: the German
policy towards the Jews became progressively more and more radical. "It
must be seriously considered," wrote never charged jurist Rolf Heinz
Höppner in June 16, 1941, "whether the most humane solution is not to
finish off the Jews who are unable to work by means of a quickly working agent.
In any event, this would be more appropriate than to let them starve."
The letter was addressed to Eichmann who telephoned almost daily to Höppner,
his agent in Posen. "Give me that in writing" Eichmann would have
said, and put the written letter into the hierarchical process. Höppner did not
want an order, he asked for the complete examination of his new recommendation.
He found it audacious, "partially fantastic" but "completely
feasible." In addition, he spoke exclusively of the murder of those unable
to work, not all the 500,000 Jews for which he was responsible in the Warthegau
and especially in the Lodz Ghetto. The others he wanted to confine in a work
camp, all child bearing women sterilized, "so that the Jewish problem will
be completely resolved with this generation."
By the end of September 1944, Eichmann still had been able to only
circumspectly answer the incessant pressure of Höppner. In any event the
document strengthens the theory of the progressive discrimination against the
Jews to the point of complete segregation and impoverishment in which the long
practiced policy of social death transformed itself into industrial
extermination in conformity with internal logic, no longer directed by anyone.
Apart from the question of whether an order preceded the Holocaust, confusion
reigned as well about the date of the decision. Some historians opined with good
reasons for March 1941, others increasingly for September/October of the same
year. The predominant opinion was nonetheless that "at the high point of
the expectation of victory" in the eastern war on July 31, 1941 "all
had become clear." Regardless however whether they saw Hitler as the
originator or the moderator, almost
Topics Related to December 14
Chancellors of Germany, Germany, Reinhard Heydrich, Steglitz-Zehlendorf, Wannsee Conference, Adolf Hitler, Wannsee
Essays Related to December 14
Thomas Jonathan Jackson TimelineThomas Jonathan Jackson Timeline 1824 January 21 Thomas Jonathan Jackson was born at Clarksburg, [West] Virginia. Parents: Jonathan Jackson (1790-1826) an attorney, and Julia Beckwith Neale (1798-1831). They were married in September 1817 and had four children: Elizabeth (1819-1826); Warren (1821-1841); Thomas (1824-1863), and Laura Ann (1826-1911). Gen. Stonewall Jackson From the original image in the VMI Archives Photograph collection 1826 March Jackson\'s sister Elizabeth (age 6) and his fath
Explain Bismarck’s Motives for Attacking the SociaExplain Bismarck’s Motives for Attacking the Socialists. How successful was he at Achieving his objectives? Like his predominantly unsuccessful Kulturkampf, Bismarck’s attack on the Socialists has met with much criticism, both at the time and since then. Bismarck saw the Socialist party under a paranoid veil of mistrust and apprehension, in his mind the difference between Anarchism and Socialism was negligible and it was this lack of trust that led to his anti-Socialist in the later part of his
EXPLAINING HITLER’S ELECTORAL SUCCESS AS History:EXPLAINING HITLER’S ELECTORAL SUCCESS AS History: Unit 1 – Seeds of Evil Consider the status of the following statements. Are they accurate or inaccurate? Where inaccurate, give reasons and evidence on which you base your decision. Sometimes a statement may be accurate but of only limited value. For example, it may over-simplify matters or conceal as much as it reveals. Where this is the case, explain how you would qualify or amend the statement. o The rising tide of electoral support for the Na
How and why did Hitler become chancellor of GermanHow and why did Hitler become chancellor of Germany in 1933? The reason why Hitler became chancellor of Germany in 1933, were because of many reasons; long term causes like World War One, treaty of Versailles, fear of communism, the November criminals, the early nature of the constitution1923 crisis. The economic depression 1929-1933; failure of the Weimar government; political crisis 1930-1933; role of the traditional elites and Hitler’s action, skills and leadership. I believe that all these p
The end of the Weimar Republic 1929The end of the Weimar Republic 1929 The end of the Republic 1929-33 Perhaps the greatest catalyst for the collapse of the Republic lies in the Wall Street Crash, or more correctly its aftermath. The grounds of the German recovery were overly dependent on loans from America under the Dawes and then Young plans. However, with the Wall Street Crash of 1929 America was forced to recall her debts, this directly led to the deterioration of Germany’s economy and in turn party relations in the Riechstag
ADOLPH HITLERADOLPH HITLER Adolph Hitler was a highly powerful, political and charismatic man who rose to power in Germany during the late 1920’s at a time of social, political and economic upheaval. In fact, Hitler is said to be one of the rare individuals who, without him, history would have been very different. His rule over Germany from 1934 to his death in 1945, resulted in a fascist regime, the outbreak of World War II, the destruction of the German nation-state and its society and the extermination of
Hitler And WWIIHitler And WWII Adolf Hitler Adolf Hitler’s Early Years Adolf Hitler was born in the small Austrian town of Branau on the 20th of April 1889. He came from a middle-class family that lived comfortably, although he suggested in his book Mein Kampf that his family was poor and his childhood was filled with hardship. His father Alois Hitler was a customs official with the Austrian Civil Service. His mother, Klara was a former servant girl and became Alois’ third wife. The young Hitler had ability bu