This essay Contract Law has a total of 1038 words and 8 pages.
The legal issue states that Ms. Marple decided to sell her car for no less than £20.000 to the right sort of person, she sold it to Sir Birtie Bingfield who abuse of her innocence and real name was Forsyth.
Forsyth gave her a bound cheque for £24.000 and then sold the car to Greaser, local bookmaker, later disappearing.
In order for Ms. Marple to recover her car, she will need to show that she was trying to contract with Sir Birtie Bingfield, “the right sort of person”, so that there would be no binding contract due to have been contracting with Forsyth the person in front of her and the cheque was bound on another person’s name.
The question of this issue is whether there is or not a contract. It may be argued that the term “the right sort of person”, used by Ms. Marple can be implied as a “reasonable person”, and not a fraudster.
This case can be categorized as an Agreement Mistake.
Agreement mistakes are traditionally divided into three categories relating to contractual formation; first, Mutual Mistake, when parties have a different understanding they do not reach to and agreement; therefore, there is no contract. There are few cases involving mutual mistake, on of them is Raffles v. Whilchause and Busch.Secondly, Unilateral Mistakes appear when one party makes a mistake as to term of the contract and the other party knows or, ought to have realised that there is a mistake, Examples can be found in Hartog v. Colin and Smith v. Hughes, among others. Finally, Unilateral mistakes as to identity which involves misrepresentation, often fraudulent, about a person’s identity. This is the legal rule concerning Ms. Marple’s case.
The application of the rules of mistake as to identity can be found in Boulton v. Jones. 1st Party usually called, rogue, trickster, or fraudster misrepresenting his or her identity to persuade a 2nd party to contract or take away goods in credit. Often, the rogue will sell the goods to an innocent 3rd party who has possession.
The Key here is the issue of mistake. If there is a mistake as to identity the contract is void and therefore the 3rd. party acquire no title to pass on and the original owner is entitled to have his/her goods back, such as in Cunday v. Lindsay, Hardman v. Booth and specially in Ingram v. Little (later discussed).
However, if mistake as to identity does not apply then, 3rd party (who also suffer the harsh consequences of acquiring the gods in good faith without notice and for value) will win out.
To show that this is a contract void by mistake as to identity, Ms Marple, needs to show that she was intended to deal with sir Birtie Bingfield. In Ingram v. Little, a very similar case to the one regarded, the three plaintiffs advertised a car for sale and a rogue, introducing himself as P. G. M. Hutchinson offered to buy it. He intended to intended to give a cheque but the plaintiffs at first instance refused and one of them went to check at the post office and ascertained that there was a P. G. M. Hutchinson, then the plaintiffs accepted the cheque, the cheque was not met. Meanwhile, the rogue sold the car to the defendant who bought it in good faith.
The Court held that since the plaintiffs had made an offer to the real P. G. M. Hutchinson, the rogue could not accept it. 
In this case, Ms. Marple had intended to do the same as the plaintiffs in the case last discussed. Nevertheless, there is one fact which is not sated that is whether Ms Marple had checked somewhere for the identity of “Sir Birtie Bingfield”. In case she has not don so, it could probably been presuming that she was trying to contract with the person physically present. In that case, this will be defective for her, having to pass the title to Greaser. Being this the case, the court could apply the following authority:
In Philips v. Brooks Ltd. , a rogue named North went into a Jewellery shop and called himself Sir George Bullogh, and obtained in credit a ring, he then pledge the ring to a firm of
Topics Related to Contract Law
Contract law, Mistake, Contract, Offer and acceptance, Cheque, Smith v Hughes, Misrepresentation
Essays Related to Contract Law
The Prevalent Issues of Surrogate ParentingThe Prevalent Issues of Surrogate Parenting Surrogate parenting refers to an arrangement between a married couple who is unable to have a child because of the wife\'s infertility and a fertile woman who agrees to conceive the husband\'s child through artificial insemination, carry it to term, then surrender all parental rights in the child. Often, the surrogate mother receives compensation for her services. The final step in the process is typically the father\'s acknowledgment of paternity and
Rights of Egyptian WomenRights of Egyptian Women Throughout written history, women have experienced status subservient to the men they lived with. Generally, most cultures known to modern historians followed a standard pattern of males assigned the role of protector and provider while women were assigned roles of domestic servitude. Scholars speculate endlessly at the cause: biology, religion, social custom. Nevertheless, the women were always subordinated to the men in their culture. Through their artwork, tomb inscri
Presidents and Affirmative ActionPresidents and Affirmative Action In 1965, President Lyndon B. Johnson issued Executive Order #11246 at Howard University that required federal contractors to undertake affirmative action to increase the number of minorities that they employ. He wanted to ensure that minorities were recruited to have real opportunities to be hired and then eventually get a promotion. In 1969, the Department of Labor exposed widespread racial discrimination of the Construction Department so President Richard M. N
Revenge In HamletRevenge In Hamlet The Presence of Revenge in Hamlet Revenge is a major theme in the Tragedy of Hamlet. In the play Hamlet, by William Shakespeare, the theme of revenge is repeated numerous times throughout the play and involves a great deal of characters. Of these characters, eight are dead by the end of the play by result of murder which was initiated through revenge. Shakespeare uses the revenge theme to create conflict among many characters. Revenge causes one to act blindly through anger, ra
ShakespeareShakespeare Shakespeare\'s Portrayal of Jews In Shakespeare\'s play, The Merchant of Venice, there are, as is typical of Shakespeare, several different themes. One that emerges at the beginning and is present throughout the rest of the play is anti-semitism. Many of the people of Shakespeare\'s time shared the belief that Jewish people were inferior to Christians, a belief reaching far back to ancient times. To these prejudiced people, the Jewish character of Shylock appears to posses the typica
Should surrogate motherhood be permittedShould surrogate motherhood be permitted Bradley 1 Meghan Bradley Professor Despain WR122 UH March 12, 1997 Should Surrogate Motherhood be Permitted? Surrogate Motherhood is when one women carries to term the fertilized egg of another woman. This procedure is chosen by married couples who can not conceive a child in the “natural way”. In some occasions the mother may be able to produce an egg, but has no womb or some other physical problem which prevents her from carrying a child. Whether or not
The children in Sons and lovers by DH lawerence anThe children in Sons and lovers by DH lawerence and What mass The children in Sons and Lovers by D. H. Lawerence and What Maisie Knew by Henry James The characters in Sons and Lovers by D. H. Lawrence and the characters in What Maisie Knew each have a special meaning. They all seem to be interwoven with one another portraying a new cycle in another characters life. For instance, in What Maisie Knew Mrs. Wix was introduced, in my opinion, at a time when Maisie needed a mother figure. Also, Sir Cl
The Significance of ReasonThe Significance of Reason The significance of reason is discussed both in John Locke’s, The Second Treatise of Civil Government, and in Jean-Jacques Rousseau’s, Emile. However, the definitions that both authors give to the word “reason” vary significantly. I will now attempt to compare the different meanings that each man considered to be the accurate definition of reason. John Locke believed that the state “all men are naturally in ... is a state of perfect freedom” (122), a state in which the
Economics: The American GovernmentEconomics: The American Government Most of the problems of the United states are related to the economy. One of the major issues facing the country today is social security. The United States was one of the last major industrialized nations to establish a social security system. In 1911, Wisconsin passed the first state workers compensation law to be held constitutional. At that time, most Americans believed the government should not have to care for the aged, disabled or needy. But such attitud
The Bubble Economy of JapanThe Bubble Economy of Japan The Economy of Japan had experience a tremendous growth since the end of the Korean war. The growth of GNP in 1967 and 1968 was above 10 % (double digit growth period) which exceed countries such as Britain, France and Germany. The economy experienced a boost is due to many reasons, such as: enlargement of industrial facilities, massive adaptation of western technology and education, lower the military expense to 1% of GNP, relation with power nation, human resources
Canada's Unemployment RateCanada\'s Unemployment Rate For decades prior to the 1981-82 recession, the national unemployment rates of Canada and the United States had been nearly identical. Since then, a persistent unemployment rate gap has emerged. Throughout most of the 1980s, Canada\'s unemployment rate has consistently been about 2 percentage points higher than in the United States. The gap developed in spite of very similar economic performances across the two countries: the growth rate of real per capita incomes h
Describe The Roles of Government In The Present BuDescribe The Roles of Government In The Present Business Environment In the present business environment governments have the power to change and make laws, having a major role and influence on the business environment. There are three levels of government; federal, state and local. The federal government has power over such areas as; company law, income tax, trade etc. State government has power over pollution, price controls, state courts etc. and local government has power over rates, buildin
American Government-EconomicsAmerican Government-Economics Most of the problems of the United states are related to the economy. One of the major issues facing the country today is social security. The United States was one of the last major industrialized nations to establish a social security system. In 1911, Wisconsin passed the first state workers compensation law to be held constitutional. At that time, most Americans believed the government should not have to care for the aged, disabled or needy. But such attitudes ch
Financial Report of Loewen Group Inc.Financial Report of Loewen Group Inc. The Loewen Group Inc. was founded in 1969. The company has two major headquarters in North America, one in Burnaby, British Colombia and a second in Cincinnati, Ohio. Loewen Group Inc. (L.G.I.) is the largest funeral services enterprise in Canada and is the second largest company in the North American Funeral Services Industry. L.G.I. owns 918 funeral homes and 269 cemeteries and also engages in the pre-need selling of funeral services including cemetery and
Lee IacoccaLee Iacocca Lee Iacocca, born Lido Iacocca on October fifteenth 1924, was the son of an Italian immigrant named Nicola Iacocca. He had one sister named Antonette. The family lived in Allentown, Pennsylvania. His father was some what of an entrepreneur in the food service industry. The family business was called the Orpheum Weiner House in Allentown, Pennsylvania. The company is still standing today, operating under the name Yocco\'s, his uncles\' are still making hot dogs for the public. Growing
Should Top Executives Make The Money They Do?Should Top Executives Make The Money They Do? CONTENTS Abstract ........................................................... iii Introduction ....................................................... 1 High Pay Seems Small When Compared To Company Profits .............. 2 Top Executives Are Under A Lot Of Pressure ......................... 3 US Executives Paid Three Times More Than Other Countries For A Reason ..................................................... 4 Pay Should Reflect Performance ..
American Government-EconomicsAmerican Government-Economics American Government-Economics Mid-term Paper Most of the problems of the United states are related to the economy. One of the major issues facing the country today is social security. The United States was one of the last major industrialized nations to establish a social security system. In 1911, Wisconsin passed the first state workers compensation law to be held constitutional. At that time, most Americans believed the government should not have to care for the a
Bubble EconomyBubble Economy The Economy of Japan had experience a tremendous growth since the end of the Korean war. The growth of GNP in 1967 and 1968 was above 10 % (double digit growth period) which exceed countries such as Britain, France and Germany. The economy experienced a boost is due to many reasons, such as: enlargement of industrial facilities, massive adaptation of western technology and education, lower the military expense to 1% of GNP, relation with power nation, human resources and their spi
Canada-U S unemployment rates-why is Canada's so hCanada-U S unemployment rates-why is Canada\'s so high For decades prior to the 1981-82 recession, the national unemployment rates of Canada and the United States had been nearly identical. Since then, a persistent unemployment rate gap has emerged. Throughout most of the 1980s, Canada\'s unemployment rate has consistently been about 2 percentage points higher than in the United States. The gap developed in spite of very similar economic performances across the two countries: the growth rate o
Charles H. KeatingCharles H. Keating Charles H. Keating Jr. has been the focus of criminal investigations by the Federal Bureau of Investigation, the Internal Revenue Service, the Justice Department, The Securities and Exchange Commission, and the House Banking Committee for a six-year shadow of the nation’s biggest savings-and loan debacle. The federal government proclaims that he fraudulently managed California’s Lincoln Savings into its closure, and in the process profited for himself and his family an estimat
Company Insights on BPCompany Insights on BP On August 30, we all chose 5 stocks to evaluate before purchasing. At this time I chose BP AMOCO, Microsoft, Western Digital, Toys-R-Us, and Fortune Financial Incorporated. After a few weeks of tracking these stocks, I chose to keep BP AMOCO, Microsoft, and Western Digital, because the stocks were relatively stable and most of them were on the rise at this time. As you are aware, we were given $30,000.00 to invest in our three chosen stocks, which breaks down to $10,000.00
Describe the roles of government in the present buDescribe the roles of government in the present business envi Business Studies - Essay Q: Describe the roles of government in the present business environment. In the present business environment governments have the power to change and make laws, having a major role and influence on the business environment. There are three levels of government; federal, state and local. The federal government has power over such areas as; company law, income tax, trade etc. State government has power over poll
Financial Analysis of CompanyFinancial Analysis of Company The Loewen Group Inc. was founded in 1969. The company has two major headquarters in North America, one in Burnaby, British Colombia and a second in Cincinnati, Ohio. Loewen Group Inc. (L.G.I.) is the largest funeral services enterprise in Canada and is the second largest company in the North American Funeral Services Industry. L.G.I. owns 918 funeral homes and 269 cemeteries and also engages in the pre-need selling of funeral services including cemetery and cremati
Marketing NotesChapter 1 - Marketing In a ChangingMarketing NotesChapter 1 - Marketing In a Changing WorldWhat is marketing?- Creating customer value and stratification are at the very heart of modernmarketing thinking and practice.Market Defined- Markets always focus at satisfying customers needs- Marketing: A social and managerial process by which individuals and groupsobtain what they need and want through creating exchanging products and valuewith others.- Needs: States of felt deprivation- Wants: Are the form taken by human needs as they a
Players SalariesPlayers Salaries Michael G. Bus law There was a time when men played for the love of the game; when competition alone satisfied the male ego. This age of basketball featured greats such as Wilt Chamberlain, Bill Russell, and Oscar Robinson. These gladiators, and those like them, battled repeatedly winning league championships, MVP’s, scoring titles, and other accolades. Then, the product of James Naismith moved into an era where the love continued, but money was added. Clyde Drexler, Charles Bar
Privatization In RussiaPrivatization In Russia For some, the privatization of Russian industry has been one of the great success stories of Russia’s painful economic transition: quick, firm and radical action was taken to shift the great bulk of Russian industry out of state hands, thereby laying the basis for a radical restructuring of enterprises and improvements in their performance. Others see privatization as a best a failure, at worst a catastrophe. Not surprisingly those opposed to the market and economic refor
Proper business caseproper business case Overview regarding the current situation of AWC Inc. The company that will be analyzed in this report is that of AWC Inc. AWC Inc., is an aluminum manufacturing company located in Southwestern Ontario. The company has been around since 1950, and was founded by Mr. Jim MacDonald, father of the current president Mr. Alex MacDonald. AWC specializes in the fabrication of aluminum windows, doors, storefronts, and curtain wall products. AWC has 100 committed staff with 45 in produ
Purchasing A Small BusinessPurchasing A Small Business Purchasing a Small Business Outline I. Deciding to buy A. Why buy a small business? B. Starting out-the nine steps C. Initial details to consider 1. Are partners needed? 2. Economic factors 3. Is the location acceptable? 4. Tax strategy II. Where to start A. How much income is needed? B. The Thirteen Steps to acquiring a business III. Locating a potential purchase A. The Acquisition Plan B. Beginning the search-who can help? III. Negotiating a purchase price A. Valuat
SHOULD TOP EXECUTIVES MAKE THE MONEY THEY DOSHOULD TOP EXECUTIVES MAKE THE MONEY THEY DO SHOULD TOP EXECUTIVES MAKE THE MONEY THEY DO? Prepared for Prepared by April 4, 1997 CONTENTS Abstract ........................................................................................................... iii Introduction ..................................................................................................... 1 High Pay Seems Small When Compared To Company Profits .......................... 2 Top Executives Are Under A Lot Of Pressu
Constitutionality Of Same Sex MarriageConstitutionality Of Same Sex Marriage The proposed legalization of same-sex marriage is one of the most significant issues in contemporary American family law. Presently, it is one of the most vigorously advocated reforms discussed in law reviews, one of the most explosive political questions facing lawmakers, and one of the most provocative issues emerging before American courts. If same-sex marriage is legalized, it could be one of the most revolutionary policy decisions in the history of Ame
The InternetThe Internet The Internet has an enormous impact on the American Experience. First, It encourages the growth of businesses by providing new ways of advertising products to a large audience, and thus helps companies to publicize their products. Secondly, It allows more Americans to find out what goes on in other countries by learning about other cultures and by exchanging their opinions and ideas with other people worldwide. This may well promote a better global understanding. Finally, by allowin
The American Health Care system has prided itselfHMO The American Health Care system has prided itself on providing high quality services to the citizens who normally cannot afford them. This system has been in place for years and until now it did a fairly decent job. The problem today is money; the cost of hospital services and doctor fees are rising faster than ever before. The government has been trying to come up with a new plan these past few years even though there has been strong opposition against a new Health Care system. There are ma
Interests Of Women.Interests Of Women. This paper will show that many of her most popular beliefs are not only detrimental to society, but also not in the best interests of women. In letters from a war zone, Andrea Dworkin presents a collection of speeches and short articles she has composed during her career as a writer and activist. Many of her articles deal with censorship and pornography. One claim is central to all of these, pornography is an act and not an idea, thus censorship is not relevant to it. In resp
Internet Pro Or ConInternet Pro Or Con Worldwide Disaster: Right at Your Fingertips Internet junkies and world leaders alike are dealing with a phenomenon they do not fully understand; the internet, a vast, ungovernable, intimate, alter-reality, through which, almost anything is possible. Although many acclaim the internet as a harbinger to a new age and extol its virtues as an information source, the internet brings challenges few are ready to face. The versatility of the internet brings these troubles into many
Physician-assisted SuicidePhysician-assisted Suicide Introduction The history of physician-assisted suicide began to emerge since the ancient time. Historians and ancient philosophers especially had been debating over this issue. Thus, this issue is no longer new to us. However, it seems little vague because it has not yet been fully told. The historical story consists of patterns of thought, advocacy, and interpretation on whether to legalize assisted death. Only until June, 1999, the United States Supreme Court issued
Sexual MoralitySexual Morality Sexual Morality Sexuality is an arguable topic among individuals and can be perceived differently from person to person. How ought we view, or sex for the want of a better expression, put it into perspective in our lives? Is it a force whose end is the production of physical pleasure? Is it the procreation of life? Or is it inextricably linked to cultural expressions of love and affection? All of these are valid conceptions of the significance of sex in our everyday lives. Howeve
Should The United States End Drug Prohibition?Should The United States End Drug Prohibition? The Federal Government, while trying to protect us from our human nature, developed harsh anti-drug policies with the hope of eradicating drugs. At the time, these policies seemed simple enough: we will impose penalties on those who use substances illegally, we will intercept drugs coming from other countries while ending all drug cultivation in the States, and we will even try to prevent foreign governments from growing these substances. The idea o
Smokingsmoking Smoking in public places should be illegal, and today, we the affirmative team, will give you many reasons to prove why. People have been smoking cigarettes for hundreds of years, but it wasn\'t until recently that people started to realize exactly how bad cigarette smoking is. It can have a number of negative effects on the smoker, such as - Lung Cancer, Emphysema, Heart Disease etc…Not only can it have these effects on the smoker, but a person who is simply being exposed to the smoke c
Teenage AlcoholismTeenage Alcoholism “What is alcohol? Alcohol is many things to many people: To little kids, it is a curiosity. To teenagers, it is ‘cool’. To responsible drinkers, it is a relaxant. To bartenders, it is a job, their lives. To restaurant owners, it is a moneymaker. To probation officers, it is a frustration. To actively drinking alcoholics, it is heaven. To wives and husbands of drinking alcoholics, it is a waste. To recovering alcoholics, it is a painful old friend. To us, it is something to be
Underage Drinking In America:Underage Drinking In America: It’s Monday night at about 11:30, but I’m doing something different tonight that I haven’t done on a Monday night in a while; I’m staying sober. Yes, I am underage (19 years and 6 months to be exact) and it won’t be until my Junior year of college before I can take my first legal drink in the United States. But I am not the only one who drinks while under the legal age limit; there is an estimated 63% of underage college students that get drunk on a minimum basis of
WorkfareWorkfare : Workfare Society\'s Restraint to Social Reform Of the many chatted words in the social reform vocabulary of Canadians today, the term workfare seems to stimulate much debate and emotion. Along with the notions of self-sufficiency, employability enhancement, and work disincentives, it is the concept of workfare that causes the most tension between it\'s government and business supporters and it\'s anti-poverty and social justice critics. In actuality, workfare is a contraction of the c
Private Cable TVPrivate Cable TV The times are achanging... How France, Germany and Sweden introduced private, cable and satellite TV - a comparison over the past 10 years. 1. INTRODUCTION Why we have chosen this subject? Before starting to write about TV in Sweden, Germany and France, we wanted to compare French,German and Swedish media. But on account of the wideness of this analysis, we decided to focus on the evolution of TV broadcasting during these last 10 years. The technical revolution which has appeare
The Trials of Becoming a HeroThe Trials of Becoming a Hero The Trials of Becoming a Hero Hero worship has existed in this world since the beginning of time, from the Jews honoring Moses, to the Germans honoring Adolf Hitler. Becoming a hero is a very difficult thing to accomplish. One must be successful in gaining the reverence of one\'s peers while at the same time not developing to big of an ego. Two examples of men trying to become heroes are Prince Henry and Dr. Faustus. Both, in their respective plays, have the capabil
Mandatory AIDS TestingMandatory AIDS Testing AIDS has become a worldwide epidemic that has struck every identifiable group. However, persons who are considered to be in a high-risk group of contracting HIV, the disease believed to cause AIDS, are still stigmatized by the media and other professionals as being diseased and abnormal. It is quite surprising still that this type of stereotype still exists now in our gender-bending society. No longer do only gays, prostitutes, bisexual men, intravenous drug users contract
Black HolesBlack Holes Every day we look out upon the night sky, wondering and dreaming of what lies beyond our planet. The universe that we live in is so diverse and unique, and it interests us to learn about all the variance that lies beyond our grasp. Within this marvel of wonders, our universe holds a mystery that is very difficult to understand because of the complications that arise when trying to examine and explore the principles of space. That mystery happens to be that of the ever elusive, black
Software PiracySoftware Piracy What is Software Piracy The PC industry is just over 20 years old. In those 20 years, both the quality and quantity of available software programs have increased dramatically. Although approximately 70% of the worldwide market is today supplied by developers in the United States, significant development work is occurring in scores of nations around the world. But in both the United States and abroad, unauthorized copying of personal computer software is a serious problem. On aver
Computers And FinanceComputers And Finance Computers have made financial bookkeeping much easier, and people no longer have to spend hours tracking investments or pay someone else to do their taxes. Moreover, the advancement in technology has allowed governments to cut back on the number of big companies and employees hired to process tax returns, resulting in the saving of millions of dollars. Although these advancements are extraordinary, they are not without their shortcomings. The IRS has had increased trouble i
A Non-Religious Contract in AmericaA Non-Religious Contract in America The religious standards of Americans today have plummeted to a new low. Fewer people are going to church than earlier in the century. Many people are marrying without even going to a priest by getting a judge to marry them. Divorce is steadily on the rise. Today\'s society accepts homosexuals! Now the issue arises over whether we should allow homosexuals to marry. And you know what? It is really none of the government\'s business. America can no longer deny it
Capital PunishmentCapital Punishment He who sheds the blood of man, by man shall his blood be shed, for in the image of God was man created.(Genesis 9:6) Anyone who by violence causes a death must be put to death.(Exodus 21:12) But should any person dare to kill another with deliberate planning, you will take that person even from my altar to be put to death.(Exodus 21:14) Capital Punishment can be described as a the punishment of death for a very bad or heinous crime like murder. Not all states have got ca
Ethical Values In The Old TestamentEthical Values In The Old Testament BY JOHN G. TAYLOR III RELIGION 205 DR. FRANK JOHNSON 18 NOVEMBER 1996 ETHICAL VALUES IN THE OLD TESTAMENT How we live our lives is governed by ethics. Ethics is “human moral conduct according to principles of what is good or right to do.” Our ethical values today descend primarily from a Christian ethic in which “a truly ethical decision, we are told, must be spontaneous, undirected, free - the individual\'s unfettered and uncoerced response to each new decisi