Can One Perceive Or Confirm The Existence Of An Id
This essay Can One Perceive Or Confirm The Existence Of An Id has a total of 638 words and 3 pages.
Can One Perceive Or Confirm The Existence Of An Idea Or Object That Is External
To Him Mainly - God?
"I think therefore I am." Man wills, refuses, perceives, understands,
and denies many principles. As explained by Rene\' Descartes, man is a thinking
thing, a conscious being who truthfully exists because he is certain that it is
so. All that man perceives is internally present and not external to him or his
mind. The focal point of the third meditation that must be dealt with is: Can
one perceive or confirm the existence of an idea or object that is external to
him mainly - God?
There are three ways, Descartes explains, that one may come to the
conclusion of an objects existence. The first is through nature. The second is
through feeling an object independent of one\'s will, for example; heat and cold.
The third, and most elaborated upon is the point of cause and effect, or more
simply, the objective reality of an idea. We will primarily deal with the third
reason of cause and effect.
Descartes brings some examples to demonstrate his cause and effect
theory. More importantly, is the logic that lies behind the actual theory. The
rationale that an object will have an effect is only if it stems from a
legitimate cause. A stone, for example, cannot be perceived accurately if there
isn\'t an initial idea preceding with equal or superior properties in one\'s
intellect. The mind generates ideas and develops reality through previous
schema or beliefs as Descartes states:
"And although an idea may give rise to another idea, this
regress cannot, nevertheless, be infinite;we must in the
end reach a first idea, the cause of which is, as it were,
the archetype in which all the reality that is found
objectively in these ideas is contained formally."
Additionally, properties such as color, sound, heat, and cold are too
complex in their nature for Descartes to determine whether they are true or
false. In other words, are the ideas that one has about a property true or
false? Consequently, Descartes concludes that there is a common element between
examples like the stone and the cold. The cold portraying the unreal or false
object and the stone as a true object. He contends that they both contain
"substance" like man himself, and are therefore similar.
The only difficulty that arises is the consideration of God\'s existence.
There is no substance or idea for the notion of God to originate from. The
valid question that Descartes asks is: Is it conceivable that a finite being
have the idea of an infinite existence?
We can understand from Descartes writings that he believes in a God.
God is unspeakably great, eternal, independent, and all knowing. What Descartes
deduces is that the nature of an infinite existence cannot be comprehended by a
finite being. Subsequently, by the fact that he believes there is a God is
proof for his existence. The idea was placed there by an outside factor. He
further states that if man is independent of all other existence then he has
the potential to reach to become infinite. This in turn, lead Descartes to say
that if he was the author of his own being and independent of all existence,
then he would be God. By that matter, it is all these points collectively that
indicate to Descartes that he is dependant on another being, that is a God.
It can be argued, very briefly, that Descartes assertion about God is
slightly contradictory. As I stated earlier, an object is perceived in the mind
as long as there are equal or superior properties in the mind. His rests his
whole argument on the basis that one cannot fully grasp or fathom the existence
of God logically. It is obvious that his perception is doubtful in the first
place. There is a lot more material to be covered before I can honestly sever
Descartes\' whole argument, but this is my opinion on the third meditation.
Topics Related to Can One Perceive Or Confirm The Existence Of An Id
Ontology, Ren Descartes, Thought, Rationalists, Epistemology, Cogito ergo sum, Existence of God, Nous, Mind, Existence, Reason, Substance theory
Essays Related to Can One Perceive Or Confirm The Existence Of An Id
Originality of PhilosophyOriginality of Philosophy Feb.25.1997 What is philosophy? What does a philosopher really do? Questions like these can be answered in a review of Philosophy Now. What can possibly be answered.....questions which have them. And what is it that philosophers study? Generally, most philosophers study questions in which there is no rational or justifiable answer. And the type of articles in the magazine are very interesting because they elighten the reader to question the answers. Some of the articles
Lawrence Ferlinghetti's PoliticsLawrence Ferlinghetti\'s Politics I hope I won\'t seem too politically incorrect for saying this but after immersing myself in the writings of the guilt-obsessed asexual Jack Kerouac, the ridiculously horny Allen Ginsberg and the just plain sordid William S. Boroughs... it\'s nice to read a few poems by a guy who can get excited about a little candy store under the El or a pretty woman letting a stocking drop to the floor (“Literary Kicks”). For casual reading, Lawrence Ferlinghetti\'s poetry is
Sociological Theory: Positivistic, Interpretative,Sociological Theory: Positivistic, Interpretative, and Critical Comment on the three types of sociological theories, explain and argue, based on your library or Internet research, which type of theory is the most appropriate theory for sociology to adopt. The three general types of sociological theory are positivistic, interpretive and critical theory.In determining which theory is the most appropriate for sociology to adopt,a basic understanding of each theory\'s strengths and weaknesses is nec
Christianity in Dostoyevsky's Crime and PunishmentChristianity in Dostoyevsky\'s Crime and Punishment: An Overview Fyodor Dostoyevsky wrote, “ If someone succeded in proving to me that Christ was outside the truth, and if, indeed, the truth was outside Christ, then I would sooner remain with Christ than with the truth” (Frank 68). It was by no means easy for Dostoyevsky to reach this conclusion. In Dostoyevsky\'s life, one sees that of an intellectual Prodigal Son, returning to the Father In Heaven only after all other available systems of beli
Existentialism in the Early 19th CenturyExistentialism in the Early 19th Century Major Themes Because of the diversity of positions associated with existentialism, the term is impossible to define precisely. Certain themes common to virtually all existentialist writers can, however, be identified. The term itself suggests one major theme: the stress on concrete individual existence and, consequently, on subjectivity, individual freedom, and choice. Moral Individualism Most philosophers since Plato have held that the highest ethical go
Christianity in Dostśvsky’s CRIME AND PUNISHMENTChristianity in Dostśvsky’s CRIME AND PUNISHMENT Christianity in Dostoyevsky’s Crime and Punishment: An Overview Fyodor Dostoyevsky wrote, “ If someone succeded in proving to me that Christ was outside the truth, and if, indeed, the truth was outside Christ, then I would sooner remain with Christ than with the truth” (Frank 68). It was by no means easy for Dostoyevsky to reach this conclusion. In Dostoyevsky’s life, one sees that of an intellectual Prodigal Son, returning to the Father In Heaven
Existentialism in the early 19th CenturyExistentialism in the early 19th Century Existentialism in the early 19th Century Major Themes Because of the diversity of positions associated with existentialism, the term is impossible to define precisely. Certain themes common to virtually all existentialist writers can, however, be identified. The term itself suggests one major theme: the stress on concrete individual existence and, consequently, on subjectivity, individual freedom, and choice. Moral Individualism Most philosophers since Pl
Gender Trouble: Feminism and The Subversion of IdeGender Trouble: Feminism and The Subversion of Identity A Review/Commentary of GenderTrouble: Feminism and The Subversion of Identity, By Judith Butler Gender, Homosexuality and Ethics Feb. 9/00 Butler, Judith. Gender Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion of Identity. New York: Routledge, 1990. Judith Butler exhibits the new wave of Anglo-American academic feminism, a feminism that goes beyond the delusional categories of male and female, and wishes to confuse or “trouble” these categories all to
Does God Exist?Does God Exist? Introduction We live in a world where millions doubt the existence of God: a world of science and technology in which people only accept what they can prove. Why do these people doubt him and why do others believe so fervently? People have many varied reasons in believing in God. Some need the faith as a comfort to help them in times of loneliness or sadness. For others it gives a sense of purpose or perhaps a pattern on how to live their lives. However for the majority it is an
The Ontology of Gay and Queer The Ontology of Gay and Queer Homosexuality: History, Politics, Ethics April /2001 Table of Contents Introduction………………………………………………….. p. 2-4 Definitions and Genealogy of Homosexuality……………… p. 5- Genealogy of Ontology………………………………………. p. Coming Out of the Closet: Conversion and Inaugeration or Integration……….. p. Genetic Ontology, Social Artifice and Orientations………... p. Conclusion: The Sexual Tower of Babel and Politics of Ontology………………………………. p. -Introduction- In recent years, the gay commu
Seed To Shelf: On Aristotle’s Metaphysics Seed To Shelf: On Aristotle’s Metaphysics Ancient Philosophy 1,564 Words Aristotle’s metaphysics were born of observations of nature, the work of other philosophers, and the teachings of his mentor Plato. Because none of these sources of knowledge agreed with each other Aristotle had to take the best and most logical from each and disregard the rest. Nature influences Aristotle the most; he may be considered the first biologist. Taking into consideration what has learned from all of these sourc
International RelationsInternational Relations The study of international relations has been a contested ground for many decades. A specific indication of this would be explaining or understanding the nature or knowledge of the world. Many theorists from different schools of thought since the 1930’s have debated the contributions made among themselves. The main terminology here initially is the epistemology or ontology of the research among international relations theorists, much confined within the boundaries of soci
The Price of UniversalsThe Price of Universals Skot Crass Metaphysics In H.H. Price\'s work Universals and Resemblances he gives us two possible approaches to the ontological problem of universals: the Philosophy of Universals and the Philosophy of resemblances, both of which I shall approach shortly. However, it seems interesting that Price has neglected Plato\'s doctrine of universalia ante rem due to the thought that no one is willing to accept the idea of Plato\'s transcendental realm of forms. Additionally he has
Anna KareninaAnna Karenina The world of Tolstoy\'s Anna Karenina is a world ruled by chance. From the very opening chapters, where a watchman is accidentally run over by a train at Moscow\'s Petersburg station, to the final, climactic scenes of arbitrary destruction when Levin searches for Kitty in a forest beset by lightning, characters are brought together and forced into action against their will by coincidence and, sometimes, misfortune. That Anna and Vronsky ever meet and begin the fateful affair that b