This essay Anita Hill-Clarence Thomas Hearings has a total of 3368 words and 13 pages.
Anita Hill-Clarence Thomas Hearings
On the surface, the Anita Hill-Clarence Thomas hearings seemed to be relatively simple, wherein a man who was a candidate for one of the country\'s most prestigious positions was challenged by a former co-worker claiming sexual misconduct. It seemed at first to be a story that the American public was somewhat familiar with: politicians and prestigious men have been linked several times before with charges involving sexual misconduct. However, when we get a closer look at the situation, America was seemingly not ready for the incredibly complex debate that ensued; where issues of race, sexuality, class and gender would be addressed, constructed, (mis)used and manipulated. The first question that arises then, is how the American public and various groups of people attempted to untangle such a complex debate. Upon attempting to analyze the elements of the story, we inevitably encounter some serious questions and contradictions that make the extraction of various elements extremely tricky.
In order to effectively provide a conceptual framework that serves to make sense of this complicated situation, I argue that we must look chronologically backwards, and work from the end of the debate to the beginning. The framework of this paper then, will be focused around addressing a set of questions that will attempt to expose and explain the contradictions that arose in the debate, and how sense was made of these (on the surface), by various interest groups.
Having premised this, I will begin at the end with the first set questions: What was the result of the situation, and why? How did Clarence Thomas succeed in coming out the victor of such adverse circumstances? To answer this question we must revisit an entire history that became an important feature in debate, and was called upon to reshape the framework.
Although admittedly somewhat awkward, starting at the end point of this debate will allow the complexities of the entire story to unfold in such a way that will serve to uncover and re-emphasize the mutually constituting categories of race, class and sexuality.
As a starting point, what proved to be an especially fascinating moment of the proceedings was how Thomas chose to deal with Hill\'s allegations. This incredibly deliberate move served to reframe the story, and became the crucial moment that arguably forced Hill to be conceptually paralyzed and thus written out of the story. When we look at this particular part of the debate, two important contradictions become undeniably obvious. One, Thomas misused the lynching narrative by applying it to a situation with a black woman, and two, he played the "race card" even though he was an "individualist" and had historically distanced himself from the race. Paradoxically, he won the support of the vast majority of African Americans despite the fact that he was doing a great disservice to the community: reducing himself solely to a raced individual, emphasizing that one must fall back on race if backed into a corner, and not on his own personal (good and honorable) character. Equally important to look at is why and how these contradictions did not surface in the public reception of Thomas\'s response, and how Anita Hill became invisible.
When Thomas paralleled the situation with a lynching, and chose to use the language of racism and oppression, he successfully masked one of the most important contradictions in his argument. Anita Hill was a black woman and not a white woman entirely disturbs Thomas\' play on the lynching image. As someone who was familiar with this narrative, Thomas ignored the fact that lynching rested upon the (supposed) relationship of white women and black men. Sexual exchanges between black men and black women were not even considered or given a second look because they were both seen as sexually deviant. In fact, what was really lying at the core of the lynching narrative was the roles available to black women, and their binary opposition to white women. Paula Giddings expands on this in her essay, "The Last Taboo" (Morrison, p. 451):
At the epitome of the immorality, pathology, and impurity of the age, black women were seen in dualistic opposition to their upper-class, pure, and passionless white sisters. It was this binary opposition of women (black men\'s sex drives were not seen as inherently different than
Topics Related to Anita Hill-Clarence Thomas Hearings
Clarence Thomas, Conservatism in the United States, Gullah, Lynching, Lynching in the United States, Black feminism
Essays Related to Anita Hill-Clarence Thomas Hearings
Sexual HarassmentSexual Harassment Sexual harassment is not about sex, it is about power. -Gretchen Morgenson An unwanted sexual advance, an offensive touch, and suggestive comments illustrate examples of sexual harassment. Sexual harassment is defined by Stephanie Riger as, unwanted sexually oriented behavior in a work context. However, sexual harassment does not only appear in an occupational environment, and this form of harassment is not limited to a specific race, a specific gender, or any certain lifes
The Communication Decency Act: The Fight For FreedThe Communication Decency Act: The Fight For Freedom of Speech on the Internet The Communication Decency Act is a bill which has insulted our right as American citizens. It a bill which SHOULD not pass. I\'ll share with you how Internet users are reacting to this bill, and why they say it is unconstitutional. Some individuals disagree with one part of the bill. According to http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/ query/z?c104:s.652.enr:, which has the Communications Decency Act on-line for public viewing
Judicial ChoicesJudicial Choices Supreme Court conformations, much like everything else in politics and life, changed over the years. Conformations grew from insignificant and routine appointments to vital and painstakingly prolonged trials, because of the changes in the political parties and institutions. The parties found the Supreme Court to be a tool for increasing their power, which caused an increased interest in conformations. The change in the Senate to less hierarchical institution played part to the s
Gays: A Struggle for AcceptanceGays: A Struggle for Acceptance When the dust settles and the pages of history are written, it will not be the angry defenders of intolerance who have made the difference, that reward will go to those who dared to step outside the safety of their privacy in order to expose and rout the prevailing prejudice. - John Shelby Spong Episcopal Bishop of the Diocese of Newark, NJ November 21, 1996 During World War II and especially the twenty years after brought great political and social changes to t
Sexual HarassmentSexual Harassment The sexual harassment allegations filed by Professor Anita Hill against ClarenceThomas and the proceeding Senate Judiciary Hearing thrust the issue of sexual harassment into the political arena, the workplace, and every day life. Introduction Sexual harassment is a very broad term and can be interpreted in a variety of ways. The National Organization of Women (NOW) defines sexual harassment as any repeated or unwarranted verbal or physical advance, sexually explicit derogator
An Objection to Mandatory Drug Testing in High Sch An Objection to Mandatory Drug Testing in High Schools for the Participation of Extra-Curricular Activities: Primarily Student Athletes For LA: 401: Science, Technology, and Human Values Spring, 2004 Introduction With the recent steroid a scandal in Major League Baseball, debates over mandatory drug testing polices have sparked interest across the country. One issue that is highly controversial, but has taken a back seat in the in the debate, is the issue of mandatory drug testing policies in h
Clarence ThomasClarenceThomasClarenceThomas is one of the most arrogant, opinionated congressmen to ever serve on Congress. But, luckily he is also one of the most brilliant congressmen to ever serve on Congress. In this biography hopefully the reader will leave feeling satisfied that I have provided satisfactory documentation to back up these two bold statements. It is the opinion of many that ClarenceThomas is just a horny, selfish and typical congressman. I feel that it is up to me to justify why th
Colin FergusonColin Ferguson Colin Ferguson 2 It was an average Tuesday evening, December 7, 1993, when a group of commuters on a Long Island Rail Road car came face to face with the sort of terror most people see only on television. Without warning, a Jamaican immigrant named Colin Ferguson pulled out a pistol and started firing at random, killing 6 passengers and wounding 19. After Ferguson was convicted and before he was sentenced, the survivors of his attack and the relatives of his victims got a rare cha
The Kenneth Star ReportThe Kenneth Star Report The Kenneth Starr report on President Clinton has been going on for awhile now. This is not a one-time incident for Clinton. Scandals involving the president have been appearing as far back as he was governor of Arkansas. His newest scandal involved a White House Intern named Monica Lewinsky. It wouldn’t be such big news by itself but she was involved in a grand jury trial involving the president. In which she testified in favor of the president. Everyday new skeletons fr
Anita Hill-Clarence Thomas HearingsAnita Hill-ClarenceThomas Hearings On the surface, the Anita Hill-ClarenceThomas hearings seemed to be relatively simple, wherein a man who was a candidate for one of the country\'s most prestigious positions was challenged by a former co-worker claiming sexual misconduct. It seemed at first to be a story that the American public was somewhat familiar with: politicians and prestigious men have been linked several times before with charges involving sexual misconduct. However, when we get a clo
The Myth of the Plague of Sexual HarassmentThe Myth of the Plague of Sexual Harassment One of the most talked-about issues of the past few years has been the issue of sexual harassment, and it supposed prevalence in all workplaces. Pushed to the national spotlight by the Anita Hill-ClarenceThomas hearings, in which Ms. Hill accused her boss Justice Thomas of sexual harassment, it has become popular belief that sexual harassment occurs in all workplaces, and that the vast majority of female office -workers have been sexually harassed. Fe
Development of the United States of AmericaDevelopment of the United States of America Many peoples have contributed to the development of the United States of America, a vast nation that arose from a scattering of British colonial outposts in the New World. The first humans to inhabit the North American continent were migrants from northeast Asia who established settlements in North America as early as 8000 BC and possibly much earlier (see NORTH AMERICAN ARCHAEOLOGY). By about AD 1500 the native peoples of the areas north of the Rio Gr
Affirmative ActionAffirmative Action Close your eyes, now imagine a world of love; not hate, a world of equality; not preference. Now, imagine a colorblind society. That is what most of American society wants. That is the reason Affirmative Action was birthed by Lyndon B. Johnson in 1964. That is also the reason that Proposition 209 was voted for in 1996. These two historical events are driven by the desire of equality. What is Affirmative Action? According to Geraldine Leshin, it is Taking positive or active st
CreationismCreationism Traditionally creationism has roots in many religions. There are various forms of creationism in many cultures. One of the most popular tenets in cultures around the world are variation of pair of male and female that parent the entire earth of humans. They indicate generally that there is first cause of humans and animals, usually as a result of an omnipotent being. The Christian version of creationism, that preach God as the sole creator of everything, and that everything that we s
Sexual HarassmentSexual Harassment The multimillion-dollar awards made by juries in sexual harassment cases suggests that people are overreacting to the problem, and lawyers are taking advantage of these profitable cases (Glazer). Sexual harassment is hard to define, easy to allege, and very costly to wealthy companies. Many people allege that they have been sexually harassed, but where is the line drawn in a changing society with morals differing from person to person. What’s offensive to one is totally accepta
DiscriminationDiscrimination The struggle for social and economic equality of Black people in America has been long and slow. It is sometimes amazing that any progress has been made in the racial equality arena at all; every tentative step forward seems to be diluted by losses elsewhere. For every Stacey Koons that is convicted, there seems to be a Texaco executive waiting to send Blacks back to the past. Throughout the struggle for equal rights, there have been courageous Black leaders at the forefront of
Judical LawJudical Law In 1717, Bishop Hoadly told King George I, Whoever hath an absolute authority to interpret written or spoken laws; it is he who is truly the lawgiver to all intents and purposes and not the person who wrote or spoke them (Pollack, 153). Early sentiments similar these have blossomed in to a large scale debate over which branch of our government has the power to overturn laws that do not follow the foundations of our democratic system; the constitution. In this paper I will discuss t
Jack the RipperJack the Ripper Jack the Ripper was a serial murderer in Whitechapel, London, Englan in the year 1888. From August 31 to Nonember 9, Jack killed five women. In this horrific 10 week period, he murdered five prostitutes, all in a mile area that involed the districts of Whitechapel, Spitalfields, Aldgate and the City of London proper. All ranged in age from their late teens to theri early seventies. He raped the women and they were all found nude in a road, except for one who was found in her hous
Computer CrimeComputer Crime Computer crime is a very broad term. It could mean anything from a total invasion by a hacker into the federal government or just the simple fact of one person letting another borrow a copy of his favorite flying game. Computers are defined in the dictionary as a machine that computes (WBD vol. 23). But to most people it is a machine that\'s helps us do a task easier. As we move into the 21th century though one thing is for sure, the computer will help crime become more prevalent.