This essay Analysis of Crito has a total of 421 words and 2 pages.
Analysis of Crito
The question is raised within the dialogue between Socrates and Crito
concerning civil disobedience. Crito has the desire, the means, and many
compelling reasons with which he tries to convince the condemned to acquiesce in
the plan to avoid his imminent death. Though Crito\'s temptation is imposing, it
is in accord with reason and fidelity that Socrates chooses to fulfill his
obligation to the state, even to death.
Before addressing Crito\'s claims which exhort Socrates to leave the
state and avoid immanent death, the condemned lays a solid foundation upon which
he asserts his obligation to abide by the laws. The foundation is composed of
public opinion, doing wrong, and fulfillment of one\'s obligations. Addressing
public opinion, Socrates boldly asserts that it is more important to follow the
advice of the wise and live well than to abide by the indiscriminate and
capricious public opinion and live poorly. Even when it is the public who may
put one to death, their favor need not be sought, for it is better to live well
than to submit to their opinion and live poorly. Next, wrongful doing is
dispatched of. They both consent to the idea that, under no circumstances, may
one do a wrong, even in retaliation, nor may one do an injury; doing the latter
is the same as wrong doing. The last foundation to be questioned is the
fulfillment of one\'s obligations. Both of the philosophers affirm that,
provided that the conditions one consents to are legitimate, one is compelled to
fulfill those covenants. These each are founded upon right reasoning and do
provide a justifiable foundation to discredit any design of dissent.
At line fifty, Socrates executes these foundations to destroy and make
untenable the petition that he may rightfully dissent:
Then consider the logical consequence. If we leave this place without
first persuading the state to let us go, are we or are we not doing an injury,
and doing it in a quarter where it is least justifiable? Are we or are we not
abiding by our just agreements?
To criticize or reproach Socrates\' decision to accept his punishment is
unjustifiable in most of the arguments. The only point of disagreement with
Socrates\' logic concerns his assertion, “expressed” in his dialogue with the
laws, that the state is to be more respected than one\'s parents. I contend that
one would never willingly oblige himself to a totalitarian state in which the
laws and the magistrates are to be regarded more highly than one\'s own family.
One would only contract with a government whose power insures the public good
and whose establishment seeks the to extend to its citizens utilitarian needs.
Topics Related to Analysis of Crito
Socratic dialogues, Dialogues of Plato, Crito, Ancient Greek philosophers, Socrates, Ethics, Trial of Socrates, Socrates on Trial
Essays Related to Analysis of Crito
PlatoPlato Plato, the philosopher, centered his thoughts around the soul, which to him was the principal of life and movement. The immortal wisdom of Plato, is the guidance in which ethical theory and philosophy take root. His mentor was the great philosopher, Socrates. Plato, took the Socratic point of view and developed his main philosophy, which was the philosophy of the soul. THE LIFE OF PLATO Early Life Plato was born in 427 B.C.E. into a wealthy family that was both aristocratic and politically
THE LIFE OF PLATO THE LIFE OF PLATO Plato was born in 427 B.C. into a wealthy family that was both aristocratic and politically influential. His family had a rich history of political connections and consisted of his parents, Ariston and Perictione, his older brothers Adeimantus and Glawcon, and later a younger sister, Potone. “In keeping with his family heritage, Plato was destined for the political life”(Beavers and Planeaux). During Platos early years he was instructed by eminent teachers in grammar, music, a
Socrates Socrates Intro Philosophy Spring 2004 1 Socrates Socrates was born in 469 B.C. and died in 399 B.C. He was a Greek philosopher of Athens and is generally considered as one of the wisest people of all times. He was the son of Sophroniscus, a sculptor, and Phaenarete, a midwife. During the early part of his life, he seems to have followed in his father\'s footsteps, working as a sculptor. Socrates served in the military but never wanted any important position in the army. Most of the findings of