This essay A Review Of A People’s History Of has a total of 1221 words and 9 pages.
A Review Of A People’s History Of
A Review of A People’s History of
The United States
A People’s History of the United States concentrates on the personal experiences
and struggles of people who lived in the United States from 1492-present. It is a view of
history from the common man’s perspective, rather than the view of the leaders and
upper class of this country.
The book revolves around the views of history from the oppressed point of view.
Howard Zinn makes it clear from the beginning that he will value the views and
experiences of the oppressed over the view of the oppressor. He describes the conquest
from the point of view of the Native American population. He describes slavery in the
south from the point of view of the slave. He describes industrialization from the point of
view of the workers on the shop floor. He describes World War II from the point of view
of the soldiers on the front lines. He describes the Vietnam War from the point of
view of the Vietnamese. You have to realize that these are his views of history as he sees
them, and is only one side of the story.
There is no such thing as unbiased, balanced, truthful history. History is in the eye
of the teller. In this case, Howard Zinn’s view of the history of this great country is
extremely Marxist. He seems to pick and choose historical data that fits his agenda in an
attempt to evoke an emotional response from the reader. He does make some good points
pertaining to injustices and misconceptions regarding the idealistic view of history, but
unrealistic perceptions are made of the founding and progress of this country. You have
to ask yourself, which is more important, that Columbus made his way to America or
that he treated the Indians horribly when he got here ? Which is more important,
that the Declaration of Independence states, that “all men are created equal” or the fact
that the author of the Declaration owned hundreds of slaves?
Zinn seems to argue that we cannot end evils like genocide, exploitation, and
abuse until we “face” them ... drag them into the light of day. To that point we are in
complete agreement. But, the very heart of Zinn\'s “history” is distorted. To use the two
most obvious examples; he condemns Columbus for genocide and America for slavery.
However, on the genocidal religious practices of Native Americans and on the African
elements of the international black slave trade, Zinn is virtually silent. That silence is a
crime of sorts. It is a crime because it distorts the truth rather than advances it and justice
cannot be had by any means other than the truth. If Zinn wants justice he needs to face
the truth and to face it he has to be willing to look for it. In my opinion he has attempted
nothing of the sort in this book.
Zinn\'s interpretation of the motivations of the founders with respect to the
Constitution and the Bill of Rights are inaccurate. For example, if you knew nothing
about the Constitution and the Bill of Rights, Zinn would have you believe that they were
merely the results of a clever ploy by the rich landowners. To “buy” enough support from
the middle class to assure continuation of the system that kept the rich, wealthy. You
would not know that these documents and the ideas they reflect have been profoundly
important not only in the United States, but also throughout the world.
In my opinion his history of the Cold War is wrong as well. In reading about the
Cold War, one would emerge from Zinn\'s account believing that the U.S. government
had driven the arms race throughout the 1970s and 1980s. In his view the Soviets, it
seems, had no role in all of this. Zinn fails to mention that after the end of the Cold War,
what emerged from Soviet and then Russian sources strongly corroborated most of the
United States views on the Cold War. The Soviet missiles were real; they’re potential to
conquer Europe with their massive army was real as well. They’re military expenditures
were, in fact, much higher in terms of the burden they
Topics Related to A Review Of A People’s History Of
Counterculture of the 1960s, America: Imagine the World Without Her, Films, Howard Zinn, Vietnam War, A Peoples History of the United States
Essays Related to A Review Of A People’s History Of
Expectancies As A Predictor Of Adolescent AlcoholExpectancies As A Predictor Of Adolescent Alcohol Use INTRODUCTION This paper examines the use of an idea referred to as expectancy as a predictor of teen alcohol use. Expectancies are concepts that a society reinforces which go on to influence a person\'s behavior. Current clinical and field studies show that alcohol expectancies are reasonably accurate tools in estimating future drinking patterns. This paper sets out to determine the practical applications of this knowledge in the real classro
The Hippie Movement That Arose From Vast PoliticalThe Hippie Movement That Arose From Vast Political Changes Massive black rebellions, constant strikes, gigantic anti-war demonstrations, draft resistance, Cuba, Vietnam, Algeria, a cultural revolution of seven hundred million Chinese, occupations, red power, the rising of women, disobedience and sabotage, communes & marijuana: amongst this chaos, there was a generation of youths looking to set their own standard - to fight against the establishment, which was oppressing them, and leave their mar
Lsd And Mainstream 1960s MediaLsd And Mainstream 1960s Media Despite the negative portrayal in mainstream 1960s media, justifications expressed by counterculture activists for further investigation, education and experimentation under government control of LSD were rational and valid arguments. Sex, drugs, protests, war, political upheaval, cultural chaos, and social rebellion; the many comforts TV dinner eating, republican voting, church going, suburbia conformists tried to escape through conservative ideals, town meetings,
Chapter 41: “The Stormy Sixties”Chapter 41: “The Stormy Sixties” 1960 – 1968 I. Kennedy’s “New Frontier” Spirit 1. In 1960, young, energetic John F. Kennedy was elected to president of the United States—the youngest man ever elected to that office. 2. The 1960s would bring a sexual revolution, a civil rights revolutions, the emergence of a “youth culture,” a devastating war in Vietnam, and the beginnings of a feminist revolution. 3. JFK delivered a stirring inaugural address, and he also assembled a very young cabinet, includi
Final History ExamFinal History Exam 1.List the reasons the US got involved in World War I: The Germans ignored Wilsons calls for peace, resumed unrestricted submarine warfare, announcing that their U-boats would sink all ships in British waters - hostile or neutral - on sight. Then the German foreign minister sent a telegram, nicknamed the Zimmermann note to the German ambassador in Mexico. This telegram proposed an alliance between Mexico Germany promised that if the war with the US broke out, Germany would sup
The Deadhead PhenomenonThe Deadhead Phenomenon “If a man does not keep pace with his companions, perhaps it is because he hears a different drummer. Let him step to the music which he hears, however measured or far away.” - Henry David Thoreau In 1967, Timothy Leary persuaded America’s youth to “tune in, turn on, and drop out.” Thousands of young adults literally heard the “far away music” and, to the dismay of their parents, marched away. America’s children grew their hair, burned their bras and draft cards and perma
History of CaliforniaHistory of California When the first Europeans arrived, in the early 16th century, the region of California was inhabited by a relatively sparse Indian population, scattered in many small, fairly independent groups hat lived mainly as hunter-gatherers. Among the Indian groups were the Hupa, Pomo, Wishosk, and Yuki, in the north; the Costano, Miwok, Salinan, and Yokut, in the center; the Mono and Panamint, in the east; and the Chumash, Serrano, and Diegueno, in the south. Juan Rodriguez Cabrillo,