A Brief Comment on the Query "Is Socrates Guilty As Charged"
This essay A Brief Comment on the Query "Is Socrates Guilty As Charged" has a total of 1095 words and 5 pages.
A Brief Comment on the Query: "Is Socrates Guilty As Charged?"
In any case of law, when one is considering truth and justice, one must
first look at the validity of the court and of the entity of authority itself.
In Socrates case, the situation is no different. One may be said to be guilty or
not of any said crime, but the true measure of guilt or innocence is only as
valid as the court structure to which it is subject to. Therefore, in
considering whether Socrates is 'guilty or not', we must keep in mind the
societal norms and standards of Athens at the time, and the legitimacy of his
accusers and the validity of the crimes that he allegedly committed. Having said
this, we must first look at the affidavit of the trial, what exactly Socrates
was being accused with: "Socrates does injustice and is meddlesome, by
investigating the things under the earth and the heavenly things, and by
making the weaker speech the stronger, and by teaching others these same
things."1 In breaking this charge down, we see that it is two-fold.
Firstly, Socrates is charges with impiety, a person who does not believe in the
state gods of Athens and, not only that, but by its literal meaning, does not
believe in the authority of gods at all. To this, Socrates seems baffled. He
states that the reason behind the 'criminal meddling', the questioning of
people's wisdom, was commissioned to him by the gods through the Oracle of
Delphi. As Socrates said, "...but when god stationed me, as I supposed and
assumed, ordering me to live philosophizing and examining myself and
others...that my whole care is to commit no unjust or impious deed."2He even
seems to win a victory over one of his accusers, Meletus, in questioning this
point. As Socrates points out, it is impossible for him to be both atheistic and
to believe in demons, or false gods, for if he believes in the latter, then that
would contradict his not believing in gods at all (since even demons are
considered to be at least demi-gods).
The second part of the charge was that Socrates was attacking the very
fabric of the Athenian society by corrupting its citizens, namely the youth. In
other words, Meletus and the other accusers are accusing Socrates of a crime of
'non-conformity' - instead of bowing to those who are held in places of
authority and those who have reputations of being wise, Socrates believes that
it is his role in life to question these people in their wisdom, and to expose
those who claim that they are knowledgeable and wise, but who really are not.
This nation of questioning the legitimacy of those in power would certainly not
be called a 'crime' by today's standards, nor would it really have in Athenian
time. The true nature of this charge was vengeance carried out on the part of
the power-holders of Athenian society: the politicians, poets, manual artisans.
Socrates, in effect, made fools out of these people, exposing their speeches are
mere rhetoric than actual wisdom and knowledge. By being a teacher as such, but
never collecting any fees and therefore innocent from profiting from such
ventures, he was said to have been corrupting and citizens of Athens into
believing that these so-called people of wisdom were not actually wise at all.
As Socrates says, "...and this is what will convict me, if it does convict me:
not Meletus of Antyus, but the envy and slander of the many. This has convicted
many other good men too, and I suppose it will also convict me. And there is no
danger that it will stop me."3 Another point to be made is that
Socrates proves that if what he has done has actually been corrupting society,
and could be considered a crime, then he has not caused any harm voluntarily. In
any criminal charge, the fact of the accused's mens rea, or 'guilty mind', would
be compulsory to prove on a guilty charge. But Socrates states that, at least
for him, voluntarily corrupting any human being would simply be impossible,
"...I am not even cognizant that if I ever do something wretched to any of my
associates, I will risk getting back something bad from him?"4 Although his
'guilty mind' was never proved, Socrates does realize that he will be found
guilty of this charge, although he does say that justly this would never have
been a criminal charge, but could have been dealt with privately, "...and if I
corrupt involuntarily, the law is not that you
Topics Related to A Brief Comment on the Query "Is Socrates Guilty As Charged"
Socratic dialogues, Dialogues of Plato, Socrates, Ancient Greek philosophers, Apology, Meletus, Plato, Theory of Forms, Trial of Socrates, Socrates on Trial
Essays Related to A Brief Comment on the Query "Is Socrates Guilty As Charged"
PlatoPlato Plato, the philosopher, centered his thoughts around the soul, which to him was the principal of life and movement. The immortal wisdom of Plato, is the guidance in which ethical theory and philosophy take root. His mentor was the great philosopher, Socrates. Plato, took the Socratic point of view and developed his main philosophy, which was the philosophy of the soul. THE LIFE OF PLATO Early Life Plato was born in 427 B.C.E. into a wealthy family that was both aristocratic and politically
THE LIFE OF PLATO THE LIFE OF PLATO Plato was born in 427 B.C. into a wealthy family that was both aristocratic and politically influential. His family had a rich history of political connections and consisted of his parents, Ariston and Perictione, his older brothers Adeimantus and Glawcon, and later a younger sister, Potone. “In keeping with his family heritage, Plato was destined for the political life”(Beavers and Planeaux). During Platos early years he was instructed by eminent teachers in grammar, music, a
Socrates Socrates Intro Philosophy Spring 2004 1 Socrates Socrates was born in 469 B.C. and died in 399 B.C. He was a Greek philosopher of Athens and is generally considered as one of the wisest people of all times. He was the son of Sophroniscus, a sculptor, and Phaenarete, a midwife. During the early part of his life, he seems to have followed in his father\'s footsteps, working as a sculptor. Socrates served in the military but never wanted any important position in the army. Most of the findings of
Plato was born to Ariston and Perictione a year af Plato was born to Ariston and Perictione a year after Pericles died. He had three brothers Glaucon, Adeimantus, and Antiphon his half-brother. He was most popularly known as a student and teacher to only the best, Socrates and Aristotle respectively, Plato was also known as a writer during the fourth century B.C.E. Like many of Socrates' students, Plato stove to live his life like him. Due to the tremendous influence that Socrates had on Plato, in many of his writings Socrates played the main c